FreethinkerPaperCo

Chicago, Illinois

1.3k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (361)
2 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (361)
1.3k
sales
2 years
on Etsy
1.3k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (361)
2 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (361)
1.3k
sales
2 years
on Etsy
Contact shop owner
1320 Sales
328 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All items

soft velvety matte earth conscious activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, heather purple ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte earth conscious activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, heather purple ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

soft velvety matte earth conscious activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, pale pink ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte earth conscious activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, pale pink ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

soft velvety matte earth conscious activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, moss green ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte earth conscious activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, moss green ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

5 people have this in their cart
i see you ~ encouraging card ~ card for best friend ~ just because card ~ friendship card ~ good job, you’re doing great ~ eco-friendly card

i see you ~ encouraging card ~ card for best friend ~ just because card ~ friendship card ~ good job, you’re doing great ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

soft velvety matte activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, dark teal ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, dark teal ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

soft velvety matte led zeppelin lyric button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, light chartreuse ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte led zeppelin lyric button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, light chartreuse ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

soft velvety matte vegan animal rights activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, blush pink ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte vegan animal rights activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, blush pink ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

soft velvety matte activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, mustard yellow ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, mustard yellow ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

soft velvety matte albert camus quote button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, london fog ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte albert camus quote button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, london fog ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

Annie Dillard quote bookmark ~ soft matte feel ~ pretty coastal beach aesthetic ~ bookworm gift ~ read every day ~ unplug and read a book

Annie Dillard quote bookmark ~ soft matte feel ~ pretty coastal beach aesthetic ~ bookworm gift ~ read every day ~ unplug and read a book

$5.00

soft velvety matte vegan animal rights activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, dusty brown ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte vegan animal rights activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, dusty brown ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

3 people have this in their cart
soft velvety matte james baldwin quote button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, carnelian red ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte james baldwin quote button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, carnelian red ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

soft velvety matte earth conscious activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, yellow ochre ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

soft velvety matte earth conscious activism button pin ~ 1.25 inch round, yellow ochre ~ eco-friendly recycled metal pinback button

$3.50

thinking of you ~ quirky snail mail card ~ funny just because card ~ card for pen pal ~ card for long distance friend ~ eco-friendly card

thinking of you ~ quirky snail mail card ~ funny just because card ~ card for pen pal ~ card for long distance friend ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

funny love card ~ funny valentine's day card ~ anniversary card ~ quirky card for boyfriend, girlfriend, wife, husband ~ i love you so much

funny love card ~ funny valentine's day card ~ anniversary card ~ quirky card for boyfriend, girlfriend, wife, husband ~ i love you so much

$6.00

i love you card ~ sweet sentimental card from parent to child ~ romantic anniversary card ~ keepsake card ~ all my heart ~ eco-friendly card

i love you card ~ sweet sentimental card from parent to child ~ romantic anniversary card ~ keepsake card ~ all my heart ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

soul mate card ~ lucky to know you card ~ best friend card ~ anniversary card ~ i love us card ~ space themed card ~ eco-friendly card

soul mate card ~ lucky to know you card ~ best friend card ~ anniversary card ~ i love us card ~ space themed card ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

10 people have this in their cart
sorry mama ~ funny mother’s day card ~ sweet card for mom from daughter ~ love you mom card ~ super mom card ~ eco-friendly card

sorry mama ~ funny mother’s day card ~ sweet card for mom from daughter ~ love you mom card ~ super mom card ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

quirky wedding congratulations card ~ funny engagement card for couple ~ friends wedding card ~ wedding shower card ~ eco-friendly card

quirky wedding congratulations card ~ funny engagement card for couple ~ friends wedding card ~ wedding shower card ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

in this family ~ father’s day card for mom ~ card for single mom from kids ~ hardworking mom ~ super mom card ~ eco-friendly card

in this family ~ father’s day card for mom ~ card for single mom from kids ~ hardworking mom ~ super mom card ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

great teacher ~ funny teacher appreciation card ~ card for teacher from parents ~ teacher humor card ~ blank inside ~ eco-friendly card

great teacher ~ funny teacher appreciation card ~ card for teacher from parents ~ teacher humor card ~ blank inside ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

good friend card ~ thank you card ~ best friend’s birthday card ~ just because card ~ friendship card ~ encouragement ~ eco-friendly card

good friend card ~ thank you card ~ best friend’s birthday card ~ just because card ~ friendship card ~ encouragement ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

tacos greeting card ~ simple funny card ~ date night ~ let’s taco bout it ~ just because card ~ anytime greeting card ~ eco-friendly card

tacos greeting card ~ simple funny card ~ date night ~ let’s taco bout it ~ just because card ~ anytime greeting card ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

f cancer ~ cancer sucks card ~ fighting cancer ~ here for you card ~ sending strength card ~ cancer care package card ~ eco-friendly card

f cancer ~ cancer sucks card ~ fighting cancer ~ here for you card ~ sending strength card ~ cancer care package card ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

sentimental thank you card ~ appreciation card ~ thanks for being there ~ thanks for being a friend ~ eco-friendly card

sentimental thank you card ~ appreciation card ~ thanks for being there ~ thanks for being a friend ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

