AuthenticallyElyse

Columbus, Ohio

308
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (96)
5 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (96)
308
sales
5 years
on Etsy
308
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (96)
5 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (96)
308
sales
5 years
on Etsy
Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
308 Sales
327 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All items

Spell Book with potion jar and glow in the dark spider inside a Glass Terrarium Ornament, Creepmas Ornament, Spookmas Ornament

Spell Book with potion jar and glow in the dark spider inside a Glass Terrarium Ornament, Creepmas Ornament, Spookmas Ornament

$15.00

Hanging Jack-o-Lantern Pumpkins with gold lines , 3 tier pumpkin art, Hanging Halloween

Hanging Jack-o-Lantern Pumpkins with gold lines , 3 tier pumpkin art, Hanging Halloween

$15.00

Only 3 left
Kissing Cats in love Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Kissing Cats in love Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Ghost Cat Heaven Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Ghost Cat Heaven Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Glow in the Dark Hanging Ghosts Halloween Decor

Glow in the Dark Hanging Ghosts Halloween Decor

$15.00

Only 3 left
Spooky Snake and Eyeball Moon, Hanging Moon, Crescent Moon, Eye Moon

Spooky Snake and Eyeball Moon, Hanging Moon, Crescent Moon, Eye Moon

$40.00

Tea Time Teapot Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Tea Time Teapot Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Spider Witch Hat Glass Terrarium Ornament - Winches Hat - Hanging Terrarium - Halloween Ornament

Spider Witch Hat Glass Terrarium Ornament - Winches Hat - Hanging Terrarium - Halloween Ornament

$15.00

Twilight Dreams Black Cat Tea Party Keychain, Teacup Cats

Twilight Dreams Black Cat Tea Party Keychain, Teacup Cats

$10.00

Daydreams Cream Cat Tea Party Keychain, Teacup Cats

Daydreams Cream Cat Tea Party Keychain, Teacup Cats

$10.00

Flower Crow Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Flower Crow Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Glass Heart Terrarium, Preserved moss, faux florals and white fuzzy moth, Heart Shaped Box

Glass Heart Terrarium, Preserved moss, faux florals and white fuzzy moth, Heart Shaped Box

$50.00

Haunted House Halloween Advent Calendar, 31-Day Countdown, Glow-in-the-Dark Windows, Ghost and Spiderwebs!

Haunted House Halloween Advent Calendar, 31-Day Countdown, Glow-in-the-Dark Windows, Ghost and Spiderwebs!

$290.00

Marmalade Toast Cat Keychain, Food Cat Keychain, Toast Art, Acrylic Keychain, Food Keychain, bag charm

Marmalade Toast Cat Keychain, Food Cat Keychain, Toast Art, Acrylic Keychain, Food Keychain, bag charm

$10.00

Hashbrown Cat Keychain, Food Cat Keychain, Hashbrown Art, Acrylic Keychain, Food Keychain, bag charm

Hashbrown Cat Keychain, Food Cat Keychain, Hashbrown Art, Acrylic Keychain, Food Keychain, bag charm

$10.00

Egg Cat Keychain, Food Cat Keychain, Egg Art, Acrylic Keychain, Food Keychain, bag charm

Egg Cat Keychain, Food Cat Keychain, Egg Art, Acrylic Keychain, Food Keychain, bag charm

$10.00

Butter Cat Keychain, Food Cat Keychain, Butter Art, Acrylic Keychain, Food Keychain, bag charm

Butter Cat Keychain, Food Cat Keychain, Butter Art, Acrylic Keychain, Food Keychain, bag charm

$10.00

Cat Tea Party Sticker, Teacup Cats, Waterproof , Scratch Resistant , Fade resistant

Cat Tea Party Sticker, Teacup Cats, Waterproof , Scratch Resistant , Fade resistant

$5.00

Cat Breakfast Club Sticker Pack Support TNR for our outside cat colony

Cat Breakfast Club Sticker Pack Support TNR for our outside cat colony

$5.00

Hanging Woodland Moon Phases, Moss Moon with floral accents, Spring Moon, Celestial Decor

Hanging Woodland Moon Phases, Moss Moon with floral accents, Spring Moon, Celestial Decor

$45.00

Gold Framed Glass Butterfly Flower Terrarium, Preserved moss faux floral terrarium

Gold Framed Glass Butterfly Flower Terrarium, Preserved moss faux floral terrarium

$45.00

Blue Flower Table Stand, Decorative Table, Decorative Stand Flower Shaped Table, Plant Table

Blue Flower Table Stand, Decorative Table, Decorative Stand Flower Shaped Table, Plant Table

$35.00

Glass House Butterfly Flower Terrarium, Preserved moss faux floral terrarium

Glass House Butterfly Flower Terrarium, Preserved moss faux floral terrarium

$65.00

Safe Space Coffin Blanket SUPER SOFT with original art

Safe Space Coffin Blanket SUPER SOFT with original art

$40.00

Coffee Cats Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Coffee Cats Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Only 2 left
Safe Space Coffin Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Safe Space Coffin Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Snake Bite Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Snake Bite Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Congestion Skull Blanket SUPER SOFT with original art

Congestion Skull Blanket SUPER SOFT with original art

$40.00

Mushroom Skull Blanket SUPER SOFT with original art

Mushroom Skull Blanket SUPER SOFT with original art

$40.00

Bubble Bee Blanket SUPER SOFT with original art Bumble bee

Bubble Bee Blanket SUPER SOFT with original art Bumble bee

$40.00

Mushroom Skull Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Mushroom Skull Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Bubble Bee Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

Bubble Bee Reusable Sticker Book, 50 blank pages, 8in x 6in Spiral Bound with protective cover

$20.00

Eat the Rich and Abolish ICE Candy Heart Stickers

Eat the Rich and Abolish ICE Candy Heart Stickers

$5.00

Candy Heart Print Alternative Conversation Hearts, Anti valentines Day Original Art

Candy Heart Print Alternative Conversation Hearts, Anti valentines Day Original Art

$8.00

Candy Heart Sticker Sheet Alternative Conversation Hearts, Anti valentines Day

Candy Heart Sticker Sheet Alternative Conversation Hearts, Anti valentines Day

$6.00

Winter Fox Wreath Sticker 3in Vinyl

Winter Fox Wreath Sticker 3in Vinyl

$5.00

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jan 30, 2026
Elyse McCabe

Contact shop owner

Elyse McCabe

Contact shop owner

Reviews

4.9 (96)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

About AuthenticallyElyse

Nature Inspired Whimsy delivered to your door

Sales 308
On Etsy since 2021

Nature Inspired Whimsy delivered to your door

Bringing joy by crafting joy!

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Elyse McCabe

    Owner

Production partners

  • Julie

    OH, United States

    Julie is my mother and wanted to craft something fun!

Shop policies

Last updated on Apr 18, 2022

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options
Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Custom and personalized orders

I will do my best to make your idea a reality but can not guarantee I will have the means to do so. Please reach out and we can discuss further!

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy