PreppyStepps

New York, United States

592
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (142)
13 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (142)
592
sales
13 years
on Etsy
592
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (142)
13 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (142)
592
sales
13 years
on Etsy
Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
592 Sales
374 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All items

May include: A wooden comb and brush set, decorated with pink and white floral patterns and the name "Maeve". A pink satin ribbon ties the brush. The comb has a handle and the brush is oval-shaped.

Birth Month Floral Brushes & Combs

CA$36.79

May include: A champagne bottle with a gold top and a pink label. The label reads "Preppy Stepps Brut" and "Auburn University 2023 BS Biomedical Sciences". The bottle is tied with a white ribbon.

College Graduation Bottle

CA$257.54

May include: A pink wooden bow-shaped sign with the name "ASHER" in white lettering. The sign is hanging on a white door with a pink ribbon. The bow has a black outline.

Preppy Bow Door Hanger

CA$58.87

Handpainted Pure Light Candles

Handpainted Pure Light Candles

CA$110.38

May include: Two brown leather luggage tags. One tag features the initials "MPB" in black with white and green accents. The other tag has the initials "LAB" in black, surrounded by a white floral design. Both tags have brown leather straps.

Custom Hand Painted Monogram Luggage Tags

CA$58.87

May include: A clear perfume bottle with a silver cap and a black ribbon. The label reads "Crème Vanille Eau de Parfum" with floral accents. The bottle contains 30 ml of perfume.

Handpainted Le Monde Gourmand Fragrances

CA$110.38

May include: A wooden hairbrush and comb set featuring a strawberry design. The oval brush is inscribed with "Pieta". Both items are decorated with red strawberries, white flowers, and green leaves, and are tied with a green ribbon.

Custom Strawberry, Olive, or Ivy Brush & Comb Set

CA$36.79

May include: A rectangular cologne bottle with a red cap and ribbon. The bottle is decorated with pink and red floral designs and the text "JO MALONE LONDON". The label reads "PEONY & BLUSH SUEDE COLOGNE".

Handpainted Jo Malone Fragrances

CA$110.38

May include: Six taper candles in shades of green, red, and dark green, decorated with pink rose floral patterns. The candles are arranged on a white, fluffy surface.

Hand Painted Garland Candles

CA$26.49

May include: Pink and white taper candles decorated with green Christmas trees and gold star accents. The candles are arranged on a white, fluffy surface, creating a festive holiday theme.

Hand Painted Christmas Candles

CA$26.49

Personalized Gift Bags

Personalized Gift Bags

CA$5.89

May include: A pink and gold checkered wooden cutting board with a pink bow and the name "Carlie Mae" written in cursive. A cream-coloured ribbon is tied around the handle.

Custom Gingham & Bow Brush Set

CA$36.79

May include: White wooden cross with a pink floral design. The cross has the names "Asher Paige" and the date "May 18th 2024" written on it.

Custom Sacramental Cross

CA$73.58

May include: A decorative white ceramic bottle with a silver top and a detailed floral design. The bottle features a hand-painted illustration of a building with a red brick facade and a green lawn. A framed picture is in the background.

Hand Painted Bottle

CA$294.34

May include: A pink hairbrush with a white bow painted on the back and the name "celine" written on the handle.

Personalized Bow Brush

CA$80.94

Painted Wedgewood Style Eggs

Painted Wedgewood Style Eggs

CA$58.87

May include: Three white taper candles with green bows printed on them. The candles are arranged in a row on a wooden surface.

Preppy Bow Handpainted Candlesticks

CA$18.40

May include: Assortment of taper candles with a bow design. The candles are in three colours: white, pink, and red. The bows are in black and red.

Preppy Bow Candlesticks

CA$18.40

May include: Three wooden hair brushes with pink floral designs and personalised names: "Heather", "Asher", and "Asher".

Custom Floral Brushes & Combs

CA$36.79

17 people have this in their basket
May include: A green glass Christmas bauble with gold lettering that reads "134 Circle Drive". The bauble is tied with a red and white tartan ribbon.

Custom Personalized Ornament

CA$41.21

May include: A clear glass Christmas bauble with a hand-painted portrait of a French Bulldog. The bauble is decorated with white glitter and the name "Pearce" is written on the front.

Pet Portrait Ornament

CA$110.38

May include: A white pumpkin painted with pink roses and the word "Felicity" in pink script.

Custom Floral Pumpkin

CA$36.79

May include: A basketball featuring the New York Knicks logo and the name Christian written in orange script, wrapped in clear plastic with a blue and orange satin ribbon tied at the top. The ball has blue and orange panels with white accents.

Custom Hand Painted Basketball

CA$257.54

May include: A brown leather American football featuring white laces, a blue Detroit Lions logo, the text Wilson, the number 17, the word LIONS in blue and white, and a central NFL shield emblem with blue and white detailing on the textured surface.

Painted Team Football

CA$220.75

May include: A brown burlap tote bag with a brown teddy bear with a blue bow embroidered on the front.

Hand Painted Teddy Burlap Tote

CA$176.60

May include: A clear glass Christmas bauble with a painted image of a green door with a wreath and a white bow. The bauble is decorated with a white satin ribbon and the text "Fondamente" is written on the bottom.

Front Door Ornament

CA$110.38

May include: White wooden sign with a brown ribbon attached. The sign has a scalloped edge and says "Powder Room" in black cursive lettering.

Powder Room / Pantry Door Hanger

CA$58.87

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on 09 Apr, 2025
Heather Benazzi

Contact shop owner

Heather Benazzi

Contact shop owner

Reviews

5.0 (142)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

  • Kaitlin on 31 Mar, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    Such a special keepsake that I ordered another for my other flower girl. So precious and well packaged!

    Heather

    Heather responded on 01 Apr, 2026

    Kaitlin, you are the sweetest! Thank you so much for the sweet review, it means so much to me! I hope your precious flower girl treasures it! xoxo

  • Carleigh on 21 Mar, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    So pretty! Such pretty artwork and attention to detail! I love!

    Heather

    Heather responded on 21 Mar, 2026

    Thank you so much Carleigh! It was a joy to paint this for you! Happy Spring!!

  • Stacie on 19 Jun, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    Second time ordering from Heather and I’m blown away again! She is such an artist and these personalized bottles make such great gifts and keepsakes! Can’t wait to order more!!

  • Etsy buyer on 14 Jun, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    such beautiful customization on this cute little brush for my daughter! love the lettering and sweet little strawberries 😍. thank you!!

    Heather

    Heather responded on 14 Jun, 2026

    Thank you so much for the sweet review! These strawberry brushes are the cutest!!! xoxo

  • Lisa on 16 May, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    Better than I even imagined. Heather did an amazing job! The details on the bottle were spot on. I will definitely be a repeat customer.

    Heather

    Heather responded on 20 May, 2026

    Lisa, thank you so much for the glowing review! I love when my bottles come out better than the imagination! I live for these reviews! Have a great summer, and we'll chat soon! xoxo

  • alison on 09 May, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    Excellent, beautiful item! Seller was a pleasure to work with! I highly recommend!🙌🏼🍾

    Heather

    Heather responded on 22 May, 2026

    Alison, thank you so much for the glowing review!! I’m so happy you love it!

  • Etsy buyer on 23 Apr, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    This egg is beautifully painted. Nice quality, as pictured, exceeds expectations!

    Heather

    Heather responded on 24 Apr, 2026

    Thank you so much for your fabulous review, and for your purchase! I really enjoy painting these eggs when Springtime rolls around! xo

  • PrettyInInk on 16 Apr, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    Thank you so much for the beautiful pieces and for reaching out to make sure I didn't accidentally order more than I wanted! I truly appreciate the great customer service and love the signs :)

    Heather

    Heather responded on 17 Apr, 2026

    Thank you for the wonderful review! Thank you for taking the time for me! Hope you come back again!

  • Esther on 30 Mar, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    It was such a pleasure dealing with heather she was so accommodating and she did exactly what I asked and went above and beyond was beyond excited

    Heather

    Heather responded on 02 Apr, 2026

    Thank you so much, Esther! This was so fun corresponding with you and creating this! You were such a delightful client! I hope your boyfriend went nuts over the bottle!!! xo

  • Stacie on 27 Feb, 2026

    5 out of 5 stars

    We ordered a custom hand-painted tequila bottle for our friend’s 40th birthday, and it absolutely exceeded our expectations! The attention to detail was incredible, and Heather perfectly captured everything we asked for. It was such a unique and meaningful gift — our friend was blown away! You can truly see the talent and care that went into it. We’ll definitely be ordering again. Thank you for making such a special milestone even more memorable!

    Heather

    Heather responded on 27 Feb, 2026

    awww Stacie, you are the sweetest!!! I am so blown away by your amazing review, and so happy everyone loved it!!!! 🥰 Cheers!!!

About PreppyStepps

@PreppyStepps

Sales 592
On Etsy since 2013

@PreppyStepps

  • I am so appreciative of each and every purchase! Love my customers that shop small business!
  • My work space, taken over by boys and legos!
  • Every artist needs her support system! This is my inspiration everyday! Hubby and me with our 3 babies!
  • My greatest gifts! I am one lucky wife and Mommy! (Hubby Andrew, and I with our sweet Oliver-6, Asher-2, & Liam-5!
  • My family on a beach vacation!

Gifts for all "stepps" of life!

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Heather Benazzi

    Owner

    I have been drawing since I could hold a crayon, and have always been in love with art. I have a BFA in Art Education, and a MA in Studio Art. I am a NYC Special Educator & Art Teacher now a stay at home Momma of 3 just trying to stay creative!

Shop policies

Last updated on 16 February, 2023

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Apple Pay Klarna Gift card
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 24 hours of purchase

Seller details

View shop registration details