716CustomCreation

West Seneca, New York

9.4k
 Sales

4.9 (2.5k)

5 years
on Etsy

4.9 (2.5k)

9.4k
 sales

5 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

9.4k
 Sales

4.9 (2.5k)

5 years
on Etsy

4.9 (2.5k)

9.4k
 sales

5 years
on Etsy

Request Custom Order

Contact shop owner

9434 Sales

576 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Oct 30, 2025

📦 𝑯𝒐𝒍𝒊𝒅𝒂𝒚 𝑺𝒉𝒊𝒑𝒑𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝑹𝒆𝒎𝒊𝒏𝒅𝒆𝒓: USPS is moving slower this time of year due to high volume. Once your order is scanned in, please allow 𝐚𝐛𝐨𝐮𝐭 1 𝐰𝐞𝐞𝐤 for delivery. If you need your order by a specific date, upgraded shipping at checkout is recommended.

Welcome to 716 Custom Creations! We offer unique gifts with a personalized touch for the people you care about most! If you have a custom idea that you don't see here, please message me. I will be happy to work with you to create just what you're looking for!

♡ Find me here! ♡
https://www.facebook.com/716CustomCreations
https://www.instagram.com/716customcreations

Contact shop owner

Amanda

Reviews

4.9 (2477)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Etsy buyer on Sep 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Ive ordered many of times from this seller and will continue to do so. Great customer service.

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026
Heather on Sep 23, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Matched description very well, excellent clarity and fast delivery.

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026
Carol on Sep 23, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

So cute! Exactly what I was looking for; quick shipping. Thank you

Mini Candy Corn Plush/Personalized Halloween Plush/Candy Corn Stuffed Animal/Trick or Treat Gift/Classroom Favors/Fall Décor/Mini Plush

Mini Candy Corn Plush/Personalized Halloween Plush/Candy Corn Stuffed Animal/Trick or Treat Gift/Classroom Favors/Fall Décor/Mini Plush
Judy on Sep 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Love the product. After receiving my ornament I ordered another one and am on a wait list for a larger Squishmallow.

Personalized Squishmallow Ornament, 4" Mini Plush, Custom Name, Christmas 2026 Tree Décor, Stocking Stuffer, Kids Gift, Holiday Party Favor

Personalized Squishmallow Ornament, 4" Mini Plush, Custom Name, Christmas 2026 Tree Décor, Stocking Stuffer, Kids Gift, Holiday Party Favor
Courtney on Sep 16, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Such a cute little piece! I just put it out at the farm stand today and it’s already grabbing so many people’s attention! Love the design and it fits my business (and cards) perfectly! Keep bringing on quality items!

Sourdough Business Card Holder • Bakery Display Stand • Bread Desk Organizer • Farmers Market Display Decor • Gift for Bakers • Bakery Decor

Sourdough Business Card Holder • Bakery Display Stand • Bread Desk Organizer • Farmers Market Display Decor • Gift for Bakers • Bakery Decor
Cheryl on Sep 11, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

these are the most cutest thing I have seen,

Mini Candy Corn Plush/Personalized Halloween Plush/Candy Corn Stuffed Animal/Trick or Treat Gift/Classroom Favors/Fall Décor/Mini Plush

Mini Candy Corn Plush/Personalized Halloween Plush/Candy Corn Stuffed Animal/Trick or Treat Gift/Classroom Favors/Fall Décor/Mini Plush
Kristin on Sep 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is my 3rd time ordering from this store and I have always received excellent quality and the orders always show up earlier than expected. I will definitely order from here again next sports season.

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026
L on Sep 17, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is my 3rd order and I couldn’t be happier with how the buttons turned out. Perfect size and a lot of design flexibility within template.

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026
Marybeth on Sep 16, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Amazing timespan and quality product. Excellent customer service.

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026
Karen on Sep 8, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Personalization was done beautifully. Nice gift for granddaughter. Very fast shipping.

Personalized Squishmallows, Stuffed Animal, Birthday, Custom Cheer Plush, Cheerleader, Cheerleading, Cheer Competition Gift, Sport Team Gift

Personalized Squishmallows, Stuffed Animal, Birthday, Custom Cheer Plush, Cheerleader, Cheerleading, Cheer Competition Gift, Sport Team Gift

About 716CustomCreation

Welcome! Personalized gifts for the ones you love most!

Sales 9,434

On Etsy since 2020

Welcome! Personalized gifts for the ones you love most!

716 Custom Creation

Hi there!

Thanks so much for stopping by my shop — I’m so glad you’re here!

I’m Amanda, the creator behind 716 Custom Creations, based in Buffalo, NY. I launched this small business in 2020 after my youngest started kindergarten, channeling my love for all things creative into something I could share with others. What started as a side project has grown into a full-blown passion, and I feel incredibly lucky to do what I love every single day.

From holiday-themed gifts and personalized Squishmallows to sports buttons, 3D-printed goodies, and custom keychains, I’m always designing something new. If you have a special idea or need something customized just for you, I’d love to hear it — making one-of-a-kind creations is what I do best!

Your support truly means the world. Thank you for shopping small and being a part of my creative journey!

♡ Let’s stay connected ♡
Facebook: facebook.com/716CustomCreations
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/716customcreations

Facebook

Instagram

Shop members

Amanda

Owner

Production partners

Just Play

Boca Raton, FL

Just Play manufactured the Minnie and Mickey Plush and then I add my personalization to them.
KellyToy

Los Angeles, CA

**Disclaimer KellyToy Company makes the Squishmallows, then I add the personalization you desire.**

More production partners

OTC

Omaha, NE

OTC made the plush and I personalized it.

Shop policies

Last updated on Mar 12, 2024

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Shipping Policy

Once your order is shipped with tracking, it’s in the hands of the carrier. If your package is lost, please contact us—we’re happy to assist! You may also reach out to your local post office for help.

Please note that package theft ("porch piracy") is unfortunately on the rise. If your package is stolen, you may need to file a police report. Shipping insurance does not cover theft, and we cannot replace stolen items at our expense.

To ensure a smooth delivery:
✅ Please ensure your shipping address is correct. If an item is returned due to an incorrect address, reshipping costs will be the buyer’s responsibility (if the item is available).
✅ Track your package so you know when it's expected to arrive.

Thank you for understanding!

Custom and personalized orders

I reserve the right to cancel any personalized orders that may be considered insensitive, offensive, or discriminatory in nature.

What vinyl color goes best with my Squishmallow?

Tips for Choosing the Best Vinyl Color

🎯 Black is a safe choice unless your Squishmallow is black.

🎯 For Squishmallows with a light-colored belly, avoid Silver and Lemon Sugar, as they may not "pop" as well.

🎯 If the Squishmallow has a colored belly, choose a vinyl color that contrasts for better visibility.

🎯 For Squishmallows with a white belly and a single color, a matching vinyl color will usually look great.

Feel free to message us if you have any questions about color choices!

Authenticity of Squishmallows

All of our Squishmallows are 100% authentic, produced by Kelly Toys or Jazwares.

Each Squishmallow is brand new, and as long as the distributor includes a tag, it will come with its original tag.

Shipping Time

We strive for fast shipping and typically personalize and ship orders the next business day. During our busiest months, processing time may take up to 4 business days.

Hours of Operation

Monday through Friday: 7am - 3pm ET
Saturday and Sunday: Closed

𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐥𝐨𝐧𝐠 𝐰𝐢𝐥𝐥 𝐬𝐡𝐢𝐩𝐩𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐚𝐤𝐞 𝐝𝐮𝐫𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐡𝐨𝐥𝐢𝐝𝐚𝐲 𝐬𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐨𝐧?

I always do my best to create and ship your order quickly. Between October through December, USPS experiences higher-than-normal volume, which may add extra time in transit.

Once your package is scanned in, delivery is typically 3–6 business days, but during the holiday season I recommend allowing at least one week for it to arrive.

If you have a firm date you need your item by, I strongly recommend selecting upgraded shipping at checkout so your package moves faster through the USPS system. I always want your gift to arrive on time and just right!

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Painting

Portrait of Christ by the Renaissance by PaintingMania

Storage & Organization

Mini Mail Tub/ USPS mini mail tub by 3DPrintingMailMan

Fine Art Ceramics

Buy Tony Evans Raku Pottery Online

Floor & Rugs

Shop Mha Rug

Toys

Michigan Dogman Shop Shirtless Male Miniature Shop Cyclone Missile Launcher 4014 BigBoy Royal High Valkyrie Doll for Sale Foods Good For Teeth for Sale 90s Spiky Ball - US

Shopping

Buy 1940's Spy Camera Online

Sports & Outdoor Games

Buy Riverside Jigs Online

Home Decor

Buy Outdoor Nativity Angel Online

Prints

Scratchboard Dog Art - US

Riding & Farm Animals

Shop Nurture Right 360 Quail Egg Turner

Watches

Buy Rolex Crown Online

Games & Puzzles

Shop Druid Dnd Binder

716CustomCreation

Featured items

Personalized Graduation Button, Custom Photo Graduation Pin Keepsake for Preschool, Elementary, Middle & High School, Class of 2026

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026

Class of 2026 Personalized Graduation Squishmallow, Graduation Gift for Grad, Preschool, College, Highschool, Pre-k, Custom Plush with Year

Personalized Graduation Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Senior Gift 2026, Class of 2026, College or Highschool Grad Gift, Bag Tags

Personalized Squishmallow Plush with Name • Custom Gift for Birthday, Holiday, Flower Girl, Hospital, Easter Basket, Grads • Fast Shipping

Personalized Graduation Button, Custom Photo Graduation Pin Keepsake for Preschool, Elementary, Middle & High School, Class of 2026

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026

Class of 2026 Personalized Graduation Squishmallow, Graduation Gift for Grad, Preschool, College, Highschool, Pre-k, Custom Plush with Year

Personalized Graduation Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Senior Gift 2026, Class of 2026, College or Highschool Grad Gift, Bag Tags

Personalized Squishmallow Plush with Name • Custom Gift for Birthday, Holiday, Flower Girl, Hospital, Easter Basket, Grads • Fast Shipping

All items

Personalized Wooden Christmas Ornament • Custom Name Ornament • Laser Cut Wood Ornament • Family Christmas Gift • Holiday Tree Decor

Cheer Hair Tie Holder Keychain • Cheer Bag Charm • Custom Team Colors • Cheerleader Team Gift • Ponytail Holder • Backpack Accessory

Personalized Squishmallows•Stuffed Animal•Birthday•Custom Swim Plush•Swimmer Gift•Swim Meet• Swim Team•Competition Gift•Sport Team Gift

Clicky 3D Printed Dumpling Fidget Toy • Cute Dumpling Desk Buddy • Steamer Basket Toy • Articulated Food Figure • Dumpling Clicker

Sourdough Business Card Holder • Bakery Display Stand • Bread Desk Organizer • Farmers Market Display Decor • Gift for Bakers • Bakery Decor

Personalized Teacher Gift•Thank You Teacher Gift•Teacher Appreciation Gift•End of Year Teacher Gift•Gift Card Holder•Custom Teacher Present

Personalized Squishmallows, Stuffed Animal, Birthday, Custom Cheer Plush, Cheerleader, Cheerleading, Cheer Competition Gift, Sport Team Gift

Personalized Squishmallows•Stuffed Animal•Birthday•Custom Dance Plush•Dancer Gift•Dance Recital• Dance Team•Competition Gift•Sport Team Gift

Personalized Squishmallow Plush with Name • Custom Gift for Birthday, Holiday, Flower Girl, Hospital, Easter Basket, Grads • Fast Shipping

Personalized Bridal Party Squishmallows, Stuffed Animal, Plush, Wedding Favor, Custom Stuffy, Flower Girl, Ring Bearer, Bride, Groom

Class of 2026 Personalized Graduation Squishmallow, Graduation Gift for Grad, Preschool, College, Highschool, Pre-k, Custom Plush with Year

12" Personalized Graduation Squishmallow, Stuffed Animal, Gift for Grad, Custom Plush, Class of 2026, Preschool, College, Highschool, Pre-k

Personalized Prom Squishmallow, Prom Gift, Promposal, Stuffed Animal, Custom Plush, Highschool Dance, Girlfriend, Boyfriend, Prom Date

7.5" Personalized HoCo Squishmallow, Homecoming Proposal, Stuffed Animal, Custom Plush, Highschool Dance, Girlfriend, Boyfriend, HOCO Date

7.5" Personalized Happy Birthday Squishmallow, Stuffed Animal, Custom Plush, Gift for Birthday, Birthday Present, Birthday Gift for Her/Him

Personalized Squishmallows, Stuffed Animal, Birthday, Custom Soccer Plush, Soccer, Sports, Soccer Competition Gift, Sport Team Gift

Personalized Graduation Button, Custom Photo Graduation Pin Keepsake for Preschool, Elementary, Middle & High School, Class of 2026

Custom Sport Photo Button, 3 inch Pin Back Button, Personalized Sport Photo Pin, Football, Softball, Baseball, Soccer, Hockey, Senior 2026

Personalized Minnie / Mickey Mouse, Custom Name Plush, Easter Plush, Easter Basket, Easter Basket Filler, Unique Easter Gift, Stuffed Animal

5" Personalized Squishmallows, Custom Name Plush, Easter Plush, Easter Basket, Easter Basket Filler, Unique Easter Gift, Stuffed Animal

Personalized Easter Squishmallows, Custom Name Plush, Easter Plush, Easter Basket, Easter Basket Filler, Unique Easter Gift, Stuffed Animal

Personalized Easter Gnomes, Easter Plush, Easter Gnome, Stuffed Gnomes, Personalized Easter Plush, Easter Basket Filler, Unique Easter Gift

Personalized Easter Chick, Easter Plush, Easter Basket Stuffy, Easter Basket Filler, Unique Easter Gift, Stuffed Animal, Custom Name Plush

Personalized Easter Sign, Welcome Sign, Easter Welcome Sign, Family Name Sign, Unique Easter Gift, Bunny Tail Welcome Sign, Rabbit Welcome

Personalized Baseball Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Baseball Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Custom Sports Keychain, Bag Tags

Personalized Graduation Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Senior Gift 2026, Class of 2026, College or Highschool Grad Gift, Bag Tags

Personalized Basketball Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Basketball Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Custom Sports Gift, Bag Tags

Personalized Cheerleading Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Cheerleading Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Custom Sports, Bag Tags

Personalized Martial Arts Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Custom Sports Keychain, Bag Tags

Personalized Theater Keychain•Custom Name Keyring•Drama Club Bag Tag•Actor Gift•Stage Crew Keychain•Play, Performance, Theater Gift•Bag Tag

Personalized Track and Field Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Track Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Coach Gift, Custom Sports Keychain, Bag Tags

Personalized Softball Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Softball Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Custom Sports Keychain, Bag Tags

Personalized Hockey Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Hockey Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Custom Sports Gift, Bag Tags

Personalized Swim Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Swim Team Bag Tag, Competitive Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Sports Keychain, Bag Tags

Personalized Soccer Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Soccer Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Custom Sports Keychain, Bag Tags

Personalized Football Keychain, Custom Name Keyring, Football Bag Tag, Team Gift, , Sport Coach Gift, Custom Sports Keychain, Bag Tags

Announcement

Reviews

About 716CustomCreation

Shop members

Amanda

Production partners

Shop policies

Shipping

Customs and import taxes

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations

More information

Frequently asked questions

Shipping Policy

Custom and personalized orders

What vinyl color goes best with my Squishmallow?

Authenticity of Squishmallows

Shipping Time

Hours of Operation

𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐥𝐨𝐧𝐠 𝐰𝐢𝐥𝐥 𝐬𝐡𝐢𝐩𝐩𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐚𝐤𝐞 𝐝𝐮𝐫𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐡𝐨𝐥𝐢𝐝𝐚𝐲 𝐬𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐨𝐧?