FindAPennyPaperCo

Oak Park, Illinois

9.5k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (2.3k)
11 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (2.3k)
9.5k
sales
11 years
on Etsy
9.5k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (2.3k)
11 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (2.3k)
9.5k
sales
11 years
on Etsy

FindAPennyPaperCo is taking a short break

Loading

Note from shop owner Thanks for stopping by my shop! I am closed until August 12. Please message me if you have any questions!

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Aug 1, 2026

Thanks for stopping by my shop! I am closed until August 12. Please message me if you have any questions!

Colleen DeJarnatt

Contact shop owner

Colleen DeJarnatt

Reviews

5.0 (2314)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.
Loading

About FindAPennyPaperCo

Personalized Stationery & Custom Paper Goods

Sales 9,506
On Etsy since 2015

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Personalized Stationery & Custom Paper Goods

“Find a penny, pick it up. All day long, you’ll have good luck.”

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Colleen DeJarnatt

    Owner, Designer

    I'm the mother of two happy, silly little girls. When I'm not working, you can find me trying to keep up with them!

Shop policies

Last updated on Oct 13, 2018

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options
Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

RETURN POLICY

I want you to be happy with your purchase, so please contact me if there are any problems! If the names or monograms provided at checkout were not correct, or if you approved a proof prior to print, please know that I cannot offer refunds or exchanges due to spelling or customization issues. If there is any mistake on my part, I will of course promptly replace your item free of charge. And if you are not happy for any other reason, please reach out to me and we will find a way to fix it!

ELECTRONIC PROOFS + APPROVALS

I want you to be completely happy with your order! That’s why every custom order receives an electronic proof via Etsy convo. I will copy your personalization text exactly as you have provided it. Please check everything carefully, as I cannot refund or accept returns of personalized products due to spelling or customization issues once I have approval to print.

I am happy to make changes until you love it, and proofs *must be approved* before the order is sent to print. I will follow up with you no more than four times. If I do not hear back from you at all after two weeks from the time the proof was sent, I will need to cancel the transaction, since I don't want you to have paid for something you don't receive.

SHIPPING METHODS + PRICING

{U.S. SHIPPING} All orders of $35 or more ship free! Small orders under $35 ship USPS First Class Mail (2-6 business days in transit) starting at $4. Larger orders under $35, Christmas cards, and art prints ship Priority Mail (2-3 business days in transit) starting at $5. You will receive shipment tracking with each order. Priority Mail and Express upgrades are available at checkout.

{INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING} Orders ship Global Postal or USPS Priority Mail International with shipment tracking. Base shipping price for international orders is $30; depending on destination and order size, final pricing may be higher or lower. I don't want anyone to be surprised, so convo me first for a quote!

STATIONERY PACKAGING

Flat note card sets include 12 note cards and matching envelopes; folded note card sets include 10 cards and matching envelopes.

The Find A Penny logo is printed on the back of all folded notecards. If you are ordering a customized card and would like for the logo to be removed, please let me know. The logo is also stamped onto the back of each notepad.

Stationary sets are gift-ready, packaged in a clear gift box. Notepads and art prints are sealed in a clear cello sleeve. All stationery and notepad orders come with my shop label, which includes a real, shiny penny (heads up, of course!) for good luck.

COLOR ACCURACY

There is always a chance that there may be a difference between the colors you see on your screen and the way the colors look when printed. But I have worked very hard to make sure that what you see in the listing photo is what you receive in-hand. I confidently stand behind it and do not think you will be disappointed! But, as always, if you have any questions or problems, just reach out to me!

CANCELATION POLICY

Even if an item isn't personalized, I custom print each order as I receive it. So my official policy is that I cannot accept cancelations, since I often begin printing right away. But if you change your mind on an order, please reach out to me -- I will definitely work with you to find a solution. Please note that, for personalized items, once a proof is approved, I cannot accept cancelations and the order must be paid in full.

Proofs *must be approved* before the order is sent to print. If I do not hear back from you at all after two weeks from the time the proof was sent, I will need to cancel the transaction, since I don't want you to have paid for something you don't receive!

Seller details