Only 5 left and in 14 carts
  • Baseball Cupcake Toppers | Personalized with face | 2.9 inch| Party Decorations | Rookie of the Year | Party Theme | 1st Birthday Idea image 1
  • May include: Six cupcakes with white frosting and colorful sprinkles. Each cupcake is topped with a baseball-themed cutout featuring a smiling child holding a bat. The cupcakes have a yellow cake base.
  • May include: Six cupcakes with white frosting and colorful sprinkles. Each cupcake is topped with a baseball-themed cutout featuring a child holding a bat. The background is a solid bright blue.
  • May include: Cupcakes with white frosting and colorful sprinkles, topped with baseball-themed cutouts featuring a smiling child in a baseball uniform. Baseball bat and ball decorations are also visible, along with a red helmet and blue cups.
  • May include: Cupcakes topped with white frosting and colorful sprinkles. Each cupcake has a baseball-themed topper featuring a smiling child in a baseball uniform holding a bat. The cupcakes are in paper liners.
  • May include: Six cupcakes with white frosting and colorful sprinkles. Each cupcake is topped with a baseball-themed cutout featuring a child holding a bat. The cupcakes sit on a yellow surface.
  • May include: A promotional image for Neon Pink Shop, showcasing photo editing services. The image features a before-and-after comparison of a child's photo, highlighting background removal and design additions. Text includes "We crop the photos for you."
  • May include: A pink graphic with the text "Neon Pink Shop" and "When will I receive my items?" It details shipping options: USPS First Class, Priority Mail, and Express. Includes reminders about processing times and delivery dates.
  • May include: A collage of four pink and white graphics with the phrases "WE DESIGN", "WE CREATE", "WE PACKAGE", and "WE SHIP". Each graphic includes a disco ball, lightning bolt, and heart. The "WE SHIP" graphic features a pink delivery truck.
  • May include: Pink graphic with text "WE SHIP WORLDWIDE!" and "WE HAVE SHIPPED TO ALL 50 STATES!" Flags of various countries are displayed. A pink map of the USA is shown. The image includes hearts and a disco ball.
  • May include: A collection of baseball-themed party decorations and cupcake toppers. The image includes cupcake toppers with a baby's face, baseball-themed banners, and baseball-shaped confetti. Text on the banner reads "ROOKIE OF THE YEAR".
  • Baseball Cupcake Toppers | Personalized with face | 2.9 inch| Party Decorations | Rookie of the Year | Party Theme | 1st Birthday Idea image 12
  • Baseball Cupcake Toppers | Personalized with face | 2.9 inch| Party Decorations | Rookie of the Year | Party Theme | 1st Birthday Idea image 1
  • Product video
  • May include: Six cupcakes with white frosting and colorful sprinkles. Each cupcake is topped with a baseball-themed cutout featuring a smiling child holding a bat. The cupcakes have a yellow cake base.
  • May include: Six cupcakes with white frosting and colorful sprinkles. Each cupcake is topped with a baseball-themed cutout featuring a child holding a bat. The background is a solid bright blue.
  • May include: Cupcakes with white frosting and colorful sprinkles, topped with baseball-themed cutouts featuring a smiling child in a baseball uniform. Baseball bat and ball decorations are also visible, along with a red helmet and blue cups.
  • May include: Cupcakes topped with white frosting and colorful sprinkles. Each cupcake has a baseball-themed topper featuring a smiling child in a baseball uniform holding a bat. The cupcakes are in paper liners.
  • May include: Six cupcakes with white frosting and colorful sprinkles. Each cupcake is topped with a baseball-themed cutout featuring a child holding a bat. The cupcakes sit on a yellow surface.
  • May include: A promotional image for Neon Pink Shop, showcasing photo editing services. The image features a before-and-after comparison of a child's photo, highlighting background removal and design additions. Text includes "We crop the photos for you."
  • May include: A pink graphic with the text "Neon Pink Shop" and "When will I receive my items?" It details shipping options: USPS First Class, Priority Mail, and Express. Includes reminders about processing times and delivery dates.
  • May include: A collage of four pink and white graphics with the phrases "WE DESIGN", "WE CREATE", "WE PACKAGE", and "WE SHIP". Each graphic includes a disco ball, lightning bolt, and heart. The "WE SHIP" graphic features a pink delivery truck.
  • May include: Pink graphic with text "WE SHIP WORLDWIDE!" and "WE HAVE SHIPPED TO ALL 50 STATES!" Flags of various countries are displayed. A pink map of the USA is shown. The image includes hearts and a disco ball.
  • May include: A collection of baseball-themed party decorations and cupcake toppers. The image includes cupcake toppers with a baby's face, baseball-themed banners, and baseball-shaped confetti. Text on the banner reads "ROOKIE OF THE YEAR".
  • Baseball Cupcake Toppers | Personalized with face | 2.9 inch| Party Decorations | Rookie of the Year | Party Theme | 1st Birthday Idea image 12
Report this item to Etsy

Baseball Cupcake Toppers | Personalized with face | 2.9 inch| Party Decorations | Rookie of the Year | Party Theme | 1st Birthday Idea

Neon Pink Shop Team

Made by Neon Pink Shop Team

Owner of NeonPinkShop

Please select an option

Please select an option

  • Please double check the estimated arrival dates before checkout. If you have read this message you can type "ok"

    0/256
  • Upload your photo/photos here

    We will crop the photos for you and add the cowboy design.

    Select up to 2 files
    Files must follow Etsy’s content rules

What to know

⚾ PERSONALIZED BASEBALL CUPCAKE TOPPERS
Welcome to our shop! We’re excited to create something special for your celebration.

✨ PRODUCT DETAILS
Each cupcake topper features your uploaded face photo customized onto a baseball player batting design. We crop the photos for you, add your face to the baseball player, and professionally create the cupcake toppers for your event.

📏 SIZE
• Approximately 2.5–2.8 inches

🛒 HOW TO ORDER
Select Quantity
Choose the total number of cupcake toppers you would like.
Select Number of Faces
You may choose up to 2 different photos per order.
If 2 faces are selected, the toppers will be split evenly between the uploaded photos.

Please review all estimated arrival dates before placing your order.
⚠️ IMPORTANT SHIPPING INFORMATION
Please ensure your event date is NOT within the estimated delivery window. We strongly recommend ordering early to allow time for production and possible carrier delays due to weather, holidays, or shipping disruptions.
Shipping Options
Multiple shipping options may be available at checkout.

Please note:
• Processing time remains the same.
• Shipping upgrades only speed up delivery once your order has shipped.

Upload Photos
Click the (+) upload button to upload your images.
• 1 face = upload 1 photo
• 2 faces = upload 2 photos
For best results, please upload clear, high-quality photos with good lighting.

⚾ PLEASE NOTE
We crop and customize all photos to fit the design style. Face placement and crop positioning may vary slightly depending on the photo provided.
If you have any questions, feel free to send us a message through Etsy Messages and we’ll be happy to help!

View full item details

What buyers say

Summarized by AI from all item reviews

4.9 (58)
Looks great Love it Great quality Helpful seller As described Fast shipping Perfect gift
View all item reviews

NowPrice:$11.25+

Original Price: $12.50+

10% off

•

Sale ends on September 2

Shipping & return policies

  • Order today to get by Aug 8-18
  • Returns & exchanges not accepted.
  • Ships from: Sumter, SC
  • Cost to ship: $5.40
    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.
  • Deliver to United States, 43215

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Star Seller

This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.

Etsy's Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases. View program terms

Etsy invests in climate solutions

Like electric trucks and carbon offsets for every delivery. View more

Reviews for this item

4.9

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(58 reviews)

4.9 Item quality
4.9 Shipping
4.9 Customer service
98% Buyers recommend

What buyers say

Summarized by AI from all item reviews

Looks great Love it Great quality Helpful seller As described Fast shipping Perfect gift

Filter by category
5 out of 5 stars 5

Landry Aug 1, 2026

These turned out amazing! I was unsure how my picture would look on the topper but it was absolutely perfect! Great quality as well

Landry Aug 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5

Catherine Jul 25, 2026

We absolutely love these! Can’t wait to use them for his birthday party!

Catherine Jul 25, 2026

Response from Neon Pink Shop Team

Thank you Catherine! So glad the baseball cupcake toppers were a win!

5 out of 5 stars 5

Kaitlyn Jul 14, 2026

these are so cute!

Kaitlyn Jul 14, 2026

Response from Neon Pink Shop Team

We love this photo! Thank you for sharing Kaitlyn. We are so glad you liked the baseball birthday cupcake toppers.

5 out of 5 stars 5

Etsy buyer Jul 12, 2026

Item arrived even before expected shipping time, great customer service !

Etsy buyer Jul 12, 2026

Response from Neon Pink Shop Team

Thank you. We are so glad you had a great experience shopping with us.

Photos from reviews

Meet your seller

NeonPinkShop
Neon Pink Shop Team
NeonPinkShop ·

South Carolina, United States

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9
·
78.6k sales
·
5 years on Etsy
Kelsey Brittany Kirstyn
3 shop members

Usually responds in a few hours

Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

View shop registration details

You may also like

Explore related searches

Sandlot Birthday Banner

Rookie Year Party

Rookie of the Year Birthday

Baseball Theme Birthday

Rookie of the Year

Baseball Birthday Decor

Baseball Birthday Party

Baseball Party Decor

Rookie of the Year Decor

Baseball Party Favors

Baseball Cupcakes

Baseball Cupcake Toppers

Listed on Aug 3, 2026
825 favorites
Homepage Paper & Party Supplies Party Supplies Party Decor