PersonalizingPretty

2k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (198)
2 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (198)
2k
sales
2 years
on Etsy
2k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (198)
2 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (198)
2k
sales
2 years
on Etsy
Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
2034 Sales
43 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All items

New LDS Young Women Class Builders of Faith, Messengers of Hope, Gatherers of Light | Wooden Tassel Keychain | Personalized YW Bulk Gift

New LDS Young Women Class Builders of Faith, Messengers of Hope, Gatherers of Light | Wooden Tassel Keychain | Personalized YW Bulk Gift

Sale Price $3.60

Original Price $4.50 (20% off)

LDS 2026 Youth Theme Journal, Walk with Me, Personalized Engraved Kraft Notebook and Pen for YM or YW Camp or Lessons

LDS 2026 Youth Theme Journal, Walk with Me, Personalized Engraved Kraft Notebook and Pen for YM or YW Camp or Lessons

Sale Price $2.55

Original Price $3.00 (15% off)

LDS Young Women Charm – Builders of Faith, Messengers of Hope, Gatherers of Light – New YW Name Charms, Gold or Silver, Girls Camp Gift

LDS Young Women Charm – Builders of Faith, Messengers of Hope, Gatherers of Light – New YW Name Charms, Gold or Silver, Girls Camp Gift

$4.00

LDS Young Women Keychain | Builder of Faith, Messenger of Hope, Gatherer of Light | Personalized Wooden Tassel Keychain | YW Gift | Camp

LDS Young Women Keychain | Builder of Faith, Messenger of Hope, Gatherer of Light | Personalized Wooden Tassel Keychain | YW Gift | Camp

Sale Price $3.96

Original Price $6.60 (40% off)

2026 LDS Youth Theme Charms – "Walk with Me" & Christus – Young Women Gift or Craft

2026 LDS Youth Theme Charms – "Walk with Me" & Christus – Young Women Gift or Craft

Sale Price $2.40

Original Price $4.00 (40% off)

Anda Conmigo Llavero Personalizada - Tema de Juventud SUD 2026 | Regalo de las Mujeres Jóvenes, Tirador de cremallera Moisés 6:34 - Español

Anda Conmigo Llavero Personalizada - Tema de Juventud SUD 2026 | Regalo de las Mujeres Jóvenes, Tirador de cremallera Moisés 6:34 - Español

Sale Price $5.61

Original Price $6.60 (15% off)

Set of 5, Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Pack of Personalized Engraved Pens, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Christmas, YW, YM, Bulk

Set of 5, Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Pack of Personalized Engraved Pens, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Christmas, YW, YM, Bulk

Sale Price $5.31

Original Price $6.25 (15% off)

Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YM, Bulk, D&C 6:36, Doubt Fear Not

Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YM, Bulk, D&C 6:36, Doubt Fear Not

Sale Price $3.09

Original Price $3.63 (15% off)

Walk with Me Charm Bracelet | 2026 LDS Youth Theme - Personalized Christian Jewelry, Young Women Gift, Birthday, Christmas, Camp, Moses 6:34

Walk with Me Charm Bracelet | 2026 LDS Youth Theme - Personalized Christian Jewelry, Young Women Gift, Birthday, Christmas, Camp, Moses 6:34

Sale Price $5.10

Original Price $6.00 (15% off)

Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YM, Bulk, D&C 6:36, Doubt Fear Not

Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YM, Bulk, D&C 6:36, Doubt Fear Not

Sale Price $3.06

Original Price $3.60 (15% off)

2026 LDS Youth Theme Wooden Pendant – "Walk with Me" | Personalized Option Available

2026 LDS Youth Theme Wooden Pendant – "Walk with Me" | Personalized Option Available

Sale Price $1.20

Original Price $2.00 (40% off)

Walk With Me Necklace – 2026 LDS Youth Theme – Christus Pendant – Christian Jewelry – Young Women Gift – YW Birthday – Christmas LDS Gift

Walk With Me Necklace – 2026 LDS Youth Theme – Christus Pendant – Christian Jewelry – Young Women Gift – YW Birthday – Christmas LDS Gift

$20.00

3 people have this in their cart
Christian Empty Tomb Charm – Easter He Is Risen Religious Faith Jewelry or Craft

Christian Empty Tomb Charm – Easter He Is Risen Religious Faith Jewelry or Craft

Sale Price $2.40

Original Price $4.00 (40% off)

Walk with Me Personalized Charm Bracelet, 2026 LDS Youth Theme, Young Women Gift, YW Birthday or Christmas Present, Girls Camp, Moses 6:34

Walk with Me Personalized Charm Bracelet, 2026 LDS Youth Theme, Young Women Gift, YW Birthday or Christmas Present, Girls Camp, Moses 6:34

Sale Price $3.60

Original Price $6.00 (40% off)

Walk With Me Necklace - 2026 LDS Youth Theme Gift - Young Women Jewelry, YW, Birthday, Packaged

Walk With Me Necklace - 2026 LDS Youth Theme Gift - Young Women Jewelry, YW, Birthday, Packaged

Sale Price $6.00

Original Price $20.00 (70% off)

Walk with Me – 2026 LDS Youth Theme Keychain | Personalized Engraved Wood + Tassel | Moses 6:34 | YW YM Gift, Zipper Pull

Walk with Me – 2026 LDS Youth Theme Keychain | Personalized Engraved Wood + Tassel | Moses 6:34 | YW YM Gift, Zipper Pull

Sale Price $3.96

Original Price $6.60 (40% off)

Christ's Arrival to Jerusalem Easter Necklace, Laser Engraved Charms, Christian Jewelry, Empty Tomb, Palm Branch, Young Women Gift, YW, LDS

Christ's Arrival to Jerusalem Easter Necklace, Laser Engraved Charms, Christian Jewelry, Empty Tomb, Palm Branch, Young Women Gift, YW, LDS

$20.00

Walk with Me, 2026 LDS Youth Theme, Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YM, Bulk, Moses 6:34

Walk with Me, 2026 LDS Youth Theme, Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YM, Bulk, Moses 6:34

Sale Price $3.82

Original Price $4.50 (15% off)

Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Christus Pendant Necklace, Christian Jewelry, Young Women, Christmas Gift, Birthday, YW, Doubt Not

Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Christus Pendant Necklace, Christian Jewelry, Young Women, Christmas Gift, Birthday, YW, Doubt Not

Sale Price $17.00

Original Price $20.00 (15% off)

Christus Pendant Necklace | Christian Jewelry - Birthday, Christmas Gift, LDS, YW, Relief Society

Christus Pendant Necklace | Christian Jewelry - Birthday, Christmas Gift, LDS, YW, Relief Society

$15.00

8 people have this in their cart
Empty Tomb Necklace, He is Risen, Easter, Disciple of Jesus Christ, Christian Jewelry, LDS, Gold, Young Women, Relief Society, Gift, YW

Empty Tomb Necklace, He is Risen, Easter, Disciple of Jesus Christ, Christian Jewelry, LDS, Gold, Young Women, Relief Society, Gift, YW

$20.00

3 people have this in their cart
Christus Pendant Necklace, Disciple of Jesus Christ, Christian Jewelry, LDS, Gold, Silver, Young Women, Relief Society, Gift, Birthday, YW

Christus Pendant Necklace, Disciple of Jesus Christ, Christian Jewelry, LDS, Gold, Silver, Young Women, Relief Society, Gift, Birthday, YW

$20.00

Personalized He Lives Empty Tomb Necklace – Risen Savior Stainless Steel Pendant – LDS Easter Gift

Personalized He Lives Empty Tomb Necklace – Risen Savior Stainless Steel Pendant – LDS Easter Gift

$25.00

Walk with Me Personalized Beadable Keychain - 2026 LDS Youth Theme | Young Women, YW, Birthday Gift, Christmas, Moses 6:34, Christ, Engraved

Walk with Me Personalized Beadable Keychain - 2026 LDS Youth Theme | Young Women, YW, Birthday Gift, Christmas, Moses 6:34, Christ, Engraved

Sale Price $5.95

Original Price $7.00 (15% off)

Set of 5 Walk with Me 2026 LDS Youth Theme Personalized Engraved Pens | Young Women and Young Men Gifts

Set of 5 Walk with Me 2026 LDS Youth Theme Personalized Engraved Pens | Young Women and Young Men Gifts

Sale Price $5.31

Original Price $6.25 (15% off)

Walk With Me Christus Necklace – 2026 LDS Youth Theme – Christian Jewelry – Young Women Gift – YW Birthday – Christmas LDS Gift - Packaged

Walk With Me Christus Necklace – 2026 LDS Youth Theme – Christian Jewelry – Young Women Gift – YW Birthday – Christmas LDS Gift - Packaged

$15.00

Mustard Seed 'Faith to Move Mountains' Gold Pendant Necklace, Personalizable, Laser Engraved, Charm Necklace, Christian Jewelry, Matt. 17:10

Mustard Seed 'Faith to Move Mountains' Gold Pendant Necklace, Personalizable, Laser Engraved, Charm Necklace, Christian Jewelry, Matt. 17:10

$29.60

Only 2 left
Walk with Me, 2026 LDS Youth Theme, Personalized Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YW, Ward, Moses 6:34, Christ

Walk with Me, 2026 LDS Youth Theme, Personalized Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YW, Ward, Moses 6:34, Christ

Sale Price $3.96

Original Price $6.60 (40% off)

Personalized Cross Necklace – Stainless Steel Bar Pendant – LDS Easter Gift - Religious Jewelry for Women

Personalized Cross Necklace – Stainless Steel Bar Pendant – LDS Easter Gift - Religious Jewelry for Women

$25.00

Jesus Loves Me Personalized Necklace – Gethsemane Prayer Stainless Steel Pendant – LDS Easter Gift

Jesus Loves Me Personalized Necklace – Gethsemane Prayer Stainless Steel Pendant – LDS Easter Gift

$25.00

Personalized He Is Risen Necklace – Stainless Steel Empty Tomb Christian Easter Gift

Personalized He Is Risen Necklace – Stainless Steel Empty Tomb Christian Easter Gift

$25.00

Personalized Sister Missionary Journal, LDS Mission Gift

Personalized Sister Missionary Journal, LDS Mission Gift

$30.00

I am a Disciple of Jesus Christ, 2024 LDS Youth Theme, Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YM, Bulk, 3 Nephi 5:13

I am a Disciple of Jesus Christ, 2024 LDS Youth Theme, Keychain, Zipper Pull, Young Women, Young Men, Gift, Birthday, YM, Bulk, 3 Nephi 5:13

$3.63

Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Necklace, Bar Charm, Young Women, Gift, Birthday, Christmas, YW, D&C 6:36, Doubt Fear Not, Jewelry

Look Unto Christ, 2025 LDS Youth Theme, Necklace, Bar Charm, Young Women, Gift, Birthday, Christmas, YW, D&C 6:36, Doubt Fear Not, Jewelry

Sale Price $15.30

Original Price $18.00 (15% off)

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Erica

Contact shop owner

Erica

Contact shop owner

Reviews

4.9 (198)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

About PersonalizingPretty

Personalized hand-made jewelry & custom laser engraving

Sales 2,034
On Etsy since 2023

Personalized hand-made jewelry & custom laser engraving

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Erica

    Owner

Production partners

  • Print Shop

    Beltsville, Md.

    They help with printing the personalized mission journals.

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.