PreppyProdigy

Austin, Texas

31.4k
 Sales

4.9 (4.9k)

13 years
on Etsy

4.9 (4.9k)

31.4k
 sales

13 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

31.4k
 Sales

4.9 (4.9k)

13 years
on Etsy

4.9 (4.9k)

31.4k
 sales

13 years
on Etsy

Request Custom Order

Contact shop owner

31432 Sales

6849 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Feb 9, 2026

Contact shop owner

Hellen Moncada

Reviews

4.9 (4897)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Etsy buyer on Mar 30, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great quality! Not blurry at all!

Personalized From the Kitchen of Labels, From the Kitchen of Stickers, Cookie Label Stickers, Homemade kitchen Label Stickers, Rolling Pin

Personalized From the Kitchen of Labels, From the Kitchen of Stickers, Cookie Label Stickers, Homemade kitchen Label Stickers, Rolling Pin
Tara on Sep 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Quality was great, fast shipping. Thanks!

Play Date Calling Cards, Kids Calling Cards, Boys, Girls, Kids, Children, End of School, Mommy Calling Cards, Let's Play, Set of 20

Play Date Calling Cards, Kids Calling Cards, Boys, Girls, Kids, Children, End of School, Mommy Calling Cards, Let's Play, Set of 20
Sarah on Sep 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Matches the description and looks simply cute. It’s perfect🤍

Play Date Calling Cards, Kids Calling Cards, Boys, Girls, Kids, Children, End of School Year Cards, Mommy Calling Cards, Let's Play

Play Date Calling Cards, Kids Calling Cards, Boys, Girls, Kids, Children, End of School Year Cards, Mommy Calling Cards, Let's Play
Etsy buyer on Sep 18, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great quality product! Thank you!

Personalized From the Kitchen of Labels, From the Kitchen of Stickers, Custom Handmade Labels, Homemade Label Stickers, Olive Leaf

Personalized From the Kitchen of Labels, From the Kitchen of Stickers, Custom Handmade Labels, Homemade Label Stickers, Olive Leaf
Etsy buyer on Sep 16, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Exactly as described. Thank you.

Personalized From the Kitchen of Labels, From the Kitchen of Stickers, Custom Handmade Labels, Homemade Label Stickers, Olive Leaf

Personalized From the Kitchen of Labels, From the Kitchen of Stickers, Custom Handmade Labels, Homemade Label Stickers, Olive Leaf
Erika on Sep 9, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These cards were wonderful quality! I was very pleased. Will definitely purchase from this seller again.

Personalized Airplane Stationery Set, Kids Thank You Notes

Personalized Airplane Stationery Set, Kids Thank You Notes
Erika on Sep 9, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I cannot say enough wonderful things about how these note cards. The card stock is great quality and the thickness is beautiful. They feel elevated and perfect. Will order again from the seller.

Personalized Airplane Stationery Set, Kids Thank You Notes

Personalized Airplane Stationery Set, Kids Thank You Notes
Madisen on Aug 26, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Amazing gift for a friend's birthday! Came exactly as ordered.

Printed Personalized Boxed Set of Recipe Cards, Recipe Kitchen Gift Idea, Custom Recipe Cards, Kitchen Decor, Set of 16, 4"x5.5, Pear

Printed Personalized Boxed Set of Recipe Cards, Recipe Kitchen Gift Idea, Custom Recipe Cards, Kitchen Decor, Set of 16, 4"x5.5, Pear
Bethany on Aug 26, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Love this! Swift delivery, great quality, and adorable. Will order again from this seller!

Personalized Garden Gift Tags, Handmade Label Tags

Personalized Garden Gift Tags, Handmade Label Tags
Etsy buyer on Aug 23, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Lovely mutely colored personalized tags..thank you

Rolling Pin Gift Tags, Handmade From the Kitchen Of, Homemade Item Tags

Rolling Pin Gift Tags, Handmade From the Kitchen Of, Homemade Item Tags

About PreppyProdigy

Everything you need to express your best self.

Sales 31,432

On Etsy since 2013

Everything you need to express your best self.

We start with 130lb. premium white card-stock sourced from world-class 140 year old mill in Wisconsin, USA
Each item is meticulously designed using the highest quality materials and handmade in our CA studio.
For every item we sell, we donate a spiral notebook or a set of pencils to a child in foster care.
We're inspired by the preppy aesthetic. Not only for it's academic roots, but for the humor it adds to our designs.
We've worked hard to develop a process that meets the unique needs of our customer while being socially responsible

About Us

From our studio to your home, our custom stationery is made-to-order in Austin, Texas. We take a timeless approach to design, drawing inspiration from the heritage of The American University. Everything we do is built on our dedication to quality craftsmanship, whether it’s a personalized note from our Grammar School collection or a pencil sourced from one of the few remaining pencil factories in America, each is thoughtfully designed and made to last. We design, print and finish each order by hand because we know small details make all the difference.

Our mission is to improve the School Supply Industry one inspirational product at a time, highlight other American manufacturers and create a better school year for ALL students.

Facebook

shop-website

Instagram

Shop members

Hellen Moncada

Owner, Proprietor

I'm Hellen, a Miami native with a background in marketing with a deep love for creativity and design. I am brimming with enthusiasm for all things pretty!

