PaperShay

Georgia, United States

22.5k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (4.1k)
15 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (4.1k)
22.5k
sales
15 years
on Etsy
22.5k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (4.1k)
15 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (4.1k)
22.5k
sales
15 years
on Etsy
Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
22521 Sales
3858 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

Personalized Playing Cards with Cupcake Design – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift for game Lovers

Personalized Playing Cards with Cupcake Design – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift for game Lovers

CA$31.68

In My Pickleball Era Platter, Retro Era Pickleball Serving Plate, Pool Side, Outdoor Dinner Party, Dinnerware for Hosting and on the Court

In My Pickleball Era Platter, Retro Era Pickleball Serving Plate, Pool Side, Outdoor Dinner Party, Dinnerware for Hosting and on the Court

CA$25.92

Enclosure Gift Cards, Gift Tags or Stickers, Floral Calling Cards, Favor Tags

Enclosure Gift Cards, Gift Tags or Stickers, Floral Calling Cards, Favor Tags

CA$21.60

Mahjong Personalized NOTEPAD with Name, Mahjong Memo Pad Thank You Notes Feminine Notepad, Game Lovers Gift

Mahjong Personalized NOTEPAD with Name, Mahjong Memo Pad Thank You Notes Feminine Notepad, Game Lovers Gift

CA$20.16

Floral Stationary Set for Women Personalized Thank You Cards Watercolor Tulip Stationery, Customized Thank You Notes Floral Thank You

Floral Stationary Set for Women Personalized Thank You Cards Watercolor Tulip Stationery, Customized Thank You Notes Floral Thank You

CA$23.04

Personalized Playing Cards with Cupcake Design – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift for game Lovers

Personalized Playing Cards with Cupcake Design – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift for game Lovers

CA$31.68

In My Pickleball Era Platter, Retro Era Pickleball Serving Plate, Pool Side, Outdoor Dinner Party, Dinnerware for Hosting and on the Court

In My Pickleball Era Platter, Retro Era Pickleball Serving Plate, Pool Side, Outdoor Dinner Party, Dinnerware for Hosting and on the Court

CA$25.92

Enclosure Gift Cards, Gift Tags or Stickers, Floral Calling Cards, Favor Tags

Enclosure Gift Cards, Gift Tags or Stickers, Floral Calling Cards, Favor Tags

CA$21.60

Mahjong Personalized NOTEPAD with Name, Mahjong Memo Pad Thank You Notes Feminine Notepad, Game Lovers Gift

Mahjong Personalized NOTEPAD with Name, Mahjong Memo Pad Thank You Notes Feminine Notepad, Game Lovers Gift

CA$20.16

Floral Stationary Set for Women Personalized Thank You Cards Watercolor Tulip Stationery, Customized Thank You Notes Floral Thank You

Floral Stationary Set for Women Personalized Thank You Cards Watercolor Tulip Stationery, Customized Thank You Notes Floral Thank You

CA$23.04

All items

Blueberry Cocktail Note Cards, Custom Folk Art Stationery Set, Personalized Bar Cart Thank You Notes

Blueberry Cocktail Note Cards, Custom Folk Art Stationery Set, Personalized Bar Cart Thank You Notes

CA$31.68

Personalized Floral Ditzy Cottage Note Cards, Custom Monogram Stationery Set

Personalized Floral Ditzy Cottage Note Cards, Custom Monogram Stationery Set

CA$31.68

Personalized Floral Ditzy Cottage Note Cards, Custom Monogram Stationery Set

Personalized Floral Ditzy Cottage Note Cards, Custom Monogram Stationery Set

CA$31.68

Personalized Scenic Mountain Valley Cottage Note Cards, Custom Monogram Stationery Set

Personalized Scenic Mountain Valley Cottage Note Cards, Custom Monogram Stationery Set

CA$31.68

Personalized Stationery Set, Grandmillenial Flat Note Cards, Preppy Custom Stationary, Double Sided Note Set

Personalized Stationery Set, Grandmillenial Flat Note Cards, Preppy Custom Stationary, Double Sided Note Set

CA$31.68

Personalized Stationery Set, Peaches Flat Note Cards, Preppy Custom Stationary, Double Sided Note Card, Fruit Writing Paper Gift

Personalized Stationery Set, Peaches Flat Note Cards, Preppy Custom Stationary, Double Sided Note Card, Fruit Writing Paper Gift

CA$31.68

Personalized Stationery Set, Cherry Flat Note Cards, Preppy Custom Stationary, Double Sided Note Card, Fruit Writing Paper Gift

Personalized Stationery Set, Cherry Flat Note Cards, Preppy Custom Stationary, Double Sided Note Card, Fruit Writing Paper Gift

CA$31.68

Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Wildflower Floral Design, Checkbook Holder

Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Wildflower Floral Design, Checkbook Holder

CA$10.08

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Daisys

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Daisys

CA$10.08

Monogrammed Floral Checkbook Cover, Cherries Design, Vinyl Wallet for Top Tear Checks

Monogrammed Floral Checkbook Cover, Cherries Design, Vinyl Wallet for Top Tear Checks

CA$10.08

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Floral Flowers

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Floral Flowers

CA$10.08

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Cherries Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Duplicate Checkbook, Top Tear Checkbook for Her, Cherries

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Cherries Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Duplicate Checkbook, Top Tear Checkbook for Her, Cherries

CA$10.08

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Muted Tulips

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Muted Tulips

CA$10.08

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Floral Hydrangeas

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Floral Hydrangeas

CA$10.08

Custom Bridal Shower Recipe Card Spoon Design Personalized 4x6 Double Sided Tea Party Recipe Keepsake Gift

Custom Bridal Shower Recipe Card Spoon Design Personalized 4x6 Double Sided Tea Party Recipe Keepsake Gift

CA$8.93

Olive Italian Recipe Card 4x6 Double Sided Printable | Italian Recipe Card Template | Kitchen Bridal Shower Recipe Insert | Recipe Card

Olive Italian Recipe Card 4x6 Double Sided Printable | Italian Recipe Card Template | Kitchen Bridal Shower Recipe Insert | Recipe Card

CA$8.93

Custom Bridal Shower Recipe Card Fruit Pear Design Personalized 4x6 Double Sided Tea Party Recipe Keepsake Gift

Custom Bridal Shower Recipe Card Fruit Pear Design Personalized 4x6 Double Sided Tea Party Recipe Keepsake Gift

CA$8.93

Pasta Style Recipe Card 4x6 Double Sided Printable | Italian Recipe Card Template | Kitchen Bridal Shower Recipe Insert | Recipe Card

Pasta Style Recipe Card 4x6 Double Sided Printable | Italian Recipe Card Template | Kitchen Bridal Shower Recipe Insert | Recipe Card

CA$8.93

Custom Bridal Shower Recipe Card Fruit Bowl Design Personalized 4x6 Double Sided Tea Party Recipe Keepsake Gift

Custom Bridal Shower Recipe Card Fruit Bowl Design Personalized 4x6 Double Sided Tea Party Recipe Keepsake Gift

CA$8.93

Custom Bridal Shower Recipe Card Teacup with Lemon Design Personalized 4x6 Double Sided Tea Party Recipe Keepsake Gift

Custom Bridal Shower Recipe Card Teacup with Lemon Design Personalized 4x6 Double Sided Tea Party Recipe Keepsake Gift

CA$8.93

Custom Recipe Card with Olive Oil Jar, 4x6 Double Sided Personalized Cooking Recipe Card Keepsake Gift for Home Chefs

Custom Recipe Card with Olive Oil Jar, 4x6 Double Sided Personalized Cooking Recipe Card Keepsake Gift for Home Chefs

CA$8.93

Custom Recipe Card Double Sided 4x6 Personalized Baking Recipe Card Keepsake Gift for Kitchen or Bridal Shower

Custom Recipe Card Double Sided 4x6 Personalized Baking Recipe Card Keepsake Gift for Kitchen or Bridal Shower

CA$8.93

Custom Macaron Recipe Card Personalized 4x6 Baking Card Double Sided French Macaroon Design Recipe Keepsake Gift for Bakers

Custom Macaron Recipe Card Personalized 4x6 Baking Card Double Sided French Macaroon Design Recipe Keepsake Gift for Bakers

CA$8.93

Italian Style Recipe Card 4x6 Double Sided Printable | Italian Recipe Card Template | Kitchen Bridal Shower Recipe Insert | Recipe Card

Italian Style Recipe Card 4x6 Double Sided Printable | Italian Recipe Card Template | Kitchen Bridal Shower Recipe Insert | Recipe Card

CA$8.93

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover< Pastel Abstract

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover< Pastel Abstract

CA$10.80

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Duplicate Checkbook, Top Tear Checkbook, Floral

Checkbook Cover, Monogrammed Vinyl Checkbook Cover, Duplicate Checkbook, Top Tear Checkbook, Floral

CA$10.80

Custom Playing Cards - Personalized Poker Deck for Game Night Gift, Card Lover, Family Gift, Bachelor Party Gift or New Home Gift

Custom Playing Cards - Personalized Poker Deck for Game Night Gift, Card Lover, Family Gift, Bachelor Party Gift or New Home Gift

CA$31.68

Cherries Checkbook Cover: Top Tear, Duplicate Checks

Cherries Checkbook Cover: Top Tear, Duplicate Checks

CA$10.08

Personalized Playing Cards with Easter Basket Design – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift for game Lovers, Easter Gift

Personalized Playing Cards with Easter Basket Design – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift for game Lovers, Easter Gift

CA$31.68

Personalized Playing Cards with Cupcake Design – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift for game Lovers

Personalized Playing Cards with Cupcake Design – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift for game Lovers

CA$31.68

Personalized Gingham Floral Playing Cards – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift

Personalized Gingham Floral Playing Cards – Custom Name Poker Cards, Feminine Gift

CA$31.68

Mr and Mrs Personalized Playing Cards with Names & Wedding Date

Mr and Mrs Personalized Playing Cards with Names & Wedding Date

CA$31.68

Custom Playing Cards for Groomsmen Gifts & Bachelor Trips

Custom Playing Cards for Groomsmen Gifts & Bachelor Trips

CA$31.68

Personalized Mahjong Platter, Custom Mahjong Serving Plate, Poolside Outdoor Dinner Party, Game Night Ladies Gift

Personalized Mahjong Platter, Custom Mahjong Serving Plate, Poolside Outdoor Dinner Party, Game Night Ladies Gift

CA$25.92

Pickleball Social Club Serving Platter 10x14, Pickleball Party Plate, Pickleball Gift for Women, Fun Pickleball Decor

Pickleball Social Club Serving Platter 10x14, Pickleball Party Plate, Pickleball Gift for Women, Fun Pickleball Decor

CA$25.92

Pickleball Serving Platter 10x14, Pickleball Martini Design, Funny Pickleball Gift for Women, Gingham Pickleball Entertaining Plate

Pickleball Serving Platter 10x14, Pickleball Martini Design, Funny Pickleball Gift for Women, Gingham Pickleball Entertaining Plate

CA$25.92

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on 29 May, 2026
jacki patterson

Contact shop owner

jacki patterson

Contact shop owner

Reviews

4.9 (4125)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

About PaperShay

Personalized stationery & gifts,A Bespoke Company

Sales 22,521
On Etsy since 2010

Personalized stationery & gifts,A Bespoke Company

  • Personalized Flasks now in shop. Add a little style and class to your bachelorette trips.

I lost my husband way too soon and created Paper Shay to be home with my girls.

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Jacki Patterson

    Owner

  • shop-member-photo
    Jaymi Stewart

    Production Manager

Production partners

  • Dye Sublimation Manufacturer

    CA, United States

    Distribution facility, located in California. Our dye sublimation manufacturers offer a wide array of dye sublimated fabric products allowing us to extend our product line while providing excellent customer service.

  • Print Shop

    Wheeling, IL

    Started business in 2014 and is the world leader in dinnerware dye sublimation.

  • A Print Shop

    United States

    This manufacturer uses our designs and manufacturers our plates and platters on an FDA approved polymer plate. They have been printing for over 40 years.

  • A Print Shop

    Overland Park, KS

    They print the Playing Cards after we design them.

  • Printify

    Wilmington, DE

    A Print on Demand Company

Shop policies

Last updated on 22 Jan, 2024

Delivery

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Digital downloads

Instant downloads
Your files will be available to download once payment is confirmed. Here's how.

Payment options

Secure options
Paypal Visa Mastercard Apple Pay Klarna Gift card
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

Privacy policy

More information

Last updated on 17 Dec, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Wholesale availability

Yes, just email Jacki@PaperShay.com

I just noticed an issue with my shipping address - can it be changed?

If you notice an issue with an address, please contact me as soon as possible with the corrections.

All orders will be sent to the address given on the order unless otherwise requested. Please ensure this address is accurate and complete as I will use it EXACTLY as given. I have no way to know if the address is correct, so please DOUBLE CHECK when completing the payment process. We process orders immediately--so ACT FAST

Do you except returns or exchanges?

Returns and exchanges are not accepted due to the nature of personalized items. If your items arrive damaged due to shipping or I made a mistake on your order, please contact me immediately.
We want you to be super happy with your purchase, so if you are not satisfied in any way, please let me know and I will do my best to make it right!

Will printed colors look exactly like on my screen?

All monitors and devices display color differently, therefore on screen colors may vary from printed colors. 



How do I add Personalization?

Please type your personalization into the text box on the listing page OR send us a message at Paper Shay text box on the cart screen. Above the personalization text field you will find the list of info we require to complete your order.

I will copy and paste your text directly from your order into the text portion of the design. So please double check it!! If a listing shows all caps or all lowercase for the name / text, your text will be printed in the same case - most of our designs use fonts that have either only upper or only lowercase letters.

If you have questions or concerns about the font or capitalizations please reach out.

Do you send Proofs prior to printing?

I only send proofs if requested, or if I feel I need your approval prior to printing due to an issue or need for clarification. Most orders do not require the proofing step and it allows me to get your order to you much faster!

How are my items packaged?

Paper Products
All are packaged in beautiful clear acrylic boxes or packaged in sealed cello sleeves--making perfect gifts for yourself or someone special!

Most of the other Products are wrapped in shipping paper for a safe trip to your destination.