Teacher Mystery Gift Bag – Choose Your Main Item + 4 Surprises
Price:$12.00
Star Seller
Star Sellers have an outstanding track record for providing a great customer experience—they consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped orders on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.
Your order should arrive by this date if you buy today. To calculate an estimated delivery date you can count on, we look at things like the carrier's latest transit times, the seller's processing time and shipping history, and where the order is shipping to and from.
Returns & exchanges accepted
Mark your order as a gift in cart. After placing the order, customize your gift teaser. We'll email the recipient your message, shipping details, and optional preview image.
You can only make an offer when buying a single item
Star Seller. This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.
Highlights
Teacher Mystery Gift Bag
🎁 YOU PICK THE MAIN ITEM — I PICK THE SURPRISES!
Each Teacher Mystery Gift Bag includes 1 teacher-themed main item of your choice + 4 surprise goodies, all packaged together in a fun gift bag.
Choose Your Main Item
Pick from available options such as:
- Beaded Pen
- Stylus
- Keychain
- Badge Reel
- Lanyard
- Bookmark
- Silicone Bracelet Keychain
- Surprise Me
Then I'll add 4 mystery teacher-themed surprises to complete your bag.
Your surprises may include items such as teacher stickers, school-themed accessories, small stationery items, charms, mini gifts and other fun teacher goodies.
How It Works
1. Choose your main item.
You get to pick the item you definitely want.
2. I choose four fun surprises.
Each bag is different, so the surprise is part of the fun!
3. Everything is packaged together in a gift pack.
Perfect for:
- Teacher Appreciation
- Back-to-School Gifts
- New Teachers
- Student Teachers
- Classroom Assistants
- School Staff
- Teacher Coworkers
- Birthdays
- Secret Pal Gifts
- End-of-Year Gifts
- Just Because
Please Note
This is a mystery-style gift pack. You choose your main item, but the additional four goodies are surprises.
Colors, beads, focal designs, stickers and surprise items will vary based on available inventory.
Photos show examples of the types of items I make and may include possible designs or surprise items. Exact items shown are not guaranteed unless specifically listed as a selectable option.
Each pack includes 1 chosen main item + 4 mystery surprises.
-
Order today to get by Nov 27-Dec 5
Your order should arrive by this date if you buy today. To calculate an estimated delivery date you can count on, we look at things like the carrier's latest transit times, the seller's processing time and shipping history, and where the order is shipping to and from.
-
Returns & exchanges accepted within 30 days
Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs. If the item is not returned in its original condition, the buyer is responsible for any loss in value.
-
Cost to ship: $4.99
-
Ships from: Ocala, FL
There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.
Etsy Purchase Protection
Shop confidently on Etsy knowing if something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases —
see program terms
Be the first to review this item
Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.
Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.
Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.
More from this shop
Visit shop-
Golden Girls Mystery Bag – Beaded Pen, Keychain, Bookmark – 80s Nostalgia Gift
$12.00
-
Christian Mystery Pack, Faith Encouragement Surprise Goodies
$12.00
-
Fall Mystery Pack | Halloween Autumn Accessories (Beaded Pen, Badge Reel, Keychain, Bracelet, Stickers)
$12.00
-
Christmas & Winter Mystery Gift Pack – 4 Accessories With Stickers
$12.00
-
Mystery Bundle, Custom scoop, Cute Desk Accessories, Office Supplies, Unique Gift, Back to School, gift for her, teacher appreciation
$10.00
-
Teacher Appreciation and School Theme Confetti Scoop: Mystery Junk Journal Embellishments
$14.00
-
Teacher Holiday Goodie Box, Teacher Christmas Gift, Teacher Snacks, Teacher Thank You, Teacher Appreciation Gift, Preschool Teacher, Winter
$19.00
-
Ultimate Teacher Gift Set – Keychain, Earrings & 7-Piece Sticker Pack
$18.99
-
5PC Lot Teacher Appreciation / End of Year / Teacher Gift / Substitute Teacher / Favorite Teacher / Teacher Gift / Teacher of the Year
$16.76
-
Teacher Bath and Body Gift Set- Teacher Apperication Gift- Teacher Christmas Gift
$15.00
-
Teacher gift bundle
$15.00
-
Teacher Back to School Gift, Teacher Christmas Gift, Teacher Survival Kit, Teacher Emergency Kit, Teacher Appreciation Gift, Bulk Gifts
$9.00
-
Teacher Survival Kit, Practical Back To School, Christmas gift for her, Emergency Supply Kit For Teachers, Appreciation Gift, Care Package
$15.00
-
Teacher Appreciation Gifts, Teacher Survival Kit, New Teacher Gift, Classroom Gifts, Teacher Bulk Gift, Back to School Gift for Teacher
$9.00
-
Teacher Appreciation Gift! Includes a keychain, Ornament, Heart pencil and notepad!
$18.99
-
Grade Level Teacher Pen: Apple & Crayon Beaded Pens // Teacher Appreciation Gift
$12.00
Shoppers with similar taste loved these
-
Teacher Gift - Paper and Pencil Notepad - Personalized Stationery
Sale Price $6.80
Original Price $8.00
-
Couch Arm Rest Table with Magazine Stand, Modern Wood Armrest Table, Simply Sofa Arm Tray Table, Couch Tray, Custom Wood Sofa Arm Table
Sale Price $78.86
Original Price $98.57
-
Neutral Beaded Lanyards - wildflowers, floral, leopard, hearts, boho, neutral tones, gift ideas, teacher, nurse, office, breakaway lanyards
$16.75
-
Digital download
Rainbow Meeting Notebook 2026-2030 for Teachers & School Admin | Teacher Meeting Notes | Printable + Digital | FREE UPDATES
$5.00
-
Trendy Teacher Lanyard - Personalized Lanyard for Keys or ID Badge - Beaded Lanyard - Disco Lanyard with Name - Adorable Teacher Gifts
Sale Price $17.46
Original Price $24.95
-
Teacher Sticky Note Pad Holder Gift | Personalized Teacher Name Gift | Student Gift For Teacher | Teacher Gift | Teacher End of Year Gift
Sale Price $13.94
Original Price $15.49
-
ELL Teacher Shirt for Women, Back to School T-Shirt, ELL Teacher T-shirt, ELL Teacher Gift, Bilingual Teacher T Shirt, English Teacher Gift
Sale Price $8.70
Original Price $21.75
-
Personalized Disney Teacher Sign, Mickey Classroom Decor, Teacher Gift
$32.99
-
Comfort Colors ESL Teacher Shirt, ELL Teacher Tee, English Language Teacher Gift, Back to School Tee, Language Support Squad 003862
Sale Price $18.45
Original Price $30.75
-
Personalized Embroidered Teacher Quarter Zip Pullover Sweatshirt - Teacher Gift - School Colors - Pencil Bow - Cute Teacher Sweater
Sale Price $36.55
Original Price $43.00
-
Comfort Colors® Leopard Teacher Shirt, Teacher Shirt, Teacher Life Shirt, Teacher Tee, Teacher, School Shirt
Sale Price $9.99
Original Price $16.65
-
Queen of the Classroom Teacher Sticker * Matte Vinyl Sticker
$4.00