MyCustomKeys

Chiefland, Florida

355
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (75)
1 year
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (75)
355
sales
1 year
on Etsy
355
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (75)
1 year
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9 (75)
355
sales
1 year
on Etsy
Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
355 Sales
50 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All items

Personalized Love Lock: Custom Engraved Padlock, Wedding Anniversary Memorial

Personalized Love Lock: Custom Engraved Padlock, Wedding Anniversary Memorial

$26.95

5 people have this in their cart
Personalized Custom House Key: Made to Order Engraved Home or Office Keys

Personalized Custom House Key: Made to Order Engraved Home or Office Keys

$8.00

14 people have this in their cart
Villainesse House Key, Uncut or Cut by Code Evil Queen, Maleficent, Ursala, Cruella Disney Villians

Villainesse House Key, Uncut or Cut by Code Evil Queen, Maleficent, Ursala, Cruella Disney Villians

$8.00

8 people have this in their cart
Personalized House Shaped Key: Custom Engraved Brass Home Key Blank

Personalized House Shaped Key: Custom Engraved Brass Home Key Blank

$8.00

5 people have this in their cart
Personalized Gardening House Key: Engraved custom home or office key

Personalized Gardening House Key: Engraved custom home or office key

$16.00

Logo or Character Custom Large House Key Personalized Engraved Any Theme or Message

Logo or Character Custom Large House Key Personalized Engraved Any Theme or Message

$16.00

Warner Bros' Scooby-Doo uncut House Key blank or cut by code

Warner Bros' Scooby-Doo uncut House Key blank or cut by code

$8.00

Disney Pixar Monster's Inc Mike & Sully House Key blank or cut by code

Disney Pixar Monster's Inc Mike & Sully House Key blank or cut by code

$8.00

5 people have this in their cart
Cannabis Marijuana Leaf Key-Tag, Personalized Pet Tag fully customizable

Cannabis Marijuana Leaf Key-Tag, Personalized Pet Tag fully customizable

$7.00

Personalized Neon House Key: Laser Engraved Aluminum Blank

Personalized Neon House Key: Laser Engraved Aluminum Blank

$8.00

SpongeBob Square Pants uncut House Key blank or cut by code

SpongeBob Square Pants uncut House Key blank or cut by code

$8.00

Custom Large House Key Personalized Full Color Photo Keys

Custom Large House Key Personalized Full Color Photo Keys

$18.00

Jack & Sally House Key, Uncut or Cut by Code Nightmare Before Christmas

Jack & Sally House Key, Uncut or Cut by Code Nightmare Before Christmas

$8.00

Custom Pet Tag Bone Shaped Personalized 3 sizes Small, Medium X Large

Custom Pet Tag Bone Shaped Personalized 3 sizes Small, Medium X Large

$4.00

Beach Lover's Large House Key Personalized Anodized Aluminum Custom Engraved Summer Time

Beach Lover's Large House Key Personalized Anodized Aluminum Custom Engraved Summer Time

$16.00

It's Happy Bunny "Let's Focus On Me" house key blank, Jim Benton Design

It's Happy Bunny "Let's Focus On Me" house key blank, Jim Benton Design

$8.00

Custom Key Tags Round Personalized Label key ring tag

Custom Key Tags Round Personalized Label key ring tag

$4.00

Custom Crystal Pet ID Tag: Bone Shaped Rhinestone Bling

Custom Crystal Pet ID Tag: Bone Shaped Rhinestone Bling

$6.00

Custom Large House Key Personalized Anodized Aluminum Engraved Any Theme or Message

Custom Large House Key Personalized Anodized Aluminum Engraved Any Theme or Message

$16.00

Coffee Lover's Large House Key Personalized Anodized Aluminum Custom Engraved Coffee Shop

Coffee Lover's Large House Key Personalized Anodized Aluminum Custom Engraved Coffee Shop

$16.00

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Aug 18, 2026
Gator Reinholtz

Contact shop owner

Gator Reinholtz

Contact shop owner

Reviews

4.9 (75)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

About MyCustomKeys

Shop will close Aug 21-Sept 1. Last order ships Aug 20

Sales 355
On Etsy since 2025

Shop will close Aug 21-Sept 1. Last order ships Aug 20

  • Corporate Gifts
  • Team Gifts with ball chain necklaces
  • Anything you want engraved front &/or back
  • Service Dog Tags
  • Visit Pretty-Keys.com for over 300 themed novelty house keys

A 3-generation locksmith family, now offering online key services.

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Gator Reinholtz

    Owner, Curator, Maker

    Gator, the youngest in a 3 generation locksmith family. Working Gator Boyz Locksmith, a mobile locksmith service in Okeechobee, FL. Working with his mom and business partner- Debbie-a lady locksmith offering custom keys, tags, locks and more.

  • shop-member-photo
    Debbie B.

    Owner, Designer, Maker

    Debbie, aka Mom, 2nd-generation lady locksmith. Semi-retired and owner of MyPrettyKeys.com an online key shop, pop-up events, and along with her husband's mobile locksmith service, The KeyMan in Levy, Dixie, Gilchrist county of NW Florida.

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.