ReturnToSenderCo

Toronto, Canada

3.6k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (949)
8 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (949)
3.6k
sales
8 years
on Etsy
3.6k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (949)
8 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (949)
3.6k
sales
8 years
on Etsy
Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
3639 Sales
1575 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All items

Personalized Gothic Snake Book Stamp - Ex Libris

Personalized Gothic Snake Book Stamp - