Report this item to Etsy

What Happened to Me? Exploring the Mary Theresa Simpson Cold Case | Paperback by Christina Fanelli

Low in stock, only 8 left

Price:$12.99+

Loading
Includes Etsy Purchase Protection

Returns & exchanges accepted

Please select an option

  • Please provide specific preferences you'd like for your copy. It is available in eBook, paperback, and hardcover formats let me know your preferred format and any other details to make your purchase unique.

    0/256
  • If you chose Signed, tell me the name to dedicate it to.

    0/256

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Highlights

On Sunday, March 15, 1964, shy and cautious Mary Theresa Simpson waved goodbye to her two cousins and her aunt as she turned to go home to her dad's house, and they walked into a neighborhood store. Mary Theresa never made it home, and her body was found on Combs Hill Road just 4 days later.

The Elmira City Police Department is still investigating this case, and unfortunately, it isn’t the only one of its kind. In What Happened to Me? factual accounts and narrative storytelling meet to explore the evidence and wider context of the disappearance and murder of 12-year-old Mary Theresa Simpson. A cold case that still weighs heavy on the heart of Elmira, New York.

Loading
  • Order today to get by Nov 27-Dec 7
  • Returns & exchanges accepted within 30 days
  • Cost to ship: $9.30
  • Ships from: Pine City, NY

There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Etsy Purchase Protection
Shop confidently on Etsy knowing if something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases — see program terms

Etsy invests in climate solutions like electric trucks and carbon offsets for every delivery. See how
Etsy invests in climate solutions like electric trucks and carbon offsets for every delivery. See how

Be the first to leave a review

Help this shop grow by ordering this personalizable item and sharing your feedback. You can still shop confidently with Etsy Purchase Protection.
Learn more

You may also like

Shoppers with similar taste loved these

Show more
Show more
Listed on Oct 5, 2026