• May include: A collection of colorful enamel evil eye charms in various shapes, including round, oval, and star. The charms feature gold-colored metal accents and come in a variety of colors, including blue, red, yellow, and green.
  • May include: Two stud earrings with an eye design, one pink and one black, each with a gold-colored border. The earrings are on a small, rectangular, brown card, set against a backdrop of green leaves.
  • May include: A collection of colorful enamel charms, including eye and star designs, arranged on a light gray ceramic plate. The charms feature various colors like blue, red, yellow, and green, with black and white detailing. The plate sits on a dark wood surface.
  • May include: A collection of small, colorful enamel charms with gold-colored metal accents. The charms are in various shapes, including round, star, and eye designs, and are arranged on a light gray plate. The charms feature shades of blue, red, green, and pink.
  • May include: A collection of gold-toned, enamel evil eye charms in various shapes, including round, oval, and heart. The charms feature vibrant colors like blue, red, yellow, and green, with a central eye design. They are displayed on a light gray surface.
  • May include: A collection of colorful, gold-toned enamel charms, including round and star shapes, featuring eye designs. The charms are in various colors, such as blue, red, yellow, and green, and are arranged on a light gray surface.
  • May include: A collection of colorful enamel eye-shaped and star-shaped pins with gold-colored metal trim. The pins feature various colors, including red, blue, yellow, green, and pink, with a white or black pupil design. The pins are arranged on a light gray surface.
  • May include: Two enamel eye stud earrings. One is pink with a white iris and black pupil, the other is black with a white iris and black pupil. Both have gold-colored metal borders. The earrings are on a small, brown, rectangular card.
  • May include: A collection of small, colorful enamel eye-shaped charms and star-shaped charms with gold-colored metal edges. A wooden ruler with inch measurements is placed next to the charms. The charms are arranged on a light gray ceramic plate.
  • May include: A collection of colorful enamel evil eye charms in various shapes, including round, oval, and star. The charms feature gold-colored metal accents and come in a variety of colors, including blue, red, yellow, and green.
  • Product video
  • May include: Two stud earrings with an eye design, one pink and one black, each with a gold-colored border. The earrings are on a small, rectangular, brown card, set against a backdrop of green leaves.
  • May include: A collection of colorful enamel charms, including eye and star designs, arranged on a light gray ceramic plate. The charms feature various colors like blue, red, yellow, and green, with black and white detailing. The plate sits on a dark wood surface.
  • May include: A collection of small, colorful enamel charms with gold-colored metal accents. The charms are in various shapes, including round, star, and eye designs, and are arranged on a light gray plate. The charms feature shades of blue, red, green, and pink.
  • May include: A collection of gold-toned, enamel evil eye charms in various shapes, including round, oval, and heart. The charms feature vibrant colors like blue, red, yellow, and green, with a central eye design. They are displayed on a light gray surface.
  • May include: A collection of colorful, gold-toned enamel charms, including round and star shapes, featuring eye designs. The charms are in various colors, such as blue, red, yellow, and green, and are arranged on a light gray surface.
  • May include: A collection of colorful enamel eye-shaped and star-shaped pins with gold-colored metal trim. The pins feature various colors, including red, blue, yellow, green, and pink, with a white or black pupil design. The pins are arranged on a light gray surface.
  • May include: Two enamel eye stud earrings. One is pink with a white iris and black pupil, the other is black with a white iris and black pupil. Both have gold-colored metal borders. The earrings are on a small, brown, rectangular card.
  • May include: A collection of small, colorful enamel eye-shaped charms and star-shaped charms with gold-colored metal edges. A wooden ruler with inch measurements is placed next to the charms. The charms are arranged on a light gray ceramic plate.
Report this item to Etsy

Mystery Eye Studs, Mystery Earrings, Pop art, Evil Eye Studs, Evil Eye Art, Pop art Jewelry, Mystery Jewelry, Fun Studs, Mystery Gift

Seller's description

Mystery Eye Studs

These fun new studs are my first mystery item! Each pair will have a random combination of eyes. In the photos above, I've shown examples of what they may look like. Each pair will have gold plated posts and include both metal and silicon push back pieces. (I photographed some without the posts for a better layout)

Size:
Width: 3/8 inch

Please message me with any other questions!
Ships from Indiana

Mystery Earrings, Pop art, Evil Eye Studs, Evil Eye Art, Pop art Jewelry, Mystery Jewelry, Fun Studs, Mystery Gift

View more

Price:$6.25

Ships from Indiana

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Shipping & return policies
  • Get it by
    Oct 29-Nov 6
  • Cost to ship
    $5.54 to United States, 43215.

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

Reviews for this item

What buyers say, summarized by AI: Looks great Love it

4.8

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(9 reviews)

4.8 Item quality
4.8 Shipping
5.0 Customer service
75% Buyers recommend
Filter by category
5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Anánír Oct 1, 2026

So far I love them! Very cute and just my style. Only thing I'd like to know is the material used for the earring posts. Not sure if they'll irritate my ears, so I make sure to remove them before bed.

Anánír Oct 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Kiera Sep 25, 2026

Such a cute and great gift idea! I love the concept of a mystery pairing.

Kiera Sep 25, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Alma Jun 6, 2026

3rd time ordering from this seller, and as always, I'm very happy w/the earrings! These are gifts for friends of mine because they liked mine so much. Thanks!!! 🩷

Alma Jun 6, 2026

Response from Katrina

Thank you so much!!

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Alma May 20, 2026

This is my second pair, and I love these earrings! Super cute. Shipped quickly. Thanks so much!!!

Alma May 20, 2026

Photos from reviews

Seller's description

Specifications

May include: A collection of colorful enamel evil eye charms in various shapes, including round, oval, and star. The charms feature gold-colored metal accents and come in a variety of colors, including blue, red, yellow, and green.

Mystery Eye Studs

These fun new studs are my first mystery item! Each pair will have a random combination of eyes. In the photos above, I've shown examples of what they may look like. Each pair will have gold plated posts and include both metal and silicon push back pieces. (I photographed some without the posts for a better layout)

Size:
Width: 3/8 inch

Please message me with any other questions!
Ships from Indiana

Mystery Earrings, Pop art, Evil Eye Studs, Evil Eye Art, Pop art Jewelry, Mystery Jewelry, Fun Studs, Mystery Gift

Delivery details and policies

  • Get it by
    Oct 29-Nov 6
  • Returns and exchanges
    Not accepted
  • Ships from
    Fishers, IN
    Shorter shipping distances are kinder to the planet
  • Cost to ship
    $5.54 to United States, 43215

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Etsy Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back on all eligible purchases. View program terms

Climate investments

Etsy supports climate solutions, from electric delivery trucks to carbon offsets for every delivery. View how

Meet your seller

KatrinaWStudio
Katrina
KatrinaWStudio ·

Indiana, United States

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9
·
4.1k sales
·
5 years on Etsy

Usually responds in 24 hours

Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

Shoppers with similar taste loved these

Show more
Show more

Explore related searches

Evil Eye Flat Back Stud

Fun Stud Earrings

Evil Eye Stud Earrings

Evil Eye Earrings

Blue Eye Earrings

Which Earrings

Halloween Earrings

Eye Ball Earrings

Listed on Oct 8, 2026
181 favorites
Homepage Jewelry Earrings Stud Earrings

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy