• May include: A plush orange fish toy with a soft texture, featuring large white eyes with black pupils and a stitched black smile. The name Collin is embroidered in black thread on the side of the fish body, which has a fin and a tail.
  • May include: A small, long-haired white and brown Shih Tzu dog lying down next to an orange plush fish toy. The plush toy features large white eyes and the name Collin embroidered in black script on its side, with a soft, textured fabric finish.
  • May include: A bright red plush fish toy featuring large white eyes with black pupils and the word "PROfish" embroidered in white thread across its side. The soft, stuffed fabric toy has a distinct fin shape and a simple stitched smile.
  • May include: A greyhound dog with a dark grey coat and a blue collar, resting on a leather surface. In front of the dog lies a bright blue plush fish toy with large white eyes and the name Dery embroidered in orange thread on its side.
  • May include: Two plush fish toys with embroidered names. The yellow fish features the name Mike in blue thread, while the pink fish features the name stella in yellow thread. Both fish have large white eyes with black pupils and a stitched smile.
  • May include: Two plush fish toys with embroidered details. The top fish is light blue with the name "Koa" stitched in purple. The bottom fish is bright blue with the name "Captain" stitched in orange. Both feature large white eyes with black pupils.
  • May include: A small tan dog with a pink flower hair accessory and a floral print shirt featuring pink, yellow, and orange blossoms. The dog is positioned next to an orange plush toy with the word Swifty embroidered in black on its side.
  • May include: A white Dalmatian dog with black spots sleeping curled up on a blue pillow. The dog is holding a small, orange, heart-shaped plush toy that features two large white eyes with black pupils printed on the front surface of the toy.
  • May include: Two small dogs sitting side by side. The dog on the left is white and brown with a collar and a black tag reading Honi, holding a bright pink plush fish toy labeled Honi. The dog on the right is brown and black with a collar, holding a teal plush fish toy labeled Koa.
  • May include: A plush fish toy in a vibrant magenta color with a soft, fuzzy texture. The toy features large, white, oval-shaped eyes with black pupils and the name Kika embroidered in yellow cursive script on its side. It has a fin and tail.
  • May include: A pink plush fish toy with a soft, fuzzy texture. The fish features large white eyes with black pupils, a stitched black mouth, and the word "lady" embroidered in pink thread on its side. It has a dorsal fin and a tail fin.
  • May include: A plush orange fish toy with a soft texture, featuring large white eyes with black pupils and a stitched black smile. The name Collin is embroidered in black thread on the side of the fish body, which has a fin and a tail.
  • May include: A small, long-haired white and brown Shih Tzu dog lying down next to an orange plush fish toy. The plush toy features large white eyes and the name Collin embroidered in black script on its side, with a soft, textured fabric finish.
  • May include: A bright red plush fish toy featuring large white eyes with black pupils and the word "PROfish" embroidered in white thread across its side. The soft, stuffed fabric toy has a distinct fin shape and a simple stitched smile.
  • May include: A greyhound dog with a dark grey coat and a blue collar, resting on a leather surface. In front of the dog lies a bright blue plush fish toy with large white eyes and the name Dery embroidered in orange thread on its side.
  • May include: Two plush fish toys with embroidered names. The yellow fish features the name Mike in blue thread, while the pink fish features the name stella in yellow thread. Both fish have large white eyes with black pupils and a stitched smile.
  • May include: Two plush fish toys with embroidered details. The top fish is light blue with the name "Koa" stitched in purple. The bottom fish is bright blue with the name "Captain" stitched in orange. Both feature large white eyes with black pupils.
  • May include: A small tan dog with a pink flower hair accessory and a floral print shirt featuring pink, yellow, and orange blossoms. The dog is positioned next to an orange plush toy with the word Swifty embroidered in black on its side.
  • May include: A white Dalmatian dog with black spots sleeping curled up on a blue pillow. The dog is holding a small, orange, heart-shaped plush toy that features two large white eyes with black pupils printed on the front surface of the toy.
  • May include: Two small dogs sitting side by side. The dog on the left is white and brown with a collar and a black tag reading Honi, holding a bright pink plush fish toy labeled Honi. The dog on the right is brown and black with a collar, holding a teal plush fish toy labeled Koa.
  • May include: A plush fish toy in a vibrant magenta color with a soft, fuzzy texture. The toy features large, white, oval-shaped eyes with black pupils and the name Kika embroidered in yellow cursive script on its side. It has a fin and tail.
  • May include: A pink plush fish toy with a soft, fuzzy texture. The fish features large white eyes with black pupils, a stitched black mouth, and the word "lady" embroidered in pink thread on its side. It has a dorsal fin and a tail fin.
Report this item to Etsy

Personalized Fish Dog Toy: Crinkle Plushie Stuffie

Item highlights

  • Materials: minky, poly fill, polyester thread, squeaker, crinkle material
  • Made to order
  • Gift wrapping: Gift wrapping by FuzzyFurPaws

    Tissue paper or gift box and ribbon with card, stickers. Gift bags also may be used.

Seller's description

How cute is this puffy little fish? Dogs will love the crinkle noise maker. It’s super soft and squishy. Pongo @the.official.pongo loves his “Squishy” so much, he sleeps with it!

Personalization is optional. There is no price difference to add a name.

Multiple colors available.



Five Sizes to choose from. Small, (5 x 6) medium, (6 x 7) and large (7 x 8) and extra large (8 x 12). Measurements are approximate.

General turn around time is to seven to fourteen days, but could ship sooner.

If you want rush service, it is available on most items. Please message me about this special service before you order so that I can make sure I have everything needed in stock. There is a fee for this service. It will bump your order up in my cue, but the shipping will remain first class unless you opt for priority mail which would arrive in two to three business days of shipping.

Each of our toys are made from the absolute best, soft Minky fabrics. Each toy is hand stuffed with premium poly fill and crinkle inside. If you dog prefers a squeaker, just make a custom request.

Each toy is triple stitched for durability. The opening is ladder stitcinshed closed. Although I'm confident in the quality, some dogs are harder on their toys than others so please supervise your pets with toys at all times. NO TOY IS INDESTRUCTIBLE!!!

Washing Instructions: Please wash your Fuzzy Fur Paws toys once a week to keep them looking good and smelling clean. You dog will appreciate you for keeping them from building up with doggy slobbers. YUCKY!!!! Wash them with other toys in cold water. Tumble dry on low heat. (Super hot heat might damage the fibers).


Feel free to make custom order requests.

View more

Low in stock, only 7 left

Price:$15.95+

Please select an option

Please select a color

  • Enter the name you want embroidered on your item. Limited up to 10 letters.

    0/10

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Shipping & return policies
  • Cost to ship
    $5.95 to United States, 43215.

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

Reviews for this item

What buyers say, summarized by AI: Great quality Love it Looks great Helpful seller

5.0

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(32 reviews)

4.9 Item quality
4.9 Shipping
5.0 Customer service
100% Buyers recommend
Filter by category
5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Etsy buyer Jun 16, 2026

Another great purchase from Teresa. Milo loves this toy as well. Thank you for making a great product!

Etsy buyer Jun 16, 2026

Response from Teresa

That’s two for two!!! I am glad to hear Milo is enjoying his little fish! keep coming back!!! 💕

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Fran Nov 25, 2025

Teresa’s craftsmanship is excellent and a pleasure to deal with. Recommend her highly..

Fran Nov 25, 2025

Response from Teresa

Hi Fran, Thank you for this awesome review. It was nice working together on your item. Come back soon!

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Connie Aug 13, 2025

My new puppy love this toy

Connie Aug 13, 2025

Response from Teresa

That's wonderful Connie! I'm glad to hear your puppy is enjoying the toy. I appreciate your business and this kind review. ~TeresaI

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Etsy buyer Jul 23, 2025

Was told by his Grandmother that he's been playing with it. Thanks.

Etsy buyer Jul 23, 2025

Photos from reviews

Seller's description

Specifications

May include: A plush orange fish toy with a soft texture, featuring large white eyes with black pupils and a stitched black smile. The name Collin is embroidered in black thread on the side of the fish body, which has a fin and a tail.

How cute is this puffy little fish? Dogs will love the crinkle noise maker. It’s super soft and squishy. Pongo @the.official.pongo loves his “Squishy” so much, he sleeps with it!

Personalization is optional. There is no price difference to add a name.

Multiple colors available.



Five Sizes to choose from. Small, (5 x 6) medium, (6 x 7) and large (7 x 8) and extra large (8 x 12). Measurements are approximate.

General turn around time is to seven to fourteen days, but could ship sooner.

If you want rush service, it is available on most items. Please message me about this special service before you order so that I can make sure I have everything needed in stock. There is a fee for this service. It will bump your order up in my cue, but the shipping will remain first class unless you opt for priority mail which would arrive in two to three business days of shipping.

Each of our toys are made from the absolute best, soft Minky fabrics. Each toy is hand stuffed with premium poly fill and crinkle inside. If you dog prefers a squeaker, just make a custom request.

Each toy is triple stitched for durability. The opening is ladder stitcinshed closed. Although I'm confident in the quality, some dogs are harder on their toys than others so please supervise your pets with toys at all times. NO TOY IS INDESTRUCTIBLE!!!

Washing Instructions: Please wash your Fuzzy Fur Paws toys once a week to keep them looking good and smelling clean. You dog will appreciate you for keeping them from building up with doggy slobbers. YUCKY!!!! Wash them with other toys in cold water. Tumble dry on low heat. (Super hot heat might damage the fibers).


Feel free to make custom order requests.

  • Made by
    FuzzyFurPaws
  • Materials
    minky, poly fill, polyester thread, squeaker, crinkle material
  • Gift wrapping

    Available

    View details

    Gift wrapping by FuzzyFurPaws

    Tissue paper or gift box and ribbon with card, stickers. Gift bags also may be used.

Delivery details and policies

  • Get it by
    Nov 7-16
  • Returns and exchanges
    Not accepted.
  • Ships from
    Alexander, AR
  • Cost to ship
    $5.95 to United States, 43215

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Etsy Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back on all eligible purchases. View program terms

Climate investments

Etsy supports climate solutions, from electric delivery trucks to carbon offsets for every delivery. View how

Meet your seller

FuzzyFurPaws
Teresa
FuzzyFurPaws ·

Little Rock, Arkansas

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0
·
7.7k sales
·
16 years on Etsy
Teresa Ace
2 shop members

Usually responds in a few hours

Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

Shoppers with similar taste loved these

Show more
Show more
Listed on Oct 1, 2026
86 favorites
Homepage Pet Supplies Pet Toys Dog Toys

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy