CastawayTradingCo

Littleton, Colorado

2.5k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (886)
16 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (886)
2.5k
sales
16 years
on Etsy
2.5k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (886)
16 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (886)
2.5k
sales
16 years
on Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All items

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jan 21, 2026
Michael and Sarah Sheridan

Contact shop owner

Michael and Sarah Sheridan

Reviews

4.9 (886)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.
Loading

About CastawayTradingCo

The Castaway Trading Co.

Sales 2,479
On Etsy since 2010

The Castaway Trading Co.

Setting sail with the Castaways!

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Sarah Rose & Michael Sheridan

    Owner, Maker, Designer

  • shop-member-photo
    Michael Sheridan

    Owner, Maker, Designer

  • shop-member-photo
    Sarah Rose

    Owner, Maker, Designer

Shop policies

Last updated on December 17, 2025

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 2 days of purchase

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Do you offer international shipping?

We absolutely do! If You want to buy one of our items that does not have an international shipping option listed, please send us a direct message and we will happily calculate your shipping costs and add them to the listing for you. HOWEVER, recent changes in shipping laws within the EU have made it extremely difficult for us to ship to Europe, so we have suspended selling within the European Union at this time. We apologize for the inconvenience.

Sizing details

If your are confused about what size you should purchase for one of our custom items, please - WE BEG YOU - message us BEFORE placing your order, and we will happily advise you on which size will work best for you.

Can I cancel my order?

We happily accept cancellation of any order within 48 hours of purchase, for any reason, for a full refund (EXCEPT in the case of rush-orders which cannot be cancelled under any circumstances). WE DO NOT ACCEPT CANCELLATIONS AFTER 48 HOURS, or once the item has been shipped, so please BE ABSOLUTELY SURE BEFORE YOU PURCHASE. The reason for this being: most in-stock items should ship within two to three days, and in the case of custom orders, these items cannot be resold, and the materials cannot be repurposed once we have begun constructing them to your measurements/specifications. Once again, rush-orders cannot be cancelled under any circumstances.

Why does our packaging look… well… kinda’ ugly sometimes?

We try to be economically and environmentally friendly by reusing old boxes and packing materials as much as possible rather than buying new. Rest assured your items will always be packaged safely even if the outside may look a bit shabby!

Do you accept returns?

The short answer is, no - and we especially will not accept returns for any custom, made-to-measure items. We make these items to fit you, and you alone, so we cannot resell them. This is why we emphasize: PLEASE provide accurate measurements, and PLEASE contact us with any questions BEFORE placing your order. We NEVER accept returns for worn/used items.
We try very hard to be as clear and transparent as possible in our listings, but we are not liable for buyers’ mistakes. However, if we make a mistake on our end, we are always happy to work with you to find a mutually beneficial solution.
If you buy something and ultimately change your mind after you receive it, we recommend looking into re-selling it to someone else who will enjoy it.

Do you accept exchanges?

We will consider exchanges on a case-by-case basis - primarily in the event that an item is flawed, or if we made a mistake in sizing. We try very hard to do quality-control before putting any item in the mail, but we are primarily a small, 2-person team, and mistakes can occasionally happen. We NEVER accept returns or exchanges for worn/used items.

Will my belt have enough length to tie the end like you show in the product pictures???

Yes.
Many people get confused by this for some reason, but We don’t use the same length of belt strap for everyone. We make every belt to order, from scratch, to the customer’s exact waist measurement, so all of the belts that are shown tied in the “Medieval knot” style are intentionally cut with a nice long tail on the end, so they can be tied just as shown in the product pictures. This is why it is important to give us your exact waist measurement in the listing, NOT the total measurement you think the entire belt should be. Just please make sure to include your exact waist measurement in the personalization field at checkout, and we will take care of the rest.

Will any dye from my belt/baldric/etc. come off on my clothing?

We work very hard to thoroughly seal all products as completely as possible, but most of our leather goods are at least partially hand-dyed, so some color transfer onto skin or clothing (especially light-colored or white clothing) is always possible.

Seller details