GeorgiaColonySmiths

Savannah, Georgia

4.4k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.8 (905)
12 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.8 (905)
4.4k
sales
12 years
on Etsy
4.4k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.8 (905)
12 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.8 (905)
4.4k
sales
12 years
on Etsy
Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
4399 Sales
589 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

All items

Salt Spoon - Style #5

Salt Spoon - Style #5

$4.98

Over 20 people have this in their cart
Round Russian Calvary Figures - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

Round Russian Calvary Figures - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

$10.59

Mjölnir Pendant Necklace

Mjölnir Pendant Necklace

$8.59

18th Century Plain American Rounded-End Pewter Spoon

18th Century Plain American Rounded-End Pewter Spoon

$14.59

Wolf Head Necklaces

Wolf Head Necklaces

$11.59

Pewter Dice - Reproduction 18th century Soldier's Game

Pewter Dice - Reproduction 18th century Soldier's Game

$6.84

Mounted Native Americans - 18th Century Toy Figures

Mounted Native Americans - 18th Century Toy Figures

$10.59

Beaver Pendant Necklaces

Beaver Pendant Necklaces

$11.59

3 people have this in their cart
Viking-Style Salt Spoon #2

Viking-Style Salt Spoon #2

$4.98

Salt Spoon - Style #6

Salt Spoon - Style #6

$4.98

4 people have this in their cart
St. Non's Cross Pendant Necklaces

St. Non's Cross Pendant Necklaces

$12.59

Pewter D12 Die

Pewter D12 Die

$12.59

Pewter D8 Die

Pewter D8 Die

$8.59

3 people have this in their cart
Pewter Anvil Charm Necklace

Pewter Anvil Charm Necklace

$9.09

Salt Spoon - Viking-Style #1

Salt Spoon - Viking-Style #1

$4.98

Round Infantry - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

Round Infantry - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

$5.59

Round Artillery Mortar Crew #2 SET WITH MORTAR - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

Round Artillery Mortar Crew #2 SET WITH MORTAR - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

$42.59

FREE shipping

Salt Spoon - Style #4

Salt Spoon - Style #4

$4.98

Salt Spoon - Style #2

Salt Spoon - Style #2

$4.98

Briton Swordsmen and Spearmen #1 - 28mm Roman War Role Playing Figures

Briton Swordsmen and Spearmen #1 - 28mm Roman War Role Playing Figures

$6.84

Pewter Heart

Pewter Heart

$12.59

18th Century Hanoverian Style Pewter Table Spoon - "Medium Spoon"

18th Century Hanoverian Style Pewter Table Spoon - "Medium Spoon"

$16.59

Pewter nativity set

Pewter nativity set

$56.59

FREE shipping

18th-19th Century Style French Pewter Spoon

18th-19th Century Style French Pewter Spoon

$20.59

Pewter D6 Die with Numbers

Pewter D6 Die with Numbers

$7.50

Pewter D10 Die

Pewter D10 Die

$7.59

Complete Set of 7 Heavy Pewter Role Playing Polyhedral Dice

Complete Set of 7 Heavy Pewter Role Playing Polyhedral Dice

$52.59

FREE shipping

18th-19th Century Fiddle-and-Thread French Pewter Table Spoon

18th-19th Century Fiddle-and-Thread French Pewter Table Spoon

$19.59

Semi-Flat Mounted Officers - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

Semi-Flat Mounted Officers - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

$10.59

Semi-Flat Painted Artillery Crews - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

Semi-Flat Painted Artillery Crews - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

$95.00

FREE shipping

Round Artillery Cannon Crew #1 WITHOUT CANNON - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

Round Artillery Cannon Crew #1 WITHOUT CANNON - 18th Century Toy Soldiers

$5.59

6 people have this in their cart
Round Artillery Cannons - 18th Century Toys

Round Artillery Cannons - 18th Century Toys

$12.59

17th-18th Century Plain Dognose-Style Pewter Table Spoon

17th-18th Century Plain Dognose-Style Pewter Table Spoon

$25.59

18th Century Hanoverian Style Pewter Table Spoon

18th Century Hanoverian Style Pewter Table Spoon

$14.59

Pewter Nail Cross Necklace

Pewter Nail Cross Necklace

$10.09

Salt Spoon - Style #3

Salt Spoon - Style #3

$4.98

3 people have this in their cart

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Aug 18, 2026
Jacob Grotheer

Contact shop owner

Jacob Grotheer

Contact shop owner

Reviews

4.8 (905)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

About GeorgiaColonySmiths

Colonial Goods and Stuff, made by Georgia Colony Smiths

Sales 4,399
On Etsy since 2014

Colonial Goods and Stuff, made by Georgia Colony Smiths

  • The usual set up

Purveyors of Colonial-era Reproduction Pewter and Blacksmithing Items

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Jacob Grotheer

    Owner, Pewtersmith

    I am a hobbyist with a full-time job. While timing might not always be my strong suit, I do my best to make high quality, handmade goods. I am the Pewtersmith of Georgia Colony Smiths.

  • shop-member-photo
    Tim Simpson

    Blacksmith

    Tim is the Blacksmith of Georgia Colony Smiths. He also assists in making and finishing pewter orders, painting chess sets and miniature soldiers, and providing moral support.

Shop policies

Last updated on April 22, 2014

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

“What is Pewter?”

By definition, pewter is any alloyed metal that is at least 85% tin. Historically, the remainder was split between copper, which adds strength, and antimony, an inert metal that helped cut down on material costs. (The antimony replaced the lead in most pewter by the 18th century.)

Does your Pewter have lead in it?

No. The pewter I use is lead-free. Most pewter in the last 300 years or so has been lead free. Though we did not truly understand just how bad lead is for you (or that it is a cumulative poison) until the 20th century, collectively we have known that lead is not good for you since the times of Ancient Rome. In the 2nd century BCE, Roman Army surgeon Dioscorides was said to have noted, "Lead makes the mind give way."

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy