20+ views in the last 24 hours
Price:CA$65.36+
The Horror Mystery Box | Spooky Gift Idea • Exclusive Horror Merch • Plushies, Collectibles, & more.
Star Seller
Star Sellers have an outstanding track record for providing a great customer experience – they consistently earned 5-star reviews, dispatched orders on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.
Your order should arrive by this date if you buy today. To calculate an estimated delivery date you can count on, we look at things like the carrier's latest transit times, the seller's processing time and dispatch history, and where the order is dispatched from and delivered to.
-
Add a note to this order? (For specific characters, it's better to confirm with us what product availability we have if it's important.)
0/256
You can only make an offer when buying a single item.
Star Seller. This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, dispatched on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.
Highlights
The Horror Mystery Box
Looking for spooky awesome Horror merch you won't find anywhere else? From exclusive designs, collectibles, limited edition items, and original characters. Come see why Horror fans think our Horror mystery boxes are the best on the market.
Choose Your Box Size
🔪The Small Box - $45
6-8 Items inside worth $60+ of our retail value.
🔪The Large Box — $75 (Best Value)
8-12 items — Shirt size is required, but a shirt is not guaranteed to be inside this box.
Avg retail value: $120+
Limited run • No repeats • Curated for true horror fans
🕸️ Spooky Safe Shipping Guarantee — if anything arrives damaged, we replace it.
Discover why thousands of customers love our Horror boxes. We do 3-4 different Horror collections a year, and this one would feature items from all of our past collections. Our next Collection is dropping in May 2026!
Ordered before and back for another? Leave a note at the cart page with items you received in your 1st box and we'll avoid duplicates!
✨ Why Customers Love It
Limited edition items
Original Characters
Exclusive designs you can’t find anywhere else
Over 1,000 5-star reviews since 2021
Perfect for gift-giving, collectors, and spooky fans
Hand-designed and curated by Sterye
Spooky Safe Shipping Guarantee: we replace anything damaged
📦 Gifting + Repeat Buyer Tips
Want a certain item shown in example photos? Leave a note at checkout.
Already ordered before? Tell us what you received so we can avoid duplicates.
🖤 Ships fast from Texas (1–2 business day processing time)
ALL packaged up inside our awesome Horror box mailers.
-
Order today to get by 06-11 Jun
Your order should arrive by this date if you buy today. To calculate an estimated delivery date you can count on, we look at things like the carrier's latest transit times, the seller's processing time and dispatch history, and where the order is dispatched from and delivered to.
-
Returns & exchanges not accepted
But please contact me if you have problems with your order
-
Free delivery
-
Dispatched from: Tomball, TX
There was a problem calculating your postage. Please try again.
Etsy Purchase Protection
Shop confidently on Etsy knowing if something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases —
see programme terms
Reviews for this item
What buyers say, summarised by AI: Love it Great quality Fast delivery Perfect gift
loved my box! Great gift to myself lol
Very nice! My husband and I are big horror fans. Got it for his birthday and he LOVED it! Very impressed with the care and consideration that went into this box. The rest of the family are each demanding their own boxes for their bdays. Fast delivery, too.
I ordered this horror box for my best friends birthday. I wrote in what kind of things she was interested in and they nailed it! Will definitely be buying again for future gifts.
love everything in the box!
Photos from reviews
More from this shop
Visit shop-
Horror Movie Log Book: Fear Reels Journal for Horror Fans
CA$29.05
-
Strawberry Cow Gift Set: Kawaii Tote Bag, Enamel Pin & Stickers
CA$21.79
-
Shroomers Mushroom Enamel Pin Blind Bag • Mystery Pin Drop • Glow in the Dark Ghost Pin • Collectible Fungi Pins • Kawaii Cottagecore Gift
CA$17.43
-
Trippy Horror Umbrella: Psychedelic Faces, Spooky Rain Gear
CA$43.57
-
Handmade Horror Mystery Box: Personalized Horror Gift Set
CA$384.29
-
Horror Themed Mystery Box!
CA$101.66
-
Horror Slate Coasters - Classic Horror Characters - Engraved Horror Monsters
CA$14.52
-
The Small Scare Horror Mystery Box
CA$101.66
-
Horror Mystery Bag 5 Items Themed To Your Choice
CA$50.83
-
Oh The Horror Gift Box / True Crime - Monsters - Horror Movies / Gothic Goth Gift Box / Horror Gift Box / Themed Gift Box / Curated Gift
CA$58.08
-
Goth Horror Self-Care Box Girlfriend Wife: Spooky Halloween Mystery Gift. Valloween
CA$79.88
-
Horror Movie Christmas Stocking, Mystery Gift Set
CA$36.31
-
Vintage Horror Mystery Box: Classic Movie, Comic & Collectibles
CA$54.50
-
bad mood bath box | mystery mood-based gift set | vegan gothic bath ritual
CA$85.00
-
Horror Movie Gift Box: Spooky Treats, Socks & Decorations
CA$87.14
-
HORROR MYSTERY BUNDLE - 2 random horror cups
CA$35.66
Shoppers with similar taste loved these
-
Gothic Skull Ring | Full Oxidized 925 Sterling Silver | Edgy Jewelry for Bold Style
CA$377.76
-
Half Jaw Crack Skull Ring | 925 Sterling Silver | Oxidized Finish | Bold Statement Jewelry
CA$321.55
-
Gothic Skull Ring | 925 Sterling Silver | Edgy Fashion Statement | Unique Jewelry
CA$321.55
-
Gothic Punk Skull Wings 925 Italian Sterling Silver Biker Rider Men's Bird Ring
CA$244.43
-
Open Jaw Gothic Biker Oxidized Aged 925 Sterling Silver Skull Crack Men Ring
CA$377.76
-
Silver Skull ring, brutalist scratched band
CA$296.07
-
Five Skulls Sterling Silver Statement Ring | Unique Design | Bold Jewelry for Edgy Fashion
CA$282.34
-
Sterling Silver Skull Ring: Handcrafted Gothic Biker Statement Jewelry
CA$144.94
-
Gothic Skull Ring | 925 Sterling Silver | Oxidized Finish | Unique Statement Jewelry
CA$377.76
-
BLOOD RAGE Dice | Handmade Resin Set for RPG, Dungeons and Dragons, Curse Of Strahd, Vampire Masquerade | Fast Shipping Option at Checkout
Sale Price CA$25.27
Original Price CA$33.69
-
Custom Wooden mini White Skull Tokens for Board Games | Hit Counters Wood Skulls
CA$35.08
-
D6 Dnd dice set 6pcs for Dungeons and Dragons Set D&D white skull and black resin dice warlock Polyhedral dice set
CA$70.75