80th birthday card ~ octogenarian card ~ funny birthday card for grandparent ~ age is just a number ~ milestone birthday ~ eco-friendly card

80th birthday card ~ octogenarian card ~ funny birthday card for grandparent ~ age is just a number ~ milestone birthday ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

manifest that ~ funny birthday card ~ snarky birthday card for friend ~ birthday wish ~ manifestation ~ you got this ~ eco-friendly card

manifest that ~ funny birthday card ~ snarky birthday card for friend ~ birthday wish ~ manifestation ~ you got this ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

simple thank you card ~ blank inside ~ floral thank you greeting card ~ thank you note ~ appreciation card ~ eco-friendly card

simple thank you card ~ blank inside ~ floral thank you greeting card ~ thank you note ~ appreciation card ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

funny get well soon card ~ card for sick friend ~ quirky speedy recovery card ~ superhero origin ~ encouragement card ~ eco-friendly card

funny get well soon card ~ card for sick friend ~ quirky speedy recovery card ~ superhero origin ~ encouragement card ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

wish you were here greeting card ~ wish you lived next door ~ just because card ~ miss you card ~ pen pal ~ blank inside ~ eco-friendly card

wish you were here greeting card ~ wish you lived next door ~ just because card ~ miss you card ~ pen pal ~ blank inside ~ eco-friendly card

$6.00

you are magic greeting card ~ you inspire me ~ anniversary card ~ card for best friend ~ cute love card ~ alternative valentine's day card

you are magic greeting card ~ you inspire me ~ anniversary card ~ card for best friend ~ cute love card ~ alternative valentine's day card

$6.00

funny holiday greeting card ~ snarky family christmas card ~ holidays are stressful ~ everything is fine ~ happy holidays ~ what a year

funny holiday greeting card ~ snarky family christmas card ~ holidays are stressful ~ everything is fine ~ happy holidays ~ what a year

$6.00

funny holiday greeting card ~ holiday movie trailer voice ~ snarky christmas card ~ christmas season card ~ tis the season ~ blank inside

funny holiday greeting card ~ holiday movie trailer voice ~ snarky christmas card ~ christmas season card ~ tis the season ~ blank inside

$6.00

funny happy new year greeting card ~ what a year ~ 2025 2026 new year ~ snarky holiday card ~ eco-friendly holiday season card

funny happy new year greeting card ~ what a year ~ 2025 2026 new year ~ snarky holiday card ~ eco-friendly holiday season card

$6.00

simple non-denominational holiday card ~ merry and bright ~ cozy winter season card ~ cottagecore winter holiday card ~ seasons greetings

simple non-denominational holiday card ~ merry and bright ~ cozy winter season card ~ cottagecore winter holiday card ~ seasons greetings

$6.00

literary quote bookmark ~ soft matte feel ~ pretty misty forest path aesthetic ~ TBR reading goals ~ bookworm gift ~ librarian gift

literary quote bookmark ~ soft matte feel ~ pretty misty forest path aesthetic ~ TBR reading goals ~ bookworm gift ~ librarian gift

$5.00

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Mar 24, 2025
Sammy and Mindy

Contact shop owner

Sammy and Mindy

Contact shop owner

Reviews

5.0 (361)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

About FreethinkerPaperCo

eco-friendly paper goods, tote bags, & button pins

Sales 1,320
On Etsy since 2024

eco-friendly paper goods, tote bags, & button pins

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

quirky ✨ sentimental ✨ thought-provoking ✨ eco-friendly paper goods & accessories

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Sammy

    Owner, Designer, Marketer

    co-creator, designs products, runs social media, loves noodles, puzzle obsessed, old soul, freethinker, daughter ♡

  • shop-member-photo
    Mindy

    Owner, Customer Service, Shipper

    co-creator, packs & ships orders, holds down the fort, also loves noodles, makes the best lavender lemonade, young at heart, freethinker, mom ♡

Production partners

  • Busy Beaver Button Co.

    Chicago, IL

    Busy Beaver Button Co. locally manufactures the button pins that we design.

  • Smartpress

    Chanhassen, MN

    Smartpress prints our greeting cards and paper bookmarks.

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Wholesale availability

Our greeting cards, bookmarks, and button pins are available for wholesale! Find us on Faire at https://faire.com/direct/freethinkerpaperco

Are your products in any brick-and-mortar shops?

We’re working on it! Check back for a list of stockists.

Are your shipping materials low-waste?

Yes! We’re committed to packing our orders with eco-friendly materials. The relatively small amount of tape we use for our labels is classic Scotch, but besides that, everything is biodegradable and plastic-free. :)

How long is your processing time?

Once you place an order with us, we’ll get it shipped out to you in 1-2 business days.

Why don’t you ship internationally?

We do ship to Canada, but that's as far as we go. We believe, in the same spirit that Greta Thunberg stopped traveling by plane, that it’s most sustainable for our shop to only operate domestically. This is not an America-first ideology, but simply an attempt to lower our carbon footprint as a company and help our customers achieve the same small(er) footprint.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy