Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

CompletelyBookmark

Seattle, Washington

73
 Sales

3 years
on Etsy

73
 sales

3 years
on Etsy

Following Follow

73
 Sales

3 years
on Etsy

73
 sales

3 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

Dolly Parton Hairspray bookmark

Dolly Parton Hairspray bookmark

$6.00

FREE shipping

1995's Animated White Christmas (VHS) bookmark | Movie bookmarks

1995's Animated White Christmas (VHS) bookmark | Movie bookmarks

$5.00

FREE shipping

Jeremy Allen White Merry and Bright Collage bookmark

Jeremy Allen White Merry and Bright Collage bookmark

$6.00

FREE shipping

Jeremy Allen White Collage bookmark

Jeremy Allen White Collage bookmark

$6.00

All items

ER Season 1 (DVD) cast bookmark | ER Show

ER Season 1 (DVD) cast bookmark | ER Show

$6.00

FREE shipping

Wacky Hats Pin-Up Collage Bookmark

Wacky Hats Pin-Up Collage Bookmark

$5.50

FREE shipping

Inspiration Pin-Up Collage Bookmark

Inspiration Pin-Up Collage Bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Planet Girl/American Girl Collage Bookmark

Planet Girl/American Girl Collage Bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

How to Say It American Girl Collage Bookmark

How to Say It American Girl Collage Bookmark

$6.00

FREE shipping

Pin Up Girl Painting Collage Bookmark

Pin Up Girl Painting Collage Bookmark

$5.00

Pam is Mad Pin-Up Collage Bookmark

Pam is Mad Pin-Up Collage Bookmark

$5.50

FREE shipping

Snow Train/American Girl Etiquette Bookmark

Snow Train/American Girl Etiquette Bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Pin Up Girl Dealer/Sap Collage Bookmark

Pin Up Girl Dealer/Sap Collage Bookmark

$5.00

Vintage Busy Housewife Collage Bookmark

Vintage Busy Housewife Collage Bookmark

$5.50

Wind Forces Collage Bookmark

Wind Forces Collage Bookmark

$5.50

FREE shipping

Pin Up Girl Collage Bookmark

Pin Up Girl Collage Bookmark

$5.00

1995's Animated White Christmas (VHS) bookmark | Movie bookmarks

1995's Animated White Christmas (VHS) bookmark | Movie bookmarks

$5.00

FREE shipping

Annie Murphy / Alexis Rose bookmark | Schitt's Creek

Annie Murphy / Alexis Rose bookmark | Schitt's Creek

$6.00

FREE shipping

Trio of Vintage Amelia Bedelia Books

Trio of Vintage Amelia Bedelia Books

$35.00

FREE shipping

1970s Middle Grade Nostalgic Book Trio

1970s Middle Grade Nostalgic Book Trio

$15.00

FREE shipping

1990s VHS Disney Movie Order Form bookmarks

1990s VHS Disney Movie Order Form bookmarks

$5.00

Tin Cup Bookmarks (VHS)

Tin Cup Bookmarks (VHS)

$5.00

Lieutenant Gabriel "Gabe" Cash bookmark

Lieutenant Gabriel "Gabe" Cash bookmark

$5.50

FREE shipping

The Land Before Time II: The Great Valley Adventure bookmark

The Land Before Time II: The Great Valley Adventure bookmark

$5.50

FREE shipping

Harry and the Hendersons cast bookmark

Harry and the Hendersons cast bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Leaving Las Vegas (VHS) bookmarks | Movie bookmarks

Leaving Las Vegas (VHS) bookmarks | Movie bookmarks

$5.00

Unhappy Feelings bookmark

Unhappy Feelings bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Jeanie Boulet | ER Season 2 (DVD) bookmark | TV bookmarks

Jeanie Boulet | ER Season 2 (DVD) bookmark | TV bookmarks

$6.00

FREE shipping

Carol Hathaway | ER Season 2 (DVD) bookmark | TV bookmarks

Carol Hathaway | ER Season 2 (DVD) bookmark | TV bookmarks

$6.00

All of Me (VHS) bookmark

All of Me (VHS) bookmark

$5.00

Devil in a Blue Dress (VHS) bookmark

Devil in a Blue Dress (VHS) bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Internet | American Girl Collage bookmark

Internet | American Girl Collage bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Grief and Condolences American Girl Collage bookmark

Grief and Condolences American Girl Collage bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

The Mall American Girl Collage bookmark

The Mall American Girl Collage bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Chitchat and Losers American Girl Collage bookmark

Chitchat and Losers American Girl Collage bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Nose-Picking and Gum American Girl Collage bookmark

Nose-Picking and Gum American Girl Collage bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

McDonald's Fries bookmark

McDonald's Fries bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Monica and Chandler Collage bookmark

Monica and Chandler Collage bookmark

$6.00

FREE shipping

Ray's Pizza bookmark

Ray's Pizza bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

You Are a Person American Girl Collage bookmark

You Are a Person American Girl Collage bookmark

$5.00

FREE shipping

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Dec 22, 2024

Jess Tholmer

Contact shop owner

Jess Tholmer

Reviews

4.7 (27)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Loading

Shannan on Dec 16, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Product was exactly as advertised and received within a wek.

Jess responded on Dec 16, 2025

Enjoy! 🩷

Book Bundle Gift: Graeme Base Books

Book Bundle Gift: Graeme Base Books
Kadi on Sep 17, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Books and and case are in such good condition and shipped super fast!

Boxed Set of Laura Ingall Wilder's Little House on the Prairie

Boxed Set of Laura Ingall Wilder's Little House on the Prairie
Bianca on Apr 9, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Book was in great condition. One of the best poet/novelists ever.

Jess responded on Apr 13, 2025

So, so glad you enjoyed!

Ocean Vuong Book Pairing

Ocean Vuong Book Pairing
Maritza on Jan 26, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Excellent! Amazing! This is a wonderful Etsy seller

Romeo + Juliet (VHS Spine) bookmark

Romeo + Juliet (VHS Spine) bookmark
Joseph on Jan 4, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Great bundle, professional seller, would buy from them again!

Great Black Literary Fiction Book Trio

Great Black Literary Fiction Book Trio
Laurent on Mar 16, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

This is my second time ordering from them and there was a hiccup in the beginning that was all because of the app and not the business at all. However their communication was fast and the bookmark came in the projected time. Along with some extra extra goodies. 😍😊 Again can’t wait to order a third and forth time. They now have a loyal customer 🤗

Pancake bookmark

Pancake bookmark
Jason on Jan 16, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Great experience with this seller and the product! Bought a bookmark for a stocking stuffer and the recipient loved it. Will definitely buy from again!

Jess responded on Jan 16, 2024

So happy to hear that! Laura Dern rules!

Laura Dern / Queen Latifah Bookmark

Laura Dern / Queen Latifah Bookmark
Ashlyn on Dec 12, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

They were so cute, exactly like the pictures! I'm gonna need allllll the Dr. Carter bookmarks, thank you! 🤣💙

Doug, Carter, and Carol / Susan and Mark - ER Season 2 Bookmark

Doug, Carter, and Carol / Susan and Mark - ER Season 2 Bookmark
Jewels on Oct 15, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

George beats McDreamy any day of the week. Sigh.....cool bookmark! Photo is most accurate!

Jess responded on Oct 15, 2023

Doug Ross > McDreamy forever

Doug - ER Season 2 Bookmark

Doug - ER Season 2 Bookmark
Karen on Oct 15, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

Received very quick. Such a throw back piece. Fun to find.

Jess responded on Oct 15, 2023

🥰🥰🥰

Doug and Mark - ER bookmark

Doug and Mark - ER bookmark

About CompletelyBookmark

Mostly bookmarks created out of collage and VHS art.

Sales 73

On Etsy since 2023

Mostly bookmarks created out of collage and VHS art.

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Electronics Cases

Shop Google Pixel Decal

Kitchen & Dining

Buy Vintage Plaid Dishes Online Ceramic Leaf Bowls 3 - US

Paper

Shop Rv Trailer Contract Christmas Card for Baba by audaciouscards

Floor & Rugs

Lord Watch Over My Crib While I Get This Money

Necklaces

Buy Turquoise Necklace 1950s Online

Pet Clothing Accessories & Shoes

HARRIS TWEED Dog neckerchief / bandana by CollaredbyMark

Lighting

Wooden Lampshade - US

Spirituality & Religion

Hiking stick with crystals

Pouches & Coin Purses

Personalized Suede Pouch Bulk for Sale

Findings

Blue Topaz Station Triangle Pendant- 15mm Gold Over Sterling Bezel Single Bail Charm Pendant (S34B17-01) by jewelersparadise

Suit & Tie Accessories

Jack Daniels Cufflinks - US

Earrings

All seeing eye ear gauges Sad boy earrings 6 gauge ear weights Evil eye gauged earrings 6g 2g 0g 00g 1/2” 9/16” 5/8” 3/4” 7/8” 1” 1.10” 1.18 by TammyGMSCN

Toys

Buy Mickey Mouse Playset Online

Closures & Fasteners

Vintage Streamlines Green Parrot Buttons Set of 3 on card 18mm by KitchenKlutter

Furniture

Gibbard Furniture - US

Party Supplies

Buy Birthday Backdrop Pink Online