Production partners

Waste Not Paper

United States

Waste Not Paper-stationery

Shop policies

Last updated on December 17, 2025

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Seller details

View shop registration details

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Paper

Buy Arsenal Labels Online Marine Helmet I Eat Crayons Vinyl Sticker by RegalDecals Pediatric Cardiovascular Notes for Sale Dog Walking Business Cards - Paper, Stationery & Cards Buy Popsicle Note Cards Online Shop Self Help Worksheets House Manual Google Drive Template Shop Sephiroth Decal Thank You Languages for Sale Shop Hair Extension Packaging Military Vinyl Decal Sticker - Semper Fi - Paper, Stationery & Cards Shop Smarties Svg Shop Pibble Dog Meme Granddaughter High School Graduation for Sale

Bracelets

Shop Gospel Bracelet

Party Supplies

Arched Winnie the Pooh Banner - Party Supplies

Kitchen & Dining

Ammi kallu - Kitchen & Dining

Fabric & Notions

Italian Denim Fabric for Sale

PreppyProdigy

Featured items

Personalized Recipe Card Set, Olive Leaf Design, Kitchen Gift

Personalized From the Kitchen of Labels, From the Kitchen of Stickers, Cookie Label Stickers, Homemade kitchen Label Stickers, Rolling Pin

Personalized Gift Enclosure Cards - Preppy Heart Stationery Set

Personalized Stationery / Personalized Stationery / Personalized Stationery Set / Inspired by "The Summer I Turned Pretty"

All items

Custom Listing for Heather Richardson

Custom Bookplate Listing for Patty

Personalized Kitchen Labels, Bread Stickers, Homemade Baking Stickers

Custom Order for Archana Kasi

Personalized Stationery Set: Dog Love Collection

Personalized Kids Valentine Cards for school, Classroom Valentine's Day Favor Cards, Space Theme Card, Rocketship Valentines with envelopes

Personalized Hanukkah Menorah Gift Tags, Party Favors

Personalized Stationery / Personalized Stationery / Personalized Stationery Set / Inspired by "The Summer I Turned Pretty"

Monogrammed Gift Tags - Red Cherry Personalized Enclosure Cards

Personalized Tennis Gift Tags - Monogrammed Enclosure Cards

Kids Birthday Party Stickers, Personalized birthday favor stickers, Birthday Party Stickers, for Kids, for boys, for girls, Scallop Border

Personalized Gift Enclosure Cards: Heartfelt Note Cards

Personalized Thank you Notes Set / Personalized Thank You Cards / Thank You Note Card Set / Thank You Gift for her / Good Hearted Thank You

Personalized Monogrammed Gift Tags - Personalized Gift Tags - Custom Tags - Personalized Gift - Favor Tags - For Girls - Good Hearted

Personalized Note Card Set, Custom Stationery Gift, A2 Size

Monogrammed Gift Tags - Pink Preppy Hearts Personalized Tags

Personalized Gift Enclosure Cards - Preppy Heart Stationery Set

Personalized Note Card Set, Handmade Stationery, Preppy Heart Design

Personalized Gift Enclosure Cards / Personalized Gift / Enclosure Cards for wedding / Heart / Gift Enclosures Thank You Cards / Red Hearts

Monogram Stickers, Personalized birthday favor stickers, Wedding Party Stickers, Heart Stickers, Everyday Stickers, Favor Label, Red Hearts

Personalized Gift Tags - Polka Dot -Everyday- Personalized Gift Tags - Custom Tags - Favor Cards - Favor Tags - Thank You Tags - Red Hearts

Personalized Stationery Note Card Set, Red Hearts Design

Personalized Gift Tag - Polka Dot -Everyday- Personalized Gift Tags - Custom Tag - Favor Cards - Favor Tags - Thank You Tags - Double Hearts

Personalized Stationery Note Card, Handmade Everyday Note Card Gift Set, Everyday Stationery Set for her, Preppy Note Cards, Double Hearts

Monogram Stickers, Personalized birthday favor sticker, Wedding Party Sticker, Heart Stickers, Everyday Stickers, Favor Label, Double Hearts

Personalized Gift Enclosure Cards / Personalized Gift / Enclosure Cards for wedding / Heart / Gift Enclosures Thank You Card / Double Hearts

Personalized Stationery Note Card Set, Handmade Everyday Note Card Gift Set, Everyday Stationery Set for her, Preppy Note Cards, double love

Monogram Stickers, Personalized birthday favor stickers, Wedding Party Stickers, Heart Stickers, Everyday Stickers, Favor Label, Double Love

Personalized Gift Enclosure Cards / Personalized Gift / Enclosure Cards for wedding / Heart / Gift Enclosures Thank You Cards / Double Love

Personalized Gift Tags - Heart -Everyday- Personalized Gift Tags - Custom Tags - Enclosure Cards - Favor Tags - Thank You Tags - Double Love

Personalized Pink Heart Bookplate Stickers, Kids Book Labels, Set of 16

Personalized Gift Enclosure Cards, Floating Hearts, Set of 10

Monogrammed Gift Tags - Personalized Gift Tags - Custom Tags - Enclosure Cards - Favor Tags - For Girls - For Boys- Kids, Floating Hearts

Personalized Thank You Note Card Set, Floating Hearts, Handmade Stationery

Monogrammed Gift Tags - Personalized Gift Tags - Custom Tags - Enclosure Cards - Favor Tags - For Girls - For Boys- Kids, Rainbow Block

Kids Birthday Party Stickers, Personalized birthday favor stickers, Birthday Party Stickers, for Kids, for boys, for girls, Rainbow Block

Announcement

Reviews

About PreppyProdigy

Shop members

Hellen Moncada

Production partners

Shop policies

Returns & exchanges

Seller details