Low in stock, only 1 left
  • May include: Three white plush teeth with smiling faces and embroidered hearts. The two larger teeth have hanging loops. The smaller tooth has glitter and pink cheeks. A colorful button with the text "Lost My Tooth" is in the foreground.
  • May include: White tooth-shaped pillow with pink embroidered hearts and a black embroidered smile. The text "Free "I lost my tooth" button with purchase of any Tooth Fairy Pillow from my store!" is written below the pillow.
  • May include: Two plush tooth-shaped ornaments, one blue and white striped with the name "Preston" embroidered on it, and the other pink with white polka dots and the name "Hadley" embroidered on it. A smaller white plush tooth with a smiley face is in the center. A button with a smiling tooth and the words "I lost my tooth" is in the foreground.
  • May include: A white plush tooth with a smiling face and pink hearts on the cheeks. The tooth is hanging from a white cord and has a round button with the text "I Lost My Tooth" on it.
  • May include: A pink and white tooth-shaped plush toy with white polka dots. The toy is hanging from a white rope.
  • May include: White plush tooth with a smiling face and two blue hearts on either side of the face.
  • May include: A white tooth-shaped pillow with blue and white stripes. The pillow has a white rope handle and a dollar bill tucked inside the pocket.
  • May include: White felt tooth ornament with a red and white striped candy cane button that says "SONNY 2018". The tooth has a smiling face with pink cheeks and black eyes. There is a green holly sprig with red berries on the top of the tooth.
  • May include: Two personalized tooth fairy pillow bags, one pink with the name Moriah and one gray with the name Dean. Each bag features a white embroidered tooth with a smiling face.
  • May include: Blue tooth pillow with a white tooth embroidered on it wearing a red firefighter hat with a yellow badge. The pillow has a white drawstring and the name Aiden is embroidered on it in yellow.
  • May include: Three white plush teeth with smiling faces and embroidered hearts. The two larger teeth have hanging loops. The smaller tooth has glitter and pink cheeks. A colorful button with the text "Lost My Tooth" is in the foreground.
  • May include: White tooth-shaped pillow with pink embroidered hearts and a black embroidered smile. The text "Free "I lost my tooth" button with purchase of any Tooth Fairy Pillow from my store!" is written below the pillow.
  • May include: Two plush tooth-shaped ornaments, one blue and white striped with the name "Preston" embroidered on it, and the other pink with white polka dots and the name "Hadley" embroidered on it. A smaller white plush tooth with a smiley face is in the center. A button with a smiling tooth and the words "I lost my tooth" is in the foreground.
  • May include: A white plush tooth with a smiling face and pink hearts on the cheeks. The tooth is hanging from a white cord and has a round button with the text "I Lost My Tooth" on it. +7 View all
Report this item to Etsy

Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillow with "I Lost My Tooth" Pin

Sandra Vaccaro

Made by Sandra

Owner of SANDRAINSTITCHES

Please select an option

Please select an option

  • Please enter name you are wanting personalized.

    0/256

What to know

Dimensions

Width: 5.00 Inches; Length: 6.5 Inches

Made to Order

Yes

Tooth Fairy Pillow. Includes Personalization! Your child will love when the Tooth Fairy comes to visit. Pillow features a pocket on the back side to slip their lost tooth in and receive a gift from the tooth fairy the next morning. A wonderful way to celebrate a lost tooth!

New optional item! Every super hero has an Alert Light, now the Tooth Fairy has one also, start a new tradition in your home by placing this Lighted Tooth Fairy Alert on your child's dresser or any flat surface to let the Tooth Fairy know she is needed. This Flameless Flickering battery operated light is a sweet addition to any Tooth Fairy Pillow. Comes with one extra battery (per the manufacturer, the average light of one battery is 72 hours) I purchased the ones I am using at Hobby Lobby, they are also available at Walmart.

This listing is for one Tooth Fairy Pillow- with option to add a alert light.

Your Tooth Fairy pillow stands 6.5 inches tall by 5.0 inches wide. Made of white fleece, back pocket is flannel (scroll thru photos to see fabric), another option is to leave back pocket white in same white fleece.

Item is made to order and will ship between 3-5 business days. It will be wrapped in a cello bag, tied with coordinating colored ribbon, makes a great presentation.
Please give your child's name in the message section when checking out.

All my items are made and stored in a smoke free/pet free studio.

View full item details

What buyers say

Summarized by AI from all item reviews

5.0 (58)
Great quality Looks great Love it Fast shipping
View all item reviews

Price:$16.95+

Shipping & return policies

  • Order today to get by Aug 7-10
  • Returns & exchanges not accepted.
  • Ships from: Tinley Park, IL
    Shorter shipping distances are kinder to the planet
  • Cost to ship: $6.95
  • Deliver to United States, 43215

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Star Seller

This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.

Etsy's Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases. View program terms

Etsy invests in climate solutions

Like electric trucks and carbon offsets for every delivery. View more

Reviews for this item

5.0

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(58 reviews)

5.0 Item quality
5.0 Shipping
5.0 Customer service
100% Buyers recommend

What buyers say

Summarized by AI from all item reviews

Great quality Looks great Love it Fast shipping

Filter by category
5 out of 5 stars 5

Lisa Jun 23, 2025

Our tooth fairy pillow arrived quickly and my son was so excited to use it! This is my second purchase and the quality is exceptional!

Lisa Jun 23, 2025

5 out of 5 stars 5

Michelle May 1, 2025

This is my go-to baby gift! Super adorable and very well made.

Michelle May 1, 2025

5 out of 5 stars 5

Nicole Oct 20, 2024

Just want I wanted, very cute

Nicole Oct 20, 2024

5 out of 5 stars 5

Collette Dec 4, 2023

Just as pictured. Well made and shipped. Very cute!

Collette Dec 4, 2023

Photos from reviews

Meet your seller

SANDRAINSTITCHES
Sandra Vaccaro
SANDRAINSTITCHES ·

Chicago, Illinois

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0
·
12k sales
·
15 years on Etsy
1 shop member

Usually responds in a few hours

Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

You may also like

Explore related searches

Tooth Fairy Pillow Girl

Tooth Pillow Boys

Tooth Pillow Girl

Tooth Fairy Pillow Girl Unicorn

Tooth Pillow With Dates

Toothfairy Pillow Girl

Hanging Tooth Pillow

Listed on Jun 6, 2026
347 favorites
Homepage Home & Living Home Decor Throw Pillows

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy