Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

CustomCritterDesigns

United States

7k
 Sales

14 years
on Etsy

7k
 sales

14 years
on Etsy

Following Follow

7k
 Sales

14 years
on Etsy

7k
 sales

14 years
on Etsy

Request Custom Order

Contact shop owner

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

AFTG Neil and Andrew - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

AFTG Neil and Andrew - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $28.05

Original Price $33.00 (15% off)

Derpy Tiger & Sussie Plush Keychain

Derpy Tiger & Sussie Plush Keychain

Sale Price $13.60

Original Price $16.00 (15% off)

Froggy Plush Keychain

Froggy Plush Keychain

Sale Price $12.32

Original Price $14.50 (15% off)

Dragon Treasure - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Dragon Treasure - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $27.37

Original Price $32.20 (15% off)

All items

AFTG Andrew & Neil - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

AFTG Andrew & Neil - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $17.85

Original Price $21.00 (15% off)

Beetle Plush Keychain

Beetle Plush Keychain

Sale Price $12.75

Original Price $15.00 (15% off)

Chicken Plush Keychain

Chicken Plush Keychain

Sale Price $14.45

Original Price $17.00 (15% off)

Sleepy Bat Plush Keychain

Sleepy Bat Plush Keychain

Sale Price $11.47

Original Price $13.50 (15% off)

Froggy Plush Keychain

Froggy Plush Keychain

Sale Price $12.32

Original Price $14.50 (15% off)

Alone At Last OLS - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Alone At Last OLS - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $28.90

Original Price $34.00 (15% off)

Cats & Bookshelves - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Cats & Bookshelves - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $26.60

Original Price $31.30 (15% off)

WLW Bookish Couples - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

WLW Bookish Couples - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $13.85

Original Price $16.30 (15% off)

Button Closure Add-On

Button Closure Add-On

Sale Price $4.25

Original Price $5.00 (15% off)

FREE shipping

Cemetery Boys Trio - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Cemetery Boys Trio - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $13.85

Original Price $16.30 (15% off)

Serpent & Dove Trio - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Serpent & Dove Trio - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $13.60

Original Price $16.00 (15% off)

Maia & Edan 5x7 Art Print

Maia & Edan 5x7 Art Print

Sale Price $9.39

Original Price $11.05 (15% off)

Squad 312 - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Squad 312 - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $20.40

Original Price $24.00 (15% off)

Aurora Cycle - Faux Knot Headband

Aurora Cycle - Faux Knot Headband

Sale Price $6.80

Original Price $8.00 (15% off)

Ren Faire Fun Wayward Son 7x5.5 Art Print

Ren Faire Fun Wayward Son 7x5.5 Art Print

Sale Price $9.35

Original Price $11.00 (15% off)

Spring Bunnies - Quilted Carry-All Bag - Makeup Bag -Cosmetic Bag - Project Bag

Spring Bunnies - Quilted Carry-All Bag - Makeup Bag -Cosmetic Bag - Project Bag

Sale Price $34.00

Original Price $40.00 (15% off)

Succulents - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Succulents - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $26.60

Original Price $31.30 (15% off)

Spring Collection #1 - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Spring Collection #1 - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $26.60

Original Price $31.30 (15% off)

On The Roof AFTG 7x5.5 Art Print

On The Roof AFTG 7x5.5 Art Print

Sale Price $10.20

Original Price $12.00 (15% off)

Her Raven Boys - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Her Raven Boys - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $28.90

Original Price $34.00 (15% off)

Ronan & Adam Tarot - The Raven Cycle - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Ronan & Adam Tarot - The Raven Cycle - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $10.20

Original Price $12.00 (15% off)

Sleepy Andreil - AFTG - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sleepy Andreil - AFTG - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $27.20

Original Price $32.00 (15% off)

You Gave Me a Key & Called It Home - AFTG - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

You Gave Me a Key & Called It Home - AFTG - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $27.45

Original Price $32.30 (15% off)

Lazy Afternoon - AFTG - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Lazy Afternoon - AFTG - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $27.45

Original Price $32.30 (15% off)

You Gave Me a Key & Called It Home AFTG 7x5.5 Art Print

You Gave Me a Key & Called It Home AFTG 7x5.5 Art Print

Sale Price $10.20

Original Price $12.00 (15% off)

Derpy Tiger & Sussie Plush Keychain

Derpy Tiger & Sussie Plush Keychain

Sale Price $13.60

Original Price $16.00 (15% off)

AFTG Yes Or No - Wristlet Keychain

AFTG Yes Or No - Wristlet Keychain

Sale Price $13.60

Original Price $16.00 (15% off)

Knife Duck Plush Keychain

Knife Duck Plush Keychain

Sale Price $14.45

Original Price $17.00 (15% off)

Bunny Plush Keychain

Bunny Plush Keychain

Sale Price $14.45

Original Price $17.00 (15% off)

Soot Sprite Plush Keychain

Soot Sprite Plush Keychain

Sale Price $13.17

Original Price $15.50 (15% off)

Cabeswater/Magical Forest - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Cabeswater/Magical Forest - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $27.20

Original Price $32.00 (15% off)

Krobus Stardew Valley Plush Keychain

Krobus Stardew Valley Plush Keychain

Sale Price $11.47

Original Price $13.50 (15% off)

Yadriel & Julian Tarot - Cemetery Boys - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Yadriel & Julian Tarot - Cemetery Boys - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $29.15

Original Price $34.30 (15% off)

Wizard & The Hatter - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Wizard & The Hatter - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $27.37

Original Price $32.20 (15% off)

Dragon Scales - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Dragon Scales - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Sale Price $27.37

Original Price $32.20 (15% off)

Reusable Paperless Towels - Choose Your Print! - 6 Pack

Reusable Paperless Towels - Choose Your Print! - 6 Pack

Sale Price $9.35

Original Price $11.00 (15% off)

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Nov 27, 2024

*NEW* 11/24 - Please note that due to the busy nature of the holidays we cannot guarantee holiday delivery. if you need something by a certain date please contact us before ordering!

Also due to the new GPSR we will be unable to ship to several EU countries. We unfortunately have to include the UK due to not being able to separate locations in shipping. Once this option becomes available we will resume! Until the 1st of December if you need to order something but are unable due to shipping please contact us for a listing.

Thank you so much for the support!

If you have any questions about made to order items or other questions please let me know!

*Please be sure to check out the shop updates section~ I will be posting there with new items and listings as they become available :)

CUSTOM ORDERS ARE OPEN!! :D If you are interested in something specific that I have not done before, please let me know! I love working on new things :)

Due to the number of orders I receive, processing times will be between 2-4 weeks to insure orders are completed and shipped out in a timely manner. If you have any questions please let me know!

Thank you all so much for your patience and support! ***

------------------------------

All Items are from a non-smoking, Pet friendly home - If you have severe allergies please let me know!
My pets are not in direct contact with these items but their hair may get on the packages.

Rikkuliam

Contact shop owner

Rikkuliam

Reviews

5.0 (3120)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Loading

Ferroxil on May 20, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

So adorable! I absolutely love my little star bat. It did take a bit longer to arrive than it originally said but that was not anything the seller did, just ups being ups. The material is so soft and everything well made. I just wish it was a taaad bit bigger but all in all perfect!

Sleepy Bat Plush Keychain

Sleepy Bat Plush Keychain
Keys on May 5, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Super cute and came with a nice thank you card! Highly recommend

Sleepy Bat Plush Keychain

Sleepy Bat Plush Keychain
Rea'ann on Jan 30, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I got this for my friend who got me into the AFTG series. She loves books and absolutely loves Neil and Andrew, so this was a perfect combination gift for her.

AFTG Andrew & Neil - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

AFTG Andrew & Neil - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover
Brooklyn on Jan 13, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

this is so good! love andreil and wanted to have a cute book protector so this is perfect. the material is soft, and the design is cute!

AFTG Andrew & Neil - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

AFTG Andrew & Neil - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover
Etsy buyer on Apr 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Second book cover I have purchased and I just love them both!

Cabeswater/Magical Forest - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover

Cabeswater/Magical Forest - Dust Jacket, Book Protector, Book Cover
K.O. on Mar 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Eeeeeeee love this item never been happier. It’s so cute carrying my lil Krobs on my keys 🖤🖤🖤🖤 I love how fluffy he is

Krobus Stardew Valley Plush Keychain

Krobus Stardew Valley Plush Keychain
Sara on Mar 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is such a beautiful little print!

He Is Half Of My Soul TSOA 5x7 Art Print

He Is Half Of My Soul TSOA 5x7 Art Print
Sara on Mar 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is the first book sleeve I've ever purchased, but I just loved the pattern of Achilles and Patroclus!

TSOA Half My Soul - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover

TSOA Half My Soul - Book Sleeve, Book Pouch, Tablet Sleeve, Book Protector, Book Cover
Etsy buyer on Mar 16, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I almost pterodactyl screamed it’s so cute and fuzzy. It’s palm sized and just the cutest little accessory

Sleepy Bat Plush Keychain

Sleepy Bat Plush Keychain
Trinket on Mar 7, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

He's perfect, I love him so much.

Krobus Stardew Valley Plush Keychain

Krobus Stardew Valley Plush Keychain

About CustomCritterDesigns

Bookish Art & Book Sleeves

Sales 7,011

On Etsy since 2011

Bookish Art & Book Sleeves

Shop policies

Last updated on Jul 10, 2023

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 24 hours of purchase

Privacy policy