• May include: A round, white ceramic ornament with a yellow ribbon. The ornament features the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH" above a cartoon tooth with a crown and wings. Below the tooth is the name "Emily", age 6, and the year 2025.
  • May include: A white ceramic ornament with a gold ribbon for hanging. The ornament features the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH" and a cartoon tooth fairy with a crown and wand. The name "Emily", age 6, and the year 2025 are also included.
  • May include: A size guide graphic with measurements in inches and centimeters. The width and height are 2.76 inches (7.00 cm), and the depth is 0.12 inches (0.30 cm). The text "COTTON DASH" is on the right side. The text "Feel free to reach out if you'd like any personal touches. I'm here to make it just right for you!" is at the bottom.
  • May include: A round, cream-colored ornament with the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH." A cartoon tooth with a crown and wings is featured. The name "Emily," age 6, and the year 2025 are also printed on the ornament. A gold ribbon is attached.
  • May include: A white round ornament with a golden string, featuring a line drawing of a couple and the text "Emma & Jimmy, God Saved Us, 2023". The ornament has a smooth surface and rounded edges. The text "What to expect?" is at the top.
  • May include: A round, off-white ceramic ornament with a yellow ribbon, hanging from a wooden fixture. The image includes customer reviews with star ratings and text. The Cotton Dash Printing Company logo is visible.
  • May include: White ceramic Christmas ornament with gold hanging loop. The ornament features the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH" and a cartoon tooth fairy with a crown and wand. The name "Emily", age 6, and the year 2025 are also printed on the ornament.
  • May include: A brown paper shopping bag with a white sticker that says "Cotton Dash Printing Company". The bag has handles and is set against a white background with text that reads "Smile Guarantee".
  • May include: A round, cream-colored ornament with the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH." It features a cartoon tooth with a crown, wings, and a wand. The name "Emily," age 6, and the year 2025 are also printed on the ornament.
  • May include: A graphic with the word "Favorite" in a dark green font, surrounded by hearts and cotton illustrations. The text encourages users to save listings to their favorites.
  • May include: A round, white ceramic ornament with a yellow ribbon. The ornament features the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH" above a cartoon tooth with a crown and wings. Below the tooth is the name "Emily", age 6, and the year 2025.
  • May include: A white ceramic ornament with a gold ribbon for hanging. The ornament features the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH" and a cartoon tooth fairy with a crown and wand. The name "Emily", age 6, and the year 2025 are also included.
  • May include: A size guide graphic with measurements in inches and centimeters. The width and height are 2.76 inches (7.00 cm), and the depth is 0.12 inches (0.30 cm). The text "COTTON DASH" is on the right side. The text "Feel free to reach out if you'd like any personal touches. I'm here to make it just right for you!" is at the bottom.
  • May include: A round, cream-colored ornament with the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH." A cartoon tooth with a crown and wings is featured. The name "Emily," age 6, and the year 2025 are also printed on the ornament. A gold ribbon is attached.
  • May include: A white round ornament with a golden string, featuring a line drawing of a couple and the text "Emma & Jimmy, God Saved Us, 2023". The ornament has a smooth surface and rounded edges. The text "What to expect?" is at the top.
  • May include: A round, off-white ceramic ornament with a yellow ribbon, hanging from a wooden fixture. The image includes customer reviews with star ratings and text. The Cotton Dash Printing Company logo is visible.
  • May include: White ceramic Christmas ornament with gold hanging loop. The ornament features the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH" and a cartoon tooth fairy with a crown and wand. The name "Emily", age 6, and the year 2025 are also printed on the ornament.
  • May include: A brown paper shopping bag with a white sticker that says "Cotton Dash Printing Company". The bag has handles and is set against a white background with text that reads "Smile Guarantee".
  • May include: A round, cream-colored ornament with the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH." It features a cartoon tooth with a crown, wings, and a wand. The name "Emily," age 6, and the year 2025 are also printed on the ornament.
  • May include: A graphic with the word "Favorite" in a dark green font, surrounded by hearts and cotton illustrations. The text encourages users to save listings to their favorites.
Report this item to Etsy

Lost First Tooth Ornament for Kids, Personalized Tooth Fairy Milestone Gift, Custom Ceramic Keepsake for Children Baby Teeth Memory Ornament

CottonDashPrintCo  
5 out of 5 stars

Item highlights

  • Dimensions: Width: 2.76 Inches
  • Made to order

Seller's description

Celebrate a magical milestone with this personalized First Lost Tooth ornament!
This sweet ceramic keepsake features a smiling crowned tooth with fairy wings and sparkles, customized with your child’s name, age, and year to capture the memory forever.

Ideal for gifting from the Tooth Fairy, keepsake boxes, or as a cute display on a memory tree 🌟

Why It’s Loved:
✓ Unique way to celebrate a childhood milestone
✓ Great for memory boxes or as a Tooth Fairy gift
✓ A keepsake parents and kids will treasure
✓ Makes a fun stocking stuffer or end-of-year surprise

Personalization Instructions:
Add the child’s name, age, and year in the personalization box when ordering.

Each ornament is handmade and created with joy and intention. If you need a custom variation or want to change any elements, feel free to message me—I’d love to help you create something extra special 💌

Product features
- Size 3" by 3"
- Vibrant color
- Solid one-piece construction for durability
- Glossy finish for a polished look
- Comes with a hole and gold-toned hanging string for easy display (string color may vary)

Care instructions
- Gently wipe the dirt or dust off with a clean, dry microfiber cloth

Shopping small Makes a Big Difference. Thank you :)

View more

Item review

Why this review appears

All reviews are from verified buyers. This review is shown automatically based on factors like recency, whether it includes comments, your chosen language, and whether the rating reflects the typical experience with the shop.

“It was just perfect! My granddaughter and her parents loved it.”

Mary

23 days ago

View all

NowPrice:$15.37

Original Price: $27.95

45% off

•

Sale ends in 2:22:10

  • Please Enter the child’s name, age, and year to be printed on your ornament.
    If no year is entered, current year will be added as default.

    0/256

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Shipping & return policies
  • Get it by
    Oct 31-Nov 4
  • Cost to ship
    $5.58 to United States, 43215.

Reviews for this item

4.5

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(12 reviews)

4.6 Item quality
4.5 Shipping
5.0 Customer service
91% Buyers recommend
Filter by category
5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Mary Oct 2, 2026

It was just perfect! My granddaughter and her parents loved it.

Mary Oct 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

THERESE Sep 19, 2026

Cute ornament for grandchild. Pleased with purchase.

THERESE Sep 19, 2026

4 out of 5 stars 4 This item

Vanessa Jan 24, 2026

I didn’t come with a hanger, but I may have missed that in the description. I looked at the photo and thought there’d be a ribbon or something attached. Not a huge deal. We can add our own!

Vanessa Jan 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Jessica Dec 25, 2025

Wonderful Christmas gift for my daughter who lost her first tooth this year!

Jessica Dec 25, 2025

Photos from reviews

Seller's description

Specifications

May include: A round, white ceramic ornament with a yellow ribbon. The ornament features the text "THE YEAR I LOST MY FIRST TOOTH" above a cartoon tooth with a crown and wings. Below the tooth is the name "Emily", age 6, and the year 2025.

Celebrate a magical milestone with this personalized First Lost Tooth ornament!
This sweet ceramic keepsake features a smiling crowned tooth with fairy wings and sparkles, customized with your child’s name, age, and year to capture the memory forever.

Ideal for gifting from the Tooth Fairy, keepsake boxes, or as a cute display on a memory tree 🌟

Why It’s Loved:
✓ Unique way to celebrate a childhood milestone
✓ Great for memory boxes or as a Tooth Fairy gift
✓ A keepsake parents and kids will treasure
✓ Makes a fun stocking stuffer or end-of-year surprise

Personalization Instructions:
Add the child’s name, age, and year in the personalization box when ordering.

Each ornament is handmade and created with joy and intention. If you need a custom variation or want to change any elements, feel free to message me—I’d love to help you create something extra special 💌

Product features
- Size 3" by 3"
- Vibrant color
- Solid one-piece construction for durability
- Glossy finish for a polished look
- Comes with a hole and gold-toned hanging string for easy display (string color may vary)

Care instructions
- Gently wipe the dirt or dust off with a clean, dry microfiber cloth

Shopping small Makes a Big Difference. Thank you :)

Delivery details and policies

  • Get it by
    Oct 31-Nov 4
  • Returns and exchanges
    Not accepted.
  • Ships from
    Fremont, CA
  • Cost to ship
    $5.58 to United States, 43215

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Star Seller

This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped orders on time, and replied quickly to messages.

Etsy Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back on all eligible purchases. View program terms

Climate investments

Etsy supports climate solutions, from electric delivery trucks to carbon offsets for every delivery. View how

Meet your seller

CottonDashPrintCo
Jess
CottonDashPrintCo ·

United States

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9
·
9.9k sales
·
3 years on Etsy

Usually responds in a few hours

Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

You may also like

Shoppers with similar taste loved these

Show more
Show more
Listed on Oct 18, 2026
87 favorites
Homepage Home & Living Home Decor Seasonal Decor Ornaments

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy