Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

CaitlinsCustomPaints

United States

29
 Sales

3 years
on Etsy

29
 sales

3 years
on Etsy

Following Follow

29
 Sales

3 years
on Etsy

29
 sales

3 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

Hand-painted Custom Banner: Personalized Party and Event Decor

Hand-painted Custom Banner: Personalized Party and Event Decor

$40.00

All items

Hand-painted “TWO sweet” Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted “TWO sweet” Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-painted Simple Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Simple Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$40.00

Hand-painted Santa Letter 16X20in banner: Personalized Christmas Banner and Event Decor

Hand-painted Santa Letter 16X20in banner: Personalized Christmas Banner and Event Decor

$18.00

Hand-Painted "Last Toast on the Coast" Bachelorette Banner: Kraft Paper

Hand-Painted "Last Toast on the Coast" Bachelorette Banner: Kraft Paper

$45.00

Hand-painted Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$50.00

Hand-painted “Putters or Pearls” Gender Reveal Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted “Putters or Pearls” Gender Reveal Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-painted Custom Banner: Personalized Party and Event Decor

Hand-painted Custom Banner: Personalized Party and Event Decor

$40.00

Hand-Painted “ Boo” Trick or Treat Bags

Hand-Painted “ Boo” Trick or Treat Bags

$5.00

Hand-Painted “ Boo” Trick or Treat Bags {with Bow}

Hand-Painted “ Boo” Trick or Treat Bags {with Bow}

$5.00

Hand-Painted “ Blue Chinoiserie Tree” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “ Blue Chinoiserie Tree” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Ginger Jar” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Ginger Jar” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Chinoiserie Merry Christmas” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Chinoiserie Merry Christmas” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted "Last Sail before the Veil" Bachelorette Banner: Kraft Paper

Hand-Painted "Last Sail before the Veil" Bachelorette Banner: Kraft Paper

$45.00

Hand-Painted “Nativity” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Nativity” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Girl’s First Christmas” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Girl’s First Christmas” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Chinoiserie Topiary” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Chinoiserie Topiary” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Boy’s First Christmas” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Boy’s First Christmas” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-painted “Galentine’s”(with cherries) Valentine Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted “Galentine’s”(with cherries) Valentine Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-painted “Galentine’s” Valentine Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted “Galentine’s” Valentine Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-Painted Valentine’s Gift or Treat Bags

Hand-Painted Valentine’s Gift or Treat Bags

$8.00

Hand-painted Simple Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Simple Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$40.00

Hand-Painted “Merry” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Merry” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Chinoiserie Tree” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Chinoiserie Tree” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Snowman” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Snowman” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Gingerbread” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Gingerbread” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Reindeer” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Reindeer” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-Painted “Santa” Wood Ornament

Hand-Painted “Santa” Wood Ornament

$15.00

Hand-painted “Berry First Birthday” Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted “Berry First Birthday” Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-painted Barbie Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Barbie Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-painted Mermaid Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Mermaid Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-painted 21st Floral Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted 21st Floral Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-painted Simple Balloon Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Simple Balloon Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Hand-painted Barbie themed Bachelorette Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Barbie themed Bachelorette Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$50.00

Hand-painted Dog themed Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Dog themed Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$50.00

Hand-painted Wood Valentines Tags- Personalized tags

Hand-painted Wood Valentines Tags- Personalized tags

$10.00

Hand-painted Valentine’s Day Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Valentine’s Day Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

$45.00

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Sep 16, 2025

✨ Welcome to Caitlin's Custom Paints✨
A curated collection of custom, hand-painted banners designed to elevate your most cherished moments.

Each piece is thoughtfully created to add a personal and artistic touch to your celebrations — from intimate gatherings to grand events. Whether you're honoring a birthday, marking a milestone, or decorating for the season, our banners are crafted to reflect the beauty and uniqueness of your occasion.

🎨 Completely customizable — Select your colors, message, and design details, and allow me to bring your vision to life.

Perfect for:
• Elegant birthday celebrations
• Weddings, showers, and anniversaries
• Seasonal and holiday décor
• Corporate events and special occasions
• Heirloom-style keepsakes

🖋️ Hand-painted with intention, care, and artistry — because every detail matters.

Thank you for choosing to support handcrafted design. I look forward to creating something truly special for you.

With gratitude,
Caitlin with Caitlin's Custom Paints

Caitlin

Contact shop owner

Caitlin

Reviews

5.0 (8)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Loading

A on Mar 13, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

She’s 2/2! No disappointments! So talented and kind

Caitlin responded on Mar 19, 2026

Thank you so much!! You are too kind! 🥰💕

Hand-painted Custom Banner: Personalized Party and Event Decor

Hand-painted Custom Banner: Personalized Party and Event Decor
Ashley on Feb 12, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

My goodness! This is adorable and arrived quickly! Seller was great to work with and ensured it arrived before Valentine's Day!

Hand-Painted Valentine’s Gift or Treat Bags

Hand-Painted Valentine’s Gift or Treat Bags
A on Feb 9, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Amazing !! Ordering every chance I get 🥰

Hand-painted “Galentine’s” Valentine Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted “Galentine’s” Valentine Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners
Kelley on Jan 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

The seller was very easy to work with and extremely responsive to my questions prior to placing my order and also after I placed my order. The banner was perfect and exactly as pictured on her site. I would highly recommend this seller!

Caitlin responded on Jan 22, 2026

Thank you so much for your kind words! ❤️ It was a pleasure!

Hand-painted Simple Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted Simple Birthday Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners
Tiffany on Jan 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

So cute! Well made, quality material that will last. Exactly as pictured.

Caitlin responded on Jan 22, 2026

Thank you so much for your order! It was a pleasure! ❤️

Hand-painted Wood Valentines Tags- Personalized tags

Hand-painted Wood Valentines Tags- Personalized tags
Larra on Nov 27, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

She confirmed what I wanted and it was perfect shipped fast definitely would use her again!

Caitlin responded on Dec 6, 2025

Thank you so much for your order and I really appreciate your wonderful review! 💕

Hand-painted “Putters or Pearls” Gender Reveal Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted “Putters or Pearls” Gender Reveal Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners
Robin on Apr 17, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

The verse is perfect. Thank you!

Beauty from Ashes sublimation file, shirt png design, Sublimation design, Digital download

Beauty from Ashes sublimation file, shirt png design, Sublimation design, Digital download
Etsy buyer on Jan 29, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Hand-painted “Putters or Pearls” Gender Reveal Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

Hand-painted “Putters or Pearls” Gender Reveal Banner: Hand-Painted Kraft Paper Banners

About CaitlinsCustomPaints

Customizable Hand-Painted Banners

Sales 29

On Etsy since 2023

Customizable Hand-Painted Banners

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.