Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

MagicCityIron

United States

86
 Sales

1 year
on Etsy

86
 sales

1 year
on Etsy

Following Follow

86
 Sales

1 year
on Etsy

86
 sales

1 year
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

Magic City Iron Logo Vinyl Sticker

$4.50

All items

Lodge No. 5, Three-Notch, Cast Iron Skillet

Lodge No. 5, Three-Notch, Cast Iron Skillet

$39.00

FREE shipping

Favorite Piqua Ware No. 3 Smiley Logo Cast Iron Skillet

$55.00

FREE shipping

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 8 “GA” Red Mountain/Early Century Cast Iron Skillet

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 8 “GA” Red Mountain/Early Century Cast Iron Skillet

$55.00

FREE shipping

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 7 "T" Red Mountain Series Cast Iron Skillet

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 7 "T" Red Mountain Series Cast Iron Skillet

$69.00

FREE shipping

T. Eaton Co. No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet

T. Eaton Co. No. 8 Cast Iron Skillet

$79.00

FREE shipping

Magic City Iron Logo Vinyl Sticker

$4.50

Lodge Blacklock No. 7 Sad Iron

Lodge Blacklock No. 7 Sad Iron

$85.00

FREE shipping

Nashville, TN Cast Iron Advertising Skillet - Phillips & Buttorff

Nashville, TN Cast Iron Advertising Skillet - Phillips & Buttorff

$69.00

FREE shipping

Griswold Deep Patty Bowl Pattern 72

Griswold Deep Patty Bowl Pattern 72

$90.00

FREE shipping

Lodge No. 8 Single-Notch Cast Iron Skillet

Lodge No. 8 Single-Notch Cast Iron Skillet

$90.00

FREE shipping

Wagner Ware Sidney -O- Krusty Korn Kobs Junior Corn Stick Pan

Wagner Ware Sidney -O- Krusty Korn Kobs Junior Corn Stick Pan

$60.00

FREE shipping

Unknown Gate Marked Round Cast Iron Griddle Circa 1800's

Unknown Gate Marked Round Cast Iron Griddle Circa 1800's

$75.00

FREE shipping

Gate-Marked Glue/Smelting Pot, No. 1 (1850s-1900)

Gate-Marked Glue/Smelting Pot, No. 1 (1850s-1900)

$70.00

FREE shipping

Lodge No. 5, Three-Notch, Hand Scribed, Cast Iron Skillet

Lodge No. 5, Three-Notch, Hand Scribed, Cast Iron Skillet

$45.00

FREE shipping

Lodge No. 3, Three-Notch Hand Scribed Cast Iron Skillet

Lodge No. 3, Three-Notch Hand Scribed Cast Iron Skillet

$39.00

FREE shipping

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 3 "S Series" Cast Iron Skillet

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 3 "S Series" Cast Iron Skillet

$69.00

FREE shipping

Unmarked Fancy Handle No. 7 Gate Mark

Unmarked Fancy Handle No. 7 Gate Mark

$69.00

FREE shipping

Lodge No. 8, Three-Notch Cast Iron Skillet

Lodge No. 8, Three-Notch Cast Iron Skillet

$60.00

FREE shipping

Lodge Corn Stick Pan

Lodge Corn Stick Pan

$30.00

FREE shipping

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 7S Corn Stick Pan

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 7S Corn Stick Pan

$30.00

FREE shipping

A&J Cox Philadelphia No. 7/8 Cast Iron Waffle Iron - PINHOLE

A&J Cox Philadelphia No. 7/8 Cast Iron Waffle Iron - PINHOLE

$170.00

FREE shipping

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 3A Red Mountain Series Cast Iron Skillet

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 3A Red Mountain Series Cast Iron Skillet

$75.00

FREE shipping

The Keeley Stove Co. Advertising Skillet

The Keeley Stove Co. Advertising Skillet

$55.00

FREE shipping

Chicago Hardware Foundry No. 5 Cast Iron Skillet Diamond Logo

$40.00

FREE shipping

Griswold No. 3 Large-Block Logo Nickel Plated Cast Iron Skillet

$85.00

FREE shipping

Griswold Corn Stick Leftover Batter Pan Pattern No. 263

Griswold Corn Stick Leftover Batter Pan Pattern No. 263

$95.00

FREE shipping

Lodge Advertising Skillet/Ashtray Mold Number 8

Lodge Advertising Skillet/Ashtray Mold Number 8

$25.00

FREE shipping

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on May 16, 2025

Magic

Contact shop owner

Magic

Reviews

4.9 (41)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Loading

Ronda on Apr 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Arrived safely, so hqppy with it, thank you!

Magic responded on Apr 1, 2026

We are thankful for your business and hope you enjoy this BSR piece!!

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 5 "C" Red Mountain/Early Century Skillet

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 5 "C" Red Mountain/Early Century Skillet
Mike on Mar 26, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great frying pan love it

Magic responded on Mar 26, 2026

Thank you!

Wagner Ware Sidney -O- Square Cast Iron Skillet

Wagner Ware Sidney -O- Square Cast Iron Skillet
Steve on Mar 5, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Excellent Seller would highly recommend them!

Magic responded on Mar 5, 2026

Thanks, Steve. We appreciate your business!

Wagner Ware Pie Logo Nickel Plated Cast Iron Skillet Pattern 1053A

Wagner Ware Pie Logo Nickel Plated Cast Iron Skillet Pattern 1053A
Deborah on Mar 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful #7 Tite top Dutch oven. Packed very well and shipped quickly. Great restoration!! Will definitely purchase from seller again. +++

Magic responded on Mar 3, 2026

Thank you! Looks like you have a great collection already. We appreciate your business!

Griswold No. 7 Tite-Top Dutch Oven

Griswold No. 7 Tite-Top Dutch Oven
Christopher on Feb 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Thanks for the top shelf service 👍

RECAST National No. 7 Cast Iron Skillet with Gate Mark

RECAST National No. 7 Cast Iron Skillet with Gate Mark
Joe on Feb 15, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Packed very well ,,very nice exactly what i expected ,,would definitely recommend this vendor

Magic responded on Feb 15, 2026

We greatly appreciate your business and feedback!

Wapak No. 8 Block Logo Cast Iron Skillet Pre-1910

Wapak No. 8 Block Logo Cast Iron Skillet Pre-1910
Christopher on Feb 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Nice piece. Quick delivery 👍

Magic responded on Feb 6, 2026

thanks! we appreciate your business!

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 8 Red Mountain Cast Iron Skillet Pattern "H"

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 8 Red Mountain Cast Iron Skillet Pattern "H"
Hanne on Jan 15, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Arrived quickly and was packaged excellently. So excited for this beautiful skillet. Also included came a complementary seasoning! Very thoughtful.

Magic responded on Jan 15, 2026

Appreciate the thoughtful review! Glad this one has gone to a good home. Hope it serves you for decades to come.

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 5 “. X .” Red Mountain/Early Century Skillet

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 5 “. X .” Red Mountain/Early Century Skillet
Palmer on Jan 12, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

One of the best experiences I've had with online purchases. Great to deal with, hope to be able to purchase more. You won't be disappointed when you buy an item from them. 😊😊

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 8 Red Mountain Cast Iron Skillet "8..XD" Wobble

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 8 Red Mountain Cast Iron Skillet "8..XD" Wobble
Tom on Jan 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great packaging with extras. Quick shipping.

Magic responded on Jan 6, 2026

Thank you! Glad it arrived quickly and safely.

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 7 "F" Red Mountain/Early Century Skillet

Birmingham Stove and Range No. 7 "F" Red Mountain/Early Century Skillet

About MagicCityIron

Restoring some of the finest cast iron cookware!

Sales 86

On Etsy since 2025

Restoring some of the finest cast iron cookware!

Production partners

Print Shop

Roseville, CA

This partner prints and die cuts stickers for me.

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Kitchen & Dining

Buy Custom Slap Koozie Online Buy Ironstone Empress Online Antique Sterling Silver Cream And Sugar Set for Sale Texas Ware 111 - US Buy Leather Table Decor Online Shop Sakura Plates 3d Printed Egg Cup - US Shop Gunther Beer Tea Pot Cover for Sale Hearts And Star Pan - US

Patches & Pins

Martin Guitar Patch for Sale

Bedding

Shop Provence Bedding

Outdoor & Garden

Buy Italian Donkey Pot Online

Costume Accessories

Buy Latex Helmet Online

Home Decor

Bulldog Wall Hook - US

Paper

Buy Outboard Decal Online

Handbags

Buy Vintage Accordion Bag Online

Lighting

Buy Vintage Table Lamps Peach Online