FirstColonyGifts

Okemos, Michigan

376
 Sales

4.9 (51)

10 months
on Etsy

4.9 (51)

376
 sales

10 months
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

376
 Sales

4.9 (51)

10 months
on Etsy

4.9 (51)

376
 sales

10 months
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

376 Sales

50 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jan 28, 2026

Returns & Refunds Policy

All of our products are made to order and produced specifically for each customer after an order is placed. We do not keep pre-made or stocked items, and every product is custom created.

For this reason, we do not accept returns or offer refunds for items due to personal preferences, including but not limited to:

Not matching personal taste or decor,

Change of mind,

Ordering by mistake.

We only accept returns or provide refunds in the following cases:

If the item arrives damaged,

If the item is defective due to a production issue,

If the wrong item was sent.

In such cases, customers must contact us within 48 hours of delivery and provide clear photos of the issue so we can assist promptly.

We appreciate your understanding and thank you for supporting handmade and made-to-order products.

Contact shop owner

ALI BAYRAM

Reviews

4.9 (51)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Etsy buyer on Jul 27, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Cute cover. Fast shipping and my daughter is going to love it!

Playful Otter Pattern Personalized Phone Case Tough Protective Case for iPhone 17 16 15 14 13 12 Air Pro Max Samsung S25 S24 S22 Ultra

Playful Otter Pattern Personalized Phone Case Tough Protective Case for iPhone 17 16 15 14 13 12 Air Pro Max Samsung S25 S24 S22 Ultra
Etsy buyer on Jul 25, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great birthday gift, nice quality

God Forbid Women Have Hobbies Coffee Mug, Feminist Christmas Gift, Witch Mug, Patriarchy Mugs, Witchy Mug, Girl Power Mug, Christmas Mug

God Forbid Women Have Hobbies Coffee Mug, Feminist Christmas Gift, Witch Mug, Patriarchy Mugs, Witchy Mug, Girl Power Mug, Christmas Mug
Beth on Jul 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

My little cousin loved it! So cute!

Playful Otter Pattern Personalized Accessory Pouch |T-Bottom Makeup-Cosmetic Zipper Bag, Gifts for Her

Playful Otter Pattern Personalized Accessory Pouch |T-Bottom Makeup-Cosmetic Zipper Bag, Gifts for Her
Sarah on Jul 9, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is such a cute case and it arrived earlier than estimated. Would highly recommend!

Playful Otter Pattern Personalized Phone Case Tough Protective Case for iPhone 17 16 15 14 13 12 Air Pro Max Samsung S25 S24 S22 Ultra

Playful Otter Pattern Personalized Phone Case Tough Protective Case for iPhone 17 16 15 14 13 12 Air Pro Max Samsung S25 S24 S22 Ultra
Yvonne on Jul 7, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely exceeded my expectations! I couldn’t be happier with this custom phone case from FirstColonyGifts! The photo quality is incredible—it’s sharp, vibrant, and captures every little detail of my grandson’s smile perfectly. The colors are beautiful, and the image looks even better in person than I expected. The case itself feels sturdy and well-made, with a nice grip and a snug fit on my phone. The cutouts and buttons line up perfectly, and it doesn’t add unnecessary bulk. This is such a meaningful keepsake that I get to carry with me every day. I’ve already received several compliments on it, and people are amazed by how clear the photo is. If you’re thinking about ordering a custom case, don’t hesitate. I would absolutely buy from FirstColonyGifts again! Highly recommend! ❤️

Tough Custom Photo iPhone Case | Personalized Samsung Galaxy Case | Custom Pet Photo Gift | Photo Gift for Her | Fast Shipping

Tough Custom Photo iPhone Case | Personalized Samsung Galaxy Case | Custom Pet Photo Gift | Photo Gift for Her | Fast Shipping
Marianne on Jul 7, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I have already reviewed this little makeup pouch twice, but I guess it's not going through. It is very cute & the young girl I bought it for is very happy with it. She loves Corgis & the overall floral pattern is lovely.

Corgi Floral Pattern Accessory Pouch | T-Bottom Makeup Bag

Corgi Floral Pattern Accessory Pouch | T-Bottom Makeup Bag
Judy on Jul 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great gift for my granddaughter

Personalized Yellow Rubber Duck Accessory Pouch, Cosmetic Bag

Personalized Yellow Rubber Duck Accessory Pouch, Cosmetic Bag
Judy on Jul 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great gift for my granddaughter

Personalized Rubber Duck Tote Bag | Yellow All-Over Print Weekender

Personalized Rubber Duck Tote Bag | Yellow All-Over Print Weekender
Judy on Jul 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great gift for my daughter

Personalized Yellow Rubber Duck Accessory Pouch, Cosmetic Bag

Personalized Yellow Rubber Duck Accessory Pouch, Cosmetic Bag
Claire on Jul 5, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Customer service was great, a photo is sent before the case is sent out to make sure you're happy with it. Bright and vibrant colours. And it's also not slippy which is good

Personalized Psychedelic Paisley Peace Sign iPhone Case | Retro Floral Cover

Personalized Psychedelic Paisley Peace Sign iPhone Case | Retro Floral Cover

About FirstColonyGifts

Thoughtful Gifts for Every Heart and Profession

Sales 376

On Etsy since 2025

Thoughtful Gifts for Every Heart and Profession

Welcome to our shop!

Based in Okemos, Michigan, we create thoughtfully designed personalized gifts and custom keepsakes to celebrate life's special moments. From cozy blankets and baby gifts to pet memorials and unique home décor, our products are crafted with care and attention to detail.

Many of our designs are handmade and created in-house, allowing us to offer unique, meaningful products that make wonderful gifts for family, friends, and loved ones.

Our goal is to provide high-quality products, excellent customer service, and a smooth shopping experience from start to finish. Thank you for supporting our small business we're honored to be part of your special memories.

Shop members

Elly

Owner, Curator

Production partners

A professional print and fulfillment partner

Wilmington, DE

They print my original designs on high-quality products and handle the shipping directly to my customers. This allows me to focus on creating unique artwork and designs while ensuring professional production and reliable delivery.

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Seller details

View shop registration details

FirstColonyGifts

Featured items

Kawaii Miffy Phone Case, Starry Night Kawaii Bunny Phone Case, Cute Rabbit Celestial Phone Case, Gift For Her

God Forbid Women Have Hobbies Coffee Mug, Feminist Christmas Gift, Witch Mug, Patriarchy Mugs, Witchy Mug, Girl Power Mug, Christmas Mug

Miffy Phone Case, Kawaii Bunny, Cute Rabbit Tulip Celestial, Cute Bunny Floral Phone Case, Gift For Her

Custom Photo Phone Case Cover For iPhone 17, 17 Air, 17 Pro Max, 16, Personalized Image Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra Phone Case, Tough Case

All items

Personalized Cotton Pillow Two Photos Custom Double sided Photo Cushion Cover Decorative Throw Pillows

Sea Otter Tote Bag, Custom Name Aquatic Floral Otter Pattern, Cute Ocean Animal Canvas Bag, Reusable Shopping Tote, Otter Lover Gift

Cute Sea Otter Phone Case, Teal Otter Pattern iPhone Case, Tough Protective Cover, Ocean Animal Lover Gift, Otter Gift for Her

Sea Otter Pattern Accessory Pouch, T-Bottom Makeup Bag, Cute Aquatic Otter Cosmetic Bag, Ocean Animal Travel Pouch, Gift for Her

Otter Pattern Phone Case, Tough Protective iPhone Case, Cute Sea Otter Cover, Animal Lover Gift, Protective Phone Case for Her

Playful Seal Pattern Accessory Pouch, T-Bottom Cosmetic Bag, Cute Seal Makeup Bag, Ocean Animal Zipper Pouch, Gift for Her

Personalized Otter Tote Bag, Custom Name Canvas Bag, Cute Playful Otter Pattern, Animal Lover Gift, Reusable Shopping Bag

Personalized Otter Mug, Custom Name Ceramic Coffee Mug, Cute Otter Pattern Cup, Sea Otter Lover Gift, Animal Mug for Her

Miffy Phone Case, Kawaii Bunny, Cute Rabbit Tulip Celestial, Cute Bunny Floral Phone Case, Gift For Her

Personalized Bulldog Accessory Pouch, Custom Name Cosmetic Bag, Cute Bulldog Pattern Makeup Bag, Dog Lover Gift, Travel Zipper Pouch

Whimsical Lighthouse Seaside Scene Accessory Pouch, Bridesmaid Gift for Her, Mother Christmas Home Gift, Teen Birthday Gift for Her

Personalized Pug Spiral Bound Journal, Cute Pug Faces & Bones Notebook, Custom Name Journal, Dog Lover Gift, Pug Mom Gift

Custom Logo Spiral Notebook, Personalized Monogram Journal, Blank Cover Design, 5x7 Lined Journal, Business Gift, Custom Notebook

Zohran New York City baby onesie | Infant Bodysuit, Political Pride Zohran Mamdani

Custom Pet Photo Blanket, Personalized Dog Portrait Blanket, Pet Memorial Gift, Cat Picture Blanket

Playful Otter Pattern Personalized Phone Case Tough Protective Case for iPhone 17 16 15 14 13 12 Air Pro Max Samsung S25 S24 S22 Ultra

God Forbid Women Have Hobbies Coffee Mug, Feminist Christmas Gift, Witch Mug, Patriarchy Mugs, Witchy Mug, Girl Power Mug, Christmas Mug

Personalized Floral Phone Case, Custom Name Phone Case, Botanical Flower, Tough Protective Case, iPhone, Samsung, Google Pixel, Gift For Her

Custom Photo Phone Case Cover For iPhone 17, 17 Air, 17 Pro Max, 16, Personalized Image Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra Phone Case, Tough Case

Personalized Rubber Duck Tote Bag | Yellow All-Over Print Weekender

Personalized Pet Custom Shaped Pillow, Custom Dog & Cat Photo Pillow, Pet Memorial Gift, Custom Shaped Pet Portrait Cushion, Pet Lover Gift

Personalized Beach Towel, Custom Name Striped Towel, Pool Towel, Groovy Beach Gift, Bachelorette Gift, Bridesmaid Gift

Playful Otter Pattern Personalized Accessory Pouch |T-Bottom Makeup-Cosmetic Zipper Bag, Gifts for Her

Personalized Striped Makeup Bag | Custom Name Cosmetic Pouch | Bridesmaid Gift | Toiletry Bag Accessory Pouch

Personalized Yellow Rubber Duck Accessory Pouch, Cosmetic Bag

Pink Heart Panda Accessory Pouch | Personalized Name T-Bottom Makeup-Cosmetic Bag

Hand Drawn Siamese Cat Accessory Pouch Cute Cat Makeup Bag Zipper Cosmetic Bag Cat Lover Gift Travel Organizer

Cute Cat Phone Case Playful Kitten Pattern Tough Case Kawaii Cat Lover Gift iPhone Samsung Protective Cover

Corgi Floral Pattern Accessory Pouch | T-Bottom Makeup Bag

Blushing Florals phone case Pink Rose Stripe phone case | Tough Case

Blushing Florals Phone Case Vintage Blush Roses phone case | Tough Cases

Simple stripe Cat and fish Phone Case Cat Funny Creativity iPhone Case for iPhone 17 16 15 14 13 12 Air Pro Max Samsung S25 S24 S22 Ultra

America 250 Mug, 250th Years Anniversary Commemorative Floral Patriotic Gift Coffee Mug, Independence Day Mug, Accent Coffee Mug 11oz 15oz

Personalized Psychedelic Paisley Peace Sign iPhone Case | Retro Floral Cover

Baldurs Gate 3 Owlbear Mug, Coffee Mug, Cute Gamer Gift, BG3 Coffee Cup

Custom Logo Blanket Personalized Business Logo Throw Custom Printed Blanket Company Branding Gift Velveteen Plush Blanket

Announcement

Reviews

About FirstColonyGifts

Shop members

Elly

Production partners

Shop policies

Returns & exchanges

Seller details