Musicalkeepsakes

64.7k
 Sales

5.0 (8.9k)

10 years
on Etsy

5.0 (8.9k)

64.7k
 sales

10 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

64.7k
 Sales

5.0 (8.9k)

10 years
on Etsy

5.0 (8.9k)

64.7k
 sales

10 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

64682 Sales

3270 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jan 6, 2026

Hello Musical Theatre Enthusiasts!

Welcome to Musical Keepsakes by Sparkling Cider Productions. I create thoughtful keepsakes and gifts for musical and play productions. If you have a production coming up our items make wonderful cast gifts!

I also designed pop-up theatre boutiques for theatre groups to support fundraising efforts for local theatre. Born out of the boutiques came this shop where we create enduring keepsakes for performers and fans of Musical Theatre.

Follow us @sparklingciderproductions on Facebook and Instagram for all our latest creations!

We enjoy your posts on Instagram and if you'd like us to follow you give us a shoutout!
Warmly,
Vicki

Contact shop owner

Vicki

Reviews

5.0 (8920)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Gina on Sep 17, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Button looks exactly like the photo! Looking forward to giving it as a break a leg for the Seussical the Musical cast member!

Seussical-inspired JoJo Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Seussical-inspired JoJo Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre
Tami on Aug 26, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

My daughter, who played a Sweep, loved it!

Step in Time, Chimney Sweep, Mary Poppins Musical Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre

Step in Time, Chimney Sweep, Mary Poppins Musical Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre
Johna on Jul 9, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

super cute. item is as described, very pleased with it and my daughter loves it. perfect gift for being am Addams Anscestor in the summer musical. item would have arrived in time for when I needed it by, but for some reason it was shipped to the local post office then back out of state twice making it arrive late. otherwise perfect!

Addams Family Musical Inspired It's Family First and Family Last Bottle cap Key Clip, Key Chain, Goth, Dark, horror, Musical Theatre

Addams Family Musical Inspired It's Family First and Family Last Bottle cap Key Clip, Key Chain, Goth, Dark, horror, Musical Theatre
N on May 12, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I love these buttons!!!! I was so excited to find them for my son’s school play. It was a last-minute order, but the seller was able to ship them to me so that I received them on time.

Seussical-inspired JoJo Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Seussical-inspired JoJo Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre
Megan on Apr 18, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Came quickly and as pictured!

Matchmaker Matchmaker Make Me A Match! Fiddler on the Roof Musical Inspired Pin, Pinback , Daughters, Musical Theatre

Matchmaker Matchmaker Make Me A Match! Fiddler on the Roof Musical Inspired Pin, Pinback , Daughters, Musical Theatre
T on Apr 8, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great, quality item! Very quick shipping! I would definitely purchase from this seller again!

Step in Time, Chimney Sweep, Mary Poppins Musical Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre

Step in Time, Chimney Sweep, Mary Poppins Musical Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre
Kevin on Mar 27, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Easy to order, arrived on time, zero complaints. This is going to be a great gift for my child as the perform Adams Family for school.

Addams Family Musical Inspired It's Family First and Family Last Bottle cap Key Clip, Key Chain, Goth, Dark, horror, Musical Theatre

Addams Family Musical Inspired It's Family First and Family Last Bottle cap Key Clip, Key Chain, Goth, Dark, horror, Musical Theatre
Etsy buyer on Sep 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

The seller was great to work with and managed to work with my tight time frame. I really appreciated her going the extra mile to make these great!

Custom Pin Order for Mercedes - Due Sept 25th

Custom Pin Order for Mercedes - Due Sept 25th
Mary on Sep 23, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

My daughter will love it!

LITTLE WOMEN Musical Some Things Are Meant To Be inspired Pinback, Button, Badge, Pin, Magnet, Musical Theatre

LITTLE WOMEN Musical Some Things Are Meant To Be inspired Pinback, Button, Badge, Pin, Magnet, Musical Theatre
Dustyn on Sep 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

High quality and fast shipping! Amazing!

SHREK Musical Inspired Duloc Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Fairytale Characters, Musical Theatre

SHREK Musical Inspired Duloc Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Fairytale Characters, Musical Theatre

About Musicalkeepsakes

Musical Theatre Inspired Keepsakes and Gifts

Sales 64,682

On Etsy since 2016

Musical Theatre Inspired Keepsakes and Gifts

Instagram

Facebook

Shop members

Vicki Fahrenholz

Owner

My love of the arts, graphic design and crafting/creating led me to create a business to reach out to musical theatre enthusiasts as my son was involved throughout his childhood and into college as a performer.

Shop policies

Last updated on Nov 14, 2018

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Keychains & Lanyards

Buy Wal Mart Badge Online

Furniture

Adult Bunk Beds for Sale

Kitchen & Dining

Shop Philip Russel Buy Patron Tequila Glass Online

Prints

Atlas Shrug Poster - US Pastor Appreciation Sign - US

Necklaces

Buy Girls Photo Necklace Online Shop Maltese Cross Seal

Patterns & How To

Job Site worker Clipart - Patterns & How To

Canvas & Surfaces

Buy Monster Inc Logo Online

Personal Care

Shop Patent Pink Bondage

Mens Clothing

Asian shirt for men - Men's Clothing

Rings

Square Moissanite for Sale

Brooches Pins & Clips

Shop Dnd Jibbitz

Collectibles

Buy White Kissing Angels Online

Womens Clothing

Buy Cut Loose Clothing Online

Gender Neutral Adult Clothing

Buy Teal Tie Dye Hoodie Online

Watches

Buy Pocket Watch Compass Online

Musicalkeepsakes

Featured items

Shrek the Musical Inspired Sticker, Story of My Life Decal, Laptop,Water Bottle Decoration, Musical Theatre

Finding Nemo the Musical Jr.& Kids Fish Are Friends Not Food Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Musical Theatre

Anastasia the Musical Land of Yesterday Inspired Pin, Badge, Magnet, Button, Musical Theatre

Descendants the Musical Rotten To The Core Inspired Pin, Badge, Magnet, Button, Musical Theatre

All items

SHREK Musical Inspired Pin, Pinback, Princess FIONA, Fiercely Fiona, Musical Theatre

Beauty and The Beast Inspired Be Our Guest Ensemble Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre

HUNCHBACK of Notre Dame Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Badge, Magnet Musical Theatre

Little Shop of Horrors Musical Seymour Inspired Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Pinback

Little Shop of Horrors Musical Mushnik and Son Inspired Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Pinback

Little Shop of Horrors Musical Inspired Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Pinback

Little Shop of Horrors Musical Audrey Inspired Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Pinback

Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Children of Israel

Step in Time, Chimney Sweep, Mary Poppins Musical Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre

Jungle Book Kids Musical Bare Necessities Inspired Pin, Magnet, Badge, Pinback, Musical Theatre

Little Mermaid the Musical Inspired Character Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Musical Theatre

FROZEN Musical Inspired Elsa Adult, Middle and Young, Pinback, Button, Badge, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Finding Nemo the Musical Jr.& Kids Go With The Flow Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Musical Theatre

Finding Nemo the Musical Jr.& Kids Just Keep Swimming Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Musical Theatre

Sound of Music Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

FROZEN The Musical A Little Bit Of You Elsa and Anna Pinback, Button, Badge, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Jungle Book Kids Musical Monkey Song, Ooh Ooh Ooh I Want To Be Like You Inspired Pin, Magnet, Badge, Pinback, Musical Theatre

Sound of Music Kurt Von Trapp Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Sound of Music The Lonely Goatherd Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

WIZARD OF OZ Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre

FROZEN The Musical Inspired Inspired Pinback, Button, Badge, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Finding Nemo the Musical Jr.& Kids Inspired Pin, Magnet, Button, Badge, Musical Theatre

Sound of Music My Favorite Things Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

FROZEN The Musical Inspired Do You Want To Build A Snowman?, Anna, Elsa, Pinback, Button, Badge, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Sound of Music Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Sound of Music So Long Farewell Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Sound of Music Do-Re-Mi Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

BEAUTY & THE BEAST Inspired Key Chain, Belle, Beast, Musical Theatre

WIZARD OF OZ Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Wizard, Musical Theatre

Annie the Musical, Kate Orphan Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre

Sound of Music Edelweiss Inspired Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Narnia Pin,"At Last it's Christmas!", Pinback, Button, Musical Theatre Keepsake

Elf Jr. The Musical Inspired Pinback, There Is A Santa Claus, Button, Badge, Magnet, Musical Theatre

The Greatest Showman the Musical Inspired The Other Side Pinback, Button, Badge, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Seussical-inspired JoJo Pin, Pinback, Button, Magnet, Musical Theatre

Beauty and The Beast "BE Our Guest" Inspired Necklace, Pendant w/ Fork & Spoon, Mrs. Potts, BELLE, Musical Theatre Jewelry

Announcement

Reviews

About Musicalkeepsakes

Shop members

Vicki Fahrenholz

Shop policies

Shipping

Customs and import taxes

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations