Only 1 left and in 3 carts
  • May include: Round button with the text "IN FOR A SCARE" in dripping neon green letters. The background features a spooky house illustration. The button has a glossy finish and is set against a black background with green smoke.
  • May include: Two black round buttons with a pumpkin graphic and the text "I'd rather be at the pumpkin patch." The larger button is 2.25 inches in diameter, and the smaller one is 1.5 inches. A dime is included for size comparison.
  • May include: Round button with the text "IN FOR A SCARE" in dripping neon green letters. The background features a spooky house illustration. The button has a glossy finish and is set against a black background with green smoke.
  • May include: Two black round buttons with a pumpkin graphic and the text "I'd rather be at the pumpkin patch." The larger button is 2.25 inches in diameter, and the smaller one is 1.5 inches. A dime is included for size comparison.
Report this item to Etsy

In For a Scare - Goosebumps Inspired Button

Please select an option

What to know

Materials

metal, high quality image paper, plastic

Made to Order

Yes

I can hear the theme music right now...

Choose a large pinback button, 2 1/4”, or smaller 1.5" size.

High-quality color image. I’ve been making buttons for over 10 years and only use high quality premium paper and premium inks. Buttons are professionally made by me and packaged with clear plastic sleeve. (Phone camera used, so photos can be a bit fuzzy and lack clarity. actual button’s image is clear and detailed.)

Each order comes with a free surprise, so inspect your package!

All images and designs copyright protected, 2025

View full item details

What buyers say

“The image is kind of dark, I thought the green would be a brighter slime green but otherwise cool.”

Kate

15 days ago

View all item reviews

NowPrice:$4.60+

Original Price: $5.75+

20% off

•

Sale ends on August 13

Shipping & return policies

  • Get it by
    Aug 7-14
  • Exchanges
    Accepted within 14 days.
  • Ships from
    Racine, WI
  • Cost to Ship
    $5.40 to United States, 43215

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Etsy's Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases. View program terms

Etsy invests in climate solutions

Like electric trucks and carbon offsets for every delivery. View more

Reviews for this item

4.0

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(1 reviews)

5.0 Item quality
5.0 Shipping
5.0 Customer service
100% Buyers recommend
4 out of 5 stars 4

Kate Jul 19, 2026

The image is kind of dark, I thought the green would be a brighter slime green but otherwise cool.

Kate Jul 19, 2026

Meet your seller

BedlamSupplyCo
Ginger
BedlamSupplyCo ·

Wisconsin, United States

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0
·
71k sales
·
15 years on Etsy
ginger
1 shop member

Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

View shop registration details

You may also like

Explore related searches

Goosebumps Enamel Pin

Goosebumps Button

90s Halloween Patches

Goosebumps Pin

Jason Voorhees Pins

Horror Book Fan Button

Listed on Jul 28, 2026
222 favorites
Homepage Accessories Pins & Clips Pins & Pinback Buttons

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy