All Natural Handmade Soap & Skincare from Long Island.

Islip, New York · 142 Sales


All Natural Handmade Soap & Skincare from Long Island.

Islip, New York 142 Sales On Etsy since 2012

0 out of 5 stars

FancyNancySoap is taking a short break

Nancy Lewis

Contact shop owner

Nancy Lewis


No reviews in the last year
View all 43 reviews


Homemade all natural soap & skincare from Long Island.

I launched Fancy Nancy Soap in 2011 after having such a hard time finding natural bath products in my area.

My pure and natural handmade soaps made from scratch are chock full of authentic, nourishing ingredients. In addition to soap, I offer homemade lip balms, body lotion, bath bombs, animal shampoo, and more!

Connect with me on Facebook!

Around the web

Shop members

  • Nancy Lewis


    My name is Nancy Lewis and I’m from Long Island, New York. Outside of soap making, I am a professional landscaper. I grow the majority of the plant materials I use in my bath & beauty products right in my own backyard – pesticide free!

Shop policies

Last updated on March 10, 2016

Accepted payment methods

Returns and exchanges
Please send me a message first if you are unhappy with your purchase. I will try to help you the best I can.

With that being said, I will only accept returns for unused products in their original packaging (no broken seals). Once I receive the items back, you will be refunded, sans shipping & handling.
Our online ordering system accepts all major credit cards, securely processed through PayPal. You do not have to have a PayPal account to check out.

If you live in Long Island (near Oakdale), I might be able to arrange local pickup & local delivery. Please message me or call first to see if this can be arranged. (631) 774-2854
At this time, Fancy Nancy Soap only ships within the United States. We apologize for any inconvenience.

Upon receiving payment, we will ship your order out within 48 hours, but usually within 24. We ship through USPS via First Class or Priority Mail (typically delivered within 1-3 days), depending on the weight of your order.
Additional policies and FAQs
If you’re interested in purchasing wholesale handmade soaps or bulk orders, please give me a call at (631) 774-2854 or shoot me an email. I can ship to you, or deliver your order if you’re located in the surrounding Long Island area.

Wholesale Information:

My home made soaps & skincare products are available for wholesale. I’d be more than happy to negotiate a wholesale agreement that works for your business. When you carry Fancy Nancy Soap in your inventory, you can trust that your customers will go home with a high-quality product, always made with pure ingredients and love.

Bulk Ordering Information:

Fancy Nancy’s all natural handmade soap and lip balm are great gifts & party favors. You can order my products in bulk in regular or smaller sizes for your guests, bridal showers, weddings, baby showers, Bar and Bat Mitzvah’s, sweet sixteens, birthdays, and just about any occasion! We can even customize our labels to compliment your event or theme.


Legal Stuff: All of my products are made by hand in my Long Island (Suffolk County) home. Fancy Nancy Soap and skincare products are for external use only. As with all cosmetics, test a small area before applying liberally. Discontinue use if irritation develops, avoid sensitive areas.