TheCostumeCafe

Canton, Illinois

9.4k
 Sales

4.8 (1.7k)

18 years
on Etsy

4.8 (1.7k)

9.4k
 sales

18 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

9.4k
 Sales

4.8 (1.7k)

18 years
on Etsy

4.8 (1.7k)

9.4k
 sales

18 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

9365 Sales

8929 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

All items

Baby Graduation Mortar Board Headband, Photo Prop Costume

Sale Price $26.25

Original Price $35.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Graduation Cap for Babies, Kids, Toddlers

Sale Price $26.25

Original Price $35.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Graduation Cap for Babies, Kids, Toddlers

Sale Price $26.25

Original Price $35.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Apple Pie Costume- Baby to Adult Sizes

Sale Price $66.00

Original Price $110.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Boysenberry Pie Headband- Knotts Berry Farm Festival Costume Accessory

Sale Price $30.00

Original Price $40.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Boysenberry Jam Headband, Knotts Berry Farm Inspired Costume Accessory

Sale Price $30.00

Original Price $40.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Boysenberry Pie Headband, Knotts Berry Farm Festival Floral Accessory

Sale Price $30.00

Original Price $40.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Kids French Fries Halloween Costume

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Hamantaschen Purim Headband Costume

Sale Price $18.75

Original Price $25.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Cookie Costume | Chocolate Sandwich, Halloween Outfit

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Kids Avocado Costume for Halloween Dress Up

Sale Price $42.00

Original Price $70.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Hamantaschen Costume for Baby or Kids

Sale Price $33.00

Original Price $55.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Donut Costume for Babies | Halloween Costume

Sale Price $60.00

Original Price $100.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Kids Chocolate Sandwich Cookie Costume | Purim, Halloween Dress Up

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Apple Costume | Handmade Halloween Outfit

Sale Price $42.00

Original Price $70.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Hamantaschen Headband Bopper for Kids and Adults

Sale Price $26.25

Original Price $35.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Juicy Orange Costume | Kids Halloween, Purim Outfit

Sale Price $42.00

Original Price $70.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Kids Peach Costume for Halloween, Purim, Dress Up

Sale Price $42.00

Original Price $70.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Cherry Costume with Hat: Halloween, Purim Dress-Up

Sale Price $42.00

Original Price $70.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Kids Blueberry Costume for Child : Toddler Halloween Costume

Sale Price $42.00

Original Price $70.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Black and White Cookie Costume for Kids, Purim Costume

Sale Price $27.00

Original Price $45.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Handmade Boysenberry Pie Costume | Eco Felt, Sensory-Friendly, Costume for Kids

Sale Price $82.50

Original Price $110.00 (25% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Pie Costume: Handmade Eco Felt Thanksgiving Outfit

Sale Price $60.00

Original Price $100.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Twin Baby Halloween Costumes: Milk and Cookie Set

Sale Price $90.00

Original Price $150.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Olive Costume with Hat, Halloween Dress-Up

Sale Price $42.00

Original Price $70.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Strawberry Costume with Headband, Toddler Halloween Dress Up

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Handmade Mushroom Costume with Fleece Hat | Waldorf Dress Up

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Twin Halloween Costumes: Peas and Carrots - Sibling Costume Dress Up

Sale Price $84.00

Original Price $140.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Nutella Jar Costume, Sensory Friendly Felt Food Outfit

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Popcorn Costume | Sensory Friendly Felt Outfit with Fleece Hat

Sale Price $60.00

Original Price $100.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Blueberry Costume with Hat, Handmade Halloween Dress-Up

Sale Price $42.00

Original Price $70.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Sushi Costume Halloween Infant Costume Shrimp Sushi Nigiri Sushi Roll with Ginger and Wasabi Group Costume for Family Costume Twin

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Sushi and Soy Sauce Costume Halloween Toddler Costumes Twin Halloween Family Costumes For Groups Shrimp Sushi Costume Wasabi and Ginger

Sale Price $108.00

Original Price $180.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby Cookie Costume with Milk Carton Hat

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Cicada Costume Baby Bug Costume For Halloween Dress Up For Kids Insect Costume Photo Prop For Infant Purim Infant Costume For Children

Sale Price $54.00

Original Price $90.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Baby French Fry and Ketchup Costumes for Halloween Twin Groups

Sale Price $111.00

Original Price $185.00 (40% off)

FREE shipping

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Feb 1, 2024

Contact shop owner

Sara Carter

Reviews

4.8 (1729)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

gail on May 4, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

super cute rainbow costume made beautifully. Excellent costumer service. Highly recommend this vendor on Etsy!

Sara responded on May 4, 2026

Thanks!

Adult Rainbow Costume with Sun Hat – Sensory Friendly Eco Felt Dress

Adult Rainbow Costume with Sun Hat – Sensory Friendly Eco Felt Dress
Ashley on Apr 17, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Exactly what we needed! I wasn’t sure on size but it was roomy and forgiving.

Toddler Sugar Cookie Costume with Milk Hat – Rainbow Sprinkles, Halloween Fancy Dress

Toddler Sugar Cookie Costume with Milk Hat – Rainbow Sprinkles, Halloween Fancy Dress
Kari on Apr 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Absolutely adorable! Can't wait to wear this at Knott's Berry Farm!

Boysenberry Festival Headband, Purple Berry Hair Accessory Knotts Inspired

Boysenberry Festival Headband, Purple Berry Hair Accessory Knotts Inspired
Jeffrey on Mar 29, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great costume for the holiday

Hamantaschen Cookie Costume, Purim Outfit for Familes

Hamantaschen Cookie Costume, Purim Outfit for Familes
Janet on Mar 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is adorable. Looking forward to wowing Seder attendees !

Matzo Headband - Passover Jewish Accessory, Felt Food

Matzo Headband - Passover Jewish Accessory, Felt Food
Crystal on Mar 8, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Very cute! It’s perfect for Easter

Chocolate Bunny Easter Headband, Candy & Eggs, Fun Easter Hair Accessory

Chocolate Bunny Easter Headband, Candy & Eggs, Fun Easter Hair Accessory
susan on Mar 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Arrived just in time for my child’s school celebration of Purim! Already got compliments on the costume

Hamantaschen Costume: Felt Purim Costume, Jewish Food Fancy Dress

Hamantaschen Costume: Felt Purim Costume, Jewish Food Fancy Dress
Leah on Mar 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Seller was super quick at responding and was super nice and accommodating. I needed something right away and she customized it for me the next day everything came out so cute. I highly recommend.

Special Order for Leah...

Special Order for Leah...
Kayla on Feb 25, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This seller was so helpful and the item came and was so cute and perfect!

Hamantaschen Costume: Felt Purim Costume, Jewish Food Fancy Dress

Hamantaschen Costume: Felt Purim Costume, Jewish Food Fancy Dress
Etsy buyer on Jan 29, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Terrific! Unusual, fun, and stylish

Matzo Headband Passover Headband Jewish Foods Jewish Accessory Felt Food Passover Hair Matza Matzah Matzoh Bread for Passover Dress Up

Matzo Headband Passover Headband Jewish Foods Jewish Accessory Felt Food Passover Hair Matza Matzah Matzoh Bread for Passover Dress Up

About TheCostumeCafe

Costumes that look good enough to eat...

Sales 9,365

On Etsy since 2008

Costumes that look good enough to eat...

Baking Up Some Delicious Pies!
Cookies, Milk, and Deviled Eggs!
My muse. (And an amazing artist in her own right!) Amelia.
Food Network Magazine Feature! October 2017
Cover of Food Network Magazine- October 2017 The Costume Cafe was featured inside!

Serving Up Costumes That Look Good Enough To Eat!

Instagram

shop-website

Shop members

Sara Carter

Owner, Designer, Creator

After 20 years in Texas, I moved back to the Midwest with my 13 year old spirited, autistic daughter, Amelia, and our 9 year old guard dog, Waffles. I design and create everything in my shop. Quality and attention to detail are very important to me.

Production partners

A print shop

United States

A production partner.
A print shop

United States

A production partner.

Shop policies

Last updated on Jun 26, 2024

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 24 hours of purchase

Privacy policy

Seller details

View shop registration details