BenchMarkCustomSigns

Metamora, Illinois

21.7k
 Sales

5.0 (4.8k)

14 years
on Etsy

5.0 (4.8k)

21.7k
 sales

14 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

21.7k
 Sales

5.0 (4.8k)

14 years
on Etsy

5.0 (4.8k)

21.7k
 sales

14 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

21696 Sales

6479 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Feb 1, 2023

Welcome to the BEST and FASTEST sign shop on Etsy. Personalized Family Name Signs make the best gifts. Use them for wedding gifts, anniversaries, man cave signs, newborn signs, engagement gifts, retirement gifts - you name it, I can make a carved sign for it. These aren’t just signs, they are family heirlooms.

I make custom signs carved into solid American hardwood. The names and images are carved deeply into the wood. The carving and finishing techniques produce an exceptionally high quality product that signs made by laser engraving, paint, or vinyl decals can simply never achieve.

Top reasons to buy your sign from me:

♠ FAST turnaround, no 21 day wait times like other shops.

♠ FREE proofs for every order.

♠ The BEST and most original designs on Etsy.

♠ I use only top grade genuine American hardwood. I don’t use knotty Pine, Poplar, MDF or any other low grade materials. The wood I use is the same as used for fine furniture.

♠ High quality carving. Light and shadow play off of the deeply carved facets, something that will never happen on painted signs or vinyl stickers. There is a considerable “wow factor” difference between carved signs and flat ones.

♠ High quality finish. I spray my signs with several coats of clear finish. Most shops do not put any finish on their signs after the carving or the application of stickers.

♠ This is a true one-man hand-made operation. There are no helpers or employees. When you buy a sign from me you are dealing with the designer, maker, packager, and floor sweeper.

These signs also make great gifts, for yourself or anyone you know; let me make one for you !

Contact shop owner

Phil

Reviews

5.0 (4756)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Maria on Jul 7, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

The vendor was very helpful fixing my issues and promptly respond to my request.

Family Name Sign Wood Established Sign Carved Wooden Sign Engagement Date Sign Carved Wedding Sign Benchmark Custom Signs LH-B

Family Name Sign Wood Established Sign Carved Wooden Sign Engagement Date Sign Carved Wedding Sign Benchmark Custom Signs LH-B
Etsy buyer on Jun 29, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This was a birthday gift for my husband, and it arrived timely and looks amazing and my husband loves it.

Personalized Gunsmith Workshop Sign; Custom Rifle Enthusiast Garage Decor; Handcrafted Wooden Hunting Plaque; Gift for Dad; CF-B

Personalized Gunsmith Workshop Sign; Custom Rifle Enthusiast Garage Decor; Handcrafted Wooden Hunting Plaque; Gift for Dad; CF-B
Chris on Jun 23, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great product. Shipped fast !

Craft Beer Sign Custom Bar Signs Personalized Pub Sign Guy Gift Custom Beer Sign Custom Pub Sign Benchmark Signs OJ-C

Craft Beer Sign Custom Bar Signs Personalized Pub Sign Guy Gift Custom Beer Sign Custom Pub Sign Benchmark Signs OJ-C
Melissa on Jun 14, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

We are so pleased with our new sign! The craftsmanship is beautiful. Phil provided me with two mockups with different wood colors so I could choose what I liked best. Great communication and the shipment packaging kept the sign completely protected. I would highly recommend purchasing your sign from Phil!

Rustic Pine Tree Cabin Sign; Personalized Family Name Lake House Welcome Plaque; Handcrafted Wooden Carved Decor, Custom Lodge Sign, TL-W

Rustic Pine Tree Cabin Sign; Personalized Family Name Lake House Welcome Plaque; Handcrafted Wooden Carved Decor, Custom Lodge Sign, TL-W
Bonnie on Jun 9, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Came fast and just what I wanted

Personalized Family Name Sign Custom Wedding Gift As for me and my house we will serve the Lord Joshua 24:15 carved wood sign SM-W

Personalized Family Name Sign Custom Wedding Gift As for me and my house we will serve the Lord Joshua 24:15 carved wood sign SM-W
Carrie on Jun 7, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

The craftsmanship is amazing, the wood quality is beautiful. Exceeded my expectations. I ordered this for a wedding gift and now my husband wants one for us! Thank you for sharing your craft with us. Highly recommend!

Irish Name Sign Family Name Sign Carved Wooden Sign Benchmark Custom Signs SK-W

Irish Name Sign Family Name Sign Carved Wooden Sign Benchmark Custom Signs SK-W
Gary on Jun 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Exactly what we wanted and I'm sure the family we are gifting it to will love it and give it a prominent place in their new home.

Personalized Family Name Sign Custom Wedding Gift As for me and my house we will serve the Lord Joshua 24:15 carved wood sign ST-W

Personalized Family Name Sign Custom Wedding Gift As for me and my house we will serve the Lord Joshua 24:15 carved wood sign ST-W
Sara on May 28, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I bought this as a wedding present but after seeing it I want one for myself now. it's gorgeous 😍

Family Name Sign Wood Established Sign Personalized Sign Carved Wooden Sign Engagement Date Sign Benchmark Custom Signs AA-W

Family Name Sign Wood Established Sign Personalized Sign Carved Wooden Sign Engagement Date Sign Benchmark Custom Signs AA-W
John on May 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Phil did a stunning job, the engraving is strong and the Cherry wood works great. The perfect wedding gift or for an Anniversary.

Family Name Sign Wood Established Sign Personalized Sign Carved Wooden Sign Engagement Date Sign Benchmark Custom Signs AA-W

Family Name Sign Wood Established Sign Personalized Sign Carved Wooden Sign Engagement Date Sign Benchmark Custom Signs AA-W
Etsy buyer on May 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Better than anticipated. I lost my brother January 29th, 2026. This sign will be displayed with honor in his memorial garden. Thanks again for such an amazing piece of artwork!

Marine Corps Sign Retirement Gift Personalized Military Sign MS-W

Marine Corps Sign Retirement Gift Personalized Military Sign MS-W

About BenchMarkCustomSigns

Personalized Family Name and other Custom Wooden Signs

Sales 21,696

On Etsy since 2011

Personalized Family Name and other Custom Wooden Signs

Original high quality designs, you won't find this high quality or designs like this anywhere else !
I use only the top grade of genuine American hardwood. I don’t use knotty Pine, Polar, Cedar, MDF, or palowena
I spray my signs with many coats of high grade finish, most shops do not put any finish on their signs after lettering
I use a technique known as V-carving. This produces a far superior product as compared to pocket carving or painting
The detail is much sharper, the carving is deeper and reflects light off of the carved facets

Personalized Family Name Signs Wood Signs Custom Signs

Top reasons to buy your sign from me:

♠ FAST turnaround, no 8 or 21 day wait times like other shops.

♠ FREE proofs for every order.

♠ The BEST most original designs on Etsy.

♠ I use only top grade genuine American hardwood. I don’t use knotty Pine, Poplar, MDF or any other low grade materials. The wood I use is the same as used for fine furniture.

♠ High quality carving. Light and shadow play off of the deeply carved facets, something that will never happen on painted signs or vinyl stickers. There is a considerable “wow factor” difference between carved signs and flat ones.

♠ High quality finish. I spray my signs with several coats of clear finish. Most shops do not put any finish on their signs after the carving or the application of stickers.

♠ This is a true one-man hand-made operation. There are no helpers or employees. When you buy a sign from me you are dealing with the designer, maker, packager, and floor sweeper.

These signs also make great gifts, for yourself or anyone you know; let me make one for you !

Copyright Benchmark Custom Signs / Benchmark Signs, all rights reserved.

Shop members

Phil

Owner

My name is Phil and I operate BenchMark Custom Signs and Wonders. I live out in the country in Central Illinois.

Shop policies

Last updated on December 17, 2025

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

BenchMarkCustomSigns

Featured items

Family Name Sign Wood Established Sign Carved Wooden Sign Engagement Date Sign Carved Wedding Sign Benchmark Custom Signs LH-W

Family Name Sign Custom Cabin Sign Lakehouse Sign Lake House Sign Wooden Last Name Sign Hunting Lodge Retreat Benchmark Custom Signs TE-C

Anniversary Gift For Parents Custom Wooden Signs Personalized Family Established Sign Last Name Plaque Easy to Hang Realtor Gift GV-K

Custom Man Cave Sign Guy Cave Sign Little Man Cave Sign Carved Wooden Sign Man Cave Sign Garage Sign Benchmark Signs CA2-B

All items

Lake House Gift; Personalized Cabin Sign with Pine Trees; Rustic Family Name Plaque; Mountain Retreat Housewarming Present; TN-C

Lake House Gift; Personalized Cabin Sign with Oars; Handcrafted Rustic Carved Wooden Plaque; Established Date Housewarming; LC-W

Mountain Cabin Gift; Personalized Ski Chalet Sign with Elevation; Rustic Carved Wooden Plaque; Alpine Retreat Housewarming; TM-K

Lake House Gift; Personalized Cabin Wall Decor; Rustic Carved Wooden Plaque; Hunting Lodge Housewarming Present; River Retreat; TC3-C

Cabin Gift; Personalized Lake House Sign with Pine Trees; Rustic Carved Wooden Plaque; Country Cottage Housewarming Present; TE3-B

Lake Cabin Gift; Personalized Hunting Lodge Sign with Canoe; Rustic Carved Wooden Plaque; Vacation Home Housewarming Present; TK-K

Beach House Gift; Personalized Coastal Family Name Sign; Handcrafted Pineapple Welcome Plaque; Nautical Housewarming Decor; TP-C

Gifts For Men Golf Clubhouse Sign; Personalized 19th Hole Display Art; Custom Golfer Decor; Carved Wooden Man Cave Plaques; NH-B

Gifts For Grandpa Woodworking; Personalized Carpenter Hand Plane Sign; Custom Workshop Decor; Carved Wooden Man Cave Display; SD-C

Gifts For Papa Woodworking Sign; Personalized Carpenter Workshop; Custom Grandparent Decor; Carved Wooden Man Cave Display; SD-K

Groomsmen Gift Music Bar Sign; Personalized Guitar Man Cave Display Art; Custom Wedding Decor; Carved Wooden Rustic Plaque; GR-B

Molon Labe Sign, Gifts For Real Men; Personalized Gun Room Display; Custom Hunter Shooting Decor Art; Carved Wooden Man Cave Plaque; AM2-C

Gifts For Men Automotive Garage Sign; Personalized Motorcycle Workshop; Custom Mechanic Decor; Carved Wooden Man Cave Display; AP-B

Gifts For Men Workshop Door Sign; Personalized Garage Entry Display; Custom Mechanic Shed Art; Carved Wooden Man Cave Plaque; DH-C

Gifts For Dad Vintage Garage Sign; Personalized Workshop Mechanic Display; Custom Man Cave Decor Art; Carved Wooden Retro Bar; CA2-K

Gifts For Dad Woodworking; Personalized Carpenter Hand Plane Sign; Custom Craftsman Workshop; Carved Wooden Man Cave Decor; SD-B

Gifts For Grandpa Workshop Sign; Personalized Garage Hand Wrench Display; Custom Mechanic Decor Art; Carved Wooden Man Cave; FW-K

Gifts For Men Motorcycle Flag Sign; Personalized Biker Garage Display; Custom Bike Chain Design Art; Carved Wooden Man Cave; WK-B

Gifts For Dad Garage Workshop Sign; Personalized Retro Mechanic Plaque; Custom Biker Decor; Carved Wooden Man Cave Display; GW-B/

Gifts For Men Wrench Flag Design; Personalized Garage Workshop Sign; Custom Mechanic Tools; Carved Wooden Motorcycle Decor; WR-B

Personalized Guitar Studio Sign; Rock Star Man Cave Decor; Handcrafted Wooden Music Room Plaque; Musician Gift; Bar Wall Art; GR-C

Personalized Gunsmith Workshop Sign; Custom Rifle Enthusiast Garage Decor; Handcrafted Wooden Hunting Plaque; Gift for Dad; CF-B

Personalized Motorcycle Garage Sign; Custom Workshop Decor for Papa; Handcrafted Wooden Man Cave Plaque; Unique Grandparent Gift; GW-C

Personalized Garage Workshop Sign; Custom Man Cave Decor; Handcrafted Rustic Wooden Plaque; Unique Vintage Style Gift for Him; BG3-B

Personalized Vocalist Studio Sign; Rock Star Microphone Decor; Handcrafted Wooden Music Room Plaque; Singer Gift; Bar Wall Art; RE-C

Personalized Biker Garage Sign; Custom Motorcycle Workshop Decor; Handcrafted Wooden Man Cave Plaque; Unique Gift for Dad; DS2-B

Custom Cigar Lounge Sign; Personalized Smoking Room Decor; Groomsman Gift; Handcrafted Wooden Bar Plaque; Rustic Man Cave Art; SF-B

Billiards Gift; Custom Pool Hall Decor; Carved Wooden Victorian Man Cave; Groomsman Present; Gentleman's Game Fathers Day; KR2-B

Fathers Day Gift; Man Shed Decor; Carved Wooden Workshop; Personalized Garage Bar; Custom Retreat Beer Enthusiast Presents; DS-W

Garage Gift; Custom Workshop Decor; Carved Wooden Man Cave; Full Throttle Fathers Day Present; Personalized Automotive Gearhead; CA-B

Baseball Gift; Groomsman Present; Carved Wooden Man Cave; Crossed Bats Decor; Vintage Sports Enthusiast Personalized Game Room; BT-B

Motorcycle Gift; Custom Bar Sign; Carved Wooden Garage Decor; Biker Man Cave; Full Throttle Birthday Present Harley Rider Gifts; BJ-B

Veteran Retirement Gift; Personalized American Flag Sign; Carved Wooden Patriotic Decor; Military Man Cave Navy Army Marines; UM-B

Bar Gift Beer Mug Sign; Custom Carved Brewery Plaque; Personalized Rustic Pub Decor; Handcrafted Wooden Tavern Art; Man Cave; JB2-B

Groomsmen Gift Whiskey Locker Sign; Personalized Tavern Plaque; Custom Home Bar Decor; Handcrafted Wooden Pub Art; Man Cave; RB2-K

Wedding Gift Saloon Plaque; Custom Carved Western Tavern Sign; Personalized Rustic Bar Decor; Handcrafted Wood Art; Man Cave; RB2-C

Announcement

Reviews

About BenchMarkCustomSigns

Shop members

Phil

Shop policies

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations