18 views in the last 24 hours
Price:$25.95+
First Fathers Day Personalized Fishing Lure | New Dad Gift for the Dad to be
Star Seller
Star Sellers have an outstanding track record for providing a great customer experience—they consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped orders on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.
Your order should arrive by this date if you buy today. To calculate an estimated delivery date you can count on, we look at things like the carrier's latest transit times, the seller's processing time and shipping history, and where the order is shipping to and from.
Returns accepted
-
Add your personalization for side #2 here (optional).
0/500 -
You can only make an offer when buying a single item
Star Seller. This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.
This First Fathers Day, give your Dad to be a gift he’ll keep forever. Our New Dad personalized fishing lure is custom made with your message, creating a meaningful keepsake from the new Baby. Hand-painted and crafted on Cape Cod, it’s a real, fishable lure—but most customers choose to display it as a reminder of his very first Father’s Day.
Ordering is simple:
1. Choose your packaging preference "Lure Only" or "Lure & Gift Tin"
2. Select your preferred logo design from the dropdown menu
3. Add your personalized message in the provided box (up to 20 characters)
4. Choose Between Hooks or make a Keyring
4. Your custom details are applied and sealed with a protective clear coat
- Hand-painted custom fishing lure made on Cape Cod with heirloom-quality detail
- Personalize with name, date or optional short message (up to 20 characters)
- Available with gift-ready tin packaging featuring recycled paper shavings for presentation
- Crystal clear topcoat ensures lasting durability and vibrant finish
Promo Lures crafts every piece with care and fast shipping to ensure your gift arrives safely and beautifully.
-
Order today to get by Jun 25-Jul 4
Your order should arrive by this date if you buy today. To calculate an estimated delivery date you can count on, we look at things like the carrier's latest transit times, the seller's processing time and shipping history, and where the order is shipping to and from.
-
Returns accepted within 14 days
Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs. If the item is not returned in its original condition, the buyer is responsible for any loss in value.
-
Cost to ship: $5.50Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.
-
Ships from: Carver, MA
There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.
Etsy Purchase Protection
Shop confidently on Etsy knowing if something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases —
see program terms
Reviews for this item
What buyers say, summarized by AI: Perfect gift Great quality Love it As described Fast shipping Looks great Unique
Just like the picture, perfect
Thank you so much! This was absolutely perfect!
Great quality and unique item
Great quality and craftsmanship. Cool gift for first Father’s Day
Photos from reviews
Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.
Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.
Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.
More from this shop
Visit shop-
Father’s Day Gift for Dad: Personalized Fishing Lure Keepsake, Handmade on Cape Cod
$25.95
-
New Dad Father's Day Gift | Personalized Fishing Lure from his Baby
$25.95
-
Fisherman Gift for Fathers Day: Handmade Fishing Lure Personalized for Dad
$25.95
-
First Fathers Day Personalized Fishing Lure | New Dad Gift for the Dad to be
$25.95
-
Personalized First Father's Day Gift for New Dad, First Fathers Day Gift, First Time Dad Gift, New Dad Gift, New Daddy Gifts, Gift from Baby
Sale Price $9.22
Original Price $11.52
-
First Fathers day, 1st Fathers Day, First fathers day Gift, First Time Dad Gift, First Time Dad, New Dad Gift, New Daddy, New Daddy Gifts
$28.91
-
Daddy's Fishing Princess Lure, New Dad Gift, Baby Reveal, Custom Fishing Lure, Hand Stamped Fish Hook, Father's Day Gift from Daughter
$16.95
-
Engraved Fishing Lure, Dad Birthday Gift, "Behind Every Good Kid Is A Great Dad",
Sale Price $17.49
Original Price $24.99
-
Daddy's New Fishing Buddy Lure, New Dad Gift, Baby Reveal, Custom Fishing Lure, Hand Stamped with Date, Engraved Fishing Hook, Father's Day
$16.95
-
FIRST FATHER'S DAY Gift for Husband Soon to be Dad Fathers Day Gift First Time Dad Gift First Time Dad New Dad Gift New Daddy New Dad Frame
$52.66
-
Daddy My First Reel Love Daddy Fishing Lure Gift for Dad Fathers Day Gift For Daddy Fishing Gift
Sale Price $13.87
Original Price $18.50
-
First Fathers day, 1st Fathers Day, First fathers day Gift, First Time Dad Gift, First Time Dad, New Dad Gift, New Daddy, New Daddy Gifts
$28.91
-
My First Fishing Buddy Lure, New Dad Gift, Baby Reveal, Custom Fishing Lure, Hand Stamped, Grandpa Gift, Father's Day Gift, Fishing Keychain
$16.95
-
New Dad Gift, Father's Day Gift For New Dad, First Time Dad Gift, New Father Gift, New Daddy Gift, Expecting Dad Gift, Dad to be Gift
$54.97
-
Dear Daddy Personalized Keychain Gift from Newborn, 1st Time Dad Gift, First Father's Day Gift, New Dad Gift, Soon to be Daddy Gift
$42.95
-
New Dad Gift, Father's Day Gift From Wife, First Time Dad Gift, New Father Gift, New Daddy Gift, Expecting Dad Gift, Dad to be Gift
$54.97
Disclaimer: As with all children's products, adult supervision is required. Products that contain small parts may pose a choking hazard and should not be used by children under 3. Sellers are responsible for following applicable laws and regulations, including posting items with accurate labeling and warnings. Etsy assumes no responsibility for the accuracy, labeling, or content of sellers' listings and products. Always read labels, warnings, directions and other information provided with the product before using it. If you have any questions, message the seller. See Etsy's Terms of Use for more information.
Shoppers with similar taste loved these
-
Custom Photo Collage Blanket With text: Personalized Family Throw, Father's Day Gift
Sale Price $7.00
Original Price $17.50
-
Custom Picture Blanket,Custom photo gifts, family blanket, anniversary blanket,picture collage blanket,Custom Photo Collage Gift for Grandma
Sale Price $23.19
Original Price $28.99
-
Custom Photo Blanket Collage, Picture Blanket With Text, Memorial Blanket, Friend Couples Gift, Birthday Anniversary Gift, Family Blanket
Sale Price $24.49
Original Price $48.98
-
Custom Blanket with Photos Collage, Personalized Family Picture Blanket With Text, 2026 Best Photo Gifts For Mother's Day and Father's Day
Sale Price $7.99
Original Price $15.98
-
Custom Photo Blanket Collage, Personalized Picture Blanket for Fans, Family Christmas Gifts
Sale Price $13.14
Original Price $32.85
-
custom photo blanket, custom blanket with picture, blankets with pictures, photo blanket collage, family blanket, customizable blanket
Sale Price $22.50
Original Price $45.00
-
Personalised Daddy & Me LEGO® Brick Photo block, Gift for Dad, White, Building Block, Puzzle, Gift, Him, Dad, Father's Day, Grandad, Grandpa
$45.41
-
Personalised First Father's Day Baby Vest - First Father's Day Gifts - First Father's Day Babygrow - Father's Day Outfit - Fathers Day Gift
$7.18
-
First Father's Day Grandad Mug & Coaster Set | First Father's Day as my Grandad Gift | New Grandpa Gift | Gift Grandad Grandpa Gramps
$9.51
-
Personalised Happy First Birthday As My Daddy Dad Dadda Father Card | Photo Card 1st Birthday New Baby Card | Any Relation Photo Card
$4.50
-
First Fathers Day Card from Baby, 1st Fathers Day Card, Daddy Fathers Day Card, Personalised Fathers Day Card, Cute Bear Card
$4.50
-
Daddy Gifts, Personalised Day You Became My Daddy Engraved Metal Keyring
$20.10
