Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

CustomCutterShoppe

St Louis, Missouri

156
 Sales

10 months
on Etsy

156
 sales

10 months
on Etsy

Following Follow

156
 Sales

10 months
on Etsy

156
 sales

10 months
on Etsy

Request Custom Order

Contact shop owner

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

Pizza Delivery Guy Cookie Cutter (B.21)

Pizza Delivery Guy Cookie Cutter (B.21)

$5.00

Special Delivery Sign Cookie Cutter (B.17)

Special Delivery Sign Cookie Cutter (B.17)

$5.00

Mug Custom Cookie Cutter ( F.06)

Mug Custom Cookie Cutter ( F.06)

$5.00

Princess Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Princess Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

All items

Custom Cookie Cutter Playset – 3D Printed Baking Tools, Mix-and-Match Designs

Custom Cookie Cutter Playset – 3D Printed Baking Tools, Mix-and-Match Designs

$1.25

4 people have this in their cart

Custom PlaySet (CC.01)

Custom PlaySet (CC.01)

$35.00

FREE shipping

Custom Key Chain

Custom Key Chain

$5.00

Monster Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Monster Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Custom PlaySet (CC.04)

Custom PlaySet (CC.04)

$45.00

FREE shipping

Custom Cookie Cutter (CC.00) Standard Size 3.5” to 4”

Custom Cookie Cutter (CC.00) Standard Size 3.5” to 4”

$5.00

5 people have this in their cart

Halloween Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Halloween Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Happy High Birthday Theme cookie cutter set - (Set of 3)

Happy High Birthday Theme cookie cutter set - (Set of 3)

$10.00

Bride and Bride Tribe Hype Chain Necklace

Bride and Bride Tribe Hype Chain Necklace

$20.00

Super Sized Lucky Clover Necklace

Super Sized Lucky Clover Necklace

$20.00

Dinosaur Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Dinosaur Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

8 people have this in their cart

Under the Sea Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Under the Sea Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Custom Toy Block Letter Wall Name Display

Custom Toy Block Letter Wall Name Display

$12.99

Happy Birthday Custom Cookie Cutter and Stamp( BB.06) - large 6x4

Happy Birthday Custom Cookie Cutter and Stamp( BB.06) - large 6x4

$10.00

Book cookie cutter

Book cookie cutter

$5.00

Flamingo Cookie Cutter (C.09)

Flamingo Cookie Cutter (C.09)

$5.00

Fruit Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Fruit Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Veggie Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Veggie Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Ice Cream Cookie Cutter Set – 3D Printed PLA+, Food Safe (Set of 4)

Ice Cream Cookie Cutter Set – 3D Printed PLA+, Food Safe (Set of 4)

$16.00

Ice Cream Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Ice Cream Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Christmas House Cookie Cutter Set | Gingerbread Village Cookies | Holiday Family Tradition

Christmas House Cookie Cutter Set | Gingerbread Village Cookies | Holiday Family Tradition

$28.00

Wedding Bundle of 12 Standard Sized Cookie Cutters, STL Digital File

Wedding Bundle of 12 Standard Sized Cookie Cutters, STL Digital File

$4.00

Digital Download

Cowboy Hat Custom Cookie Cutter (BC.01)

Cowboy Hat Custom Cookie Cutter (BC.01)

$5.00

Arrowhead Custom Cookie Cutter ( SF.04)

Arrowhead Custom Cookie Cutter ( SF.04)

$5.00

Bug Friends Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Bug Friends Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

4 people have this in their cart

Princess Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Princess Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Cheers to 21 Years Cookie Cutter STL Digital file

Cheers to 21 Years Cookie Cutter STL Digital file

$2.00

Digital Download

Plant support

$5.00

ReptileThemed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

ReptileThemed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Bear in Balloon Custom Cookie Cutter (B.14)

Bear in Balloon Custom Cookie Cutter (B.14)

$5.00

Wild West Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Wild West Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Digital File - 40 Mini Christmas Cookie Cutters - Perfect for Christmas Cookie advent calendars. No size longer than 2”

Digital File - 40 Mini Christmas Cookie Cutters - Perfect for Christmas Cookie advent calendars. No size longer than 2”

$10.00

Digital Download

Mini Christmas Cookie Cutters - Perfect for Christmas Cookie advent calendars. No size longer than 2”

Mini Christmas Cookie Cutters - Perfect for Christmas Cookie advent calendars. No size longer than 2”

$1.50

Construction Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Construction Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Tea Party Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Tea Party Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

$15.00

Super Sized “6 7” Necklace

Super Sized “6 7” Necklace

$20.00

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on May 9, 2026

Tricia Reeves

Contact shop owner

Tricia Reeves

Reviews

4.9 (34)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Loading

Sarah on Jun 26, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

these turned out SO cute for my daughter's first birthday party - I messaged the sellers and they were able to let me pick out my design & color! Will order again!

Tricia responded on Jun 26, 2026

Os glad they worked out for the party!! Happy to help and be a part of that special day!

Custom Cookie Cutter Playset – 3D Printed Baking Tools, Mix-and-Match Designs

Custom Cookie Cutter Playset – 3D Printed Baking Tools, Mix-and-Match Designs
Jennifer on May 4, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great customer service. Fash shipping

Tricia responded on May 5, 2026

Thank you! Appreciate you taking time to provide your review.

Custom Cookie Cutter (CC.00) Standard Size 3.5” to 4”

Custom Cookie Cutter (CC.00) Standard Size 3.5” to 4”
Robert on Jun 25, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

We ordered 20 cookie cutters and everyone loves them. We made 1000 dog treats with them for our church!

Tricia responded on Jun 25, 2026

I am so glad they worked out for you all and really enjoyed seeing the pictures back with the final outcome, Thank you for sharing!! Appreciate you taking time out of your day to provide this review!

Custom Cookie Cutter (CC.00) Standard Size 1.5” - 2.5”

Custom Cookie Cutter (CC.00) Standard Size 1.5” - 2.5”
Amelia on Jun 18, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

My nephew loved them! His favorite was the shark cutter!

Tricia responded on Jun 18, 2026

So glad to hear that!

Under the Sea Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Under the Sea Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy
KSAMOSKA on Jun 13, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

excellent customer service products very well made, good variety of items to shop Items shipped and received in an within a very reasonable time as well. very nicely done.

Tricia responded on Jun 13, 2026

Thank you for the wonderful feedback, it is much appreciated. enjoy your product!!!!

Bug Friends Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy

Bug Friends Themed Kids Play Dough Kit, Sensory Play Kit, Montessori Toy, Gift for Kids, Creative Play Set, Preschool Learning Toy
Tracy on Jun 9, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Everything was of great quality

Tricia responded on Jun 9, 2026

Great! so glad they worked for you. let me know if you ever need anything that you can not find and I can work them up for you!

Wedding Bundle of 12 Standard Sized Cookie Cutters, STL Digital File

Wedding Bundle of 12 Standard Sized Cookie Cutters, STL Digital File
Etsy buyer on Jun 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

the quality of the cookie cutter was fantastic. very sturdy

Wedding Themed 3D printed Cookie Cutters, You pick quantity, design, size

Wedding Themed 3D printed Cookie Cutters, You pick quantity, design, size
Etsy buyer on Jun 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

the quality of the cookie cutter was spot on.

Tricia responded on Jun 2, 2026

Thank you for the review and that is great to hear they worked well for you!

Wedding Themed 3D printed Cookie Cutters, You pick quantity, design, size

Wedding Themed 3D printed Cookie Cutters, You pick quantity, design, size
elina on Apr 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Amazing quality and great way to keep busy

Tricia responded on Apr 22, 2026

THANK You! You are too kind. Hope the kiddos enjoy spending time with them.

Transportation Themed Play Set for Dough, clay, cookies, stencils with storage bag - 13 pieces theme set with roller included.

Transportation Themed Play Set for Dough, clay, cookies, stencils with storage bag - 13 pieces theme set with roller included.
elina on Apr 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

The customer service is absolutely amazing! She was so sweet and the items came in so fast that I ordered two more packages following that. We have a blast with these and not to mention the qualities is absolutely amazing. I completely underestimated what was on its way and when I got the package, I’ve never seen better quality.

Tricia responded on Apr 21, 2026

Thank you so much for the super kind words and support of our small business. So glad you all enjoy them. Please reach out whenever you need anything!

Christmas Dough Cutter Set, Kid Play Clay, 12 Piece with Storage Bag

Christmas Dough Cutter Set, Kid Play Clay, 12 Piece with Storage Bag

About CustomCutterShoppe

3D Printed Custom Products

Sales 156

On Etsy since 2025

3D Printed Custom Products

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.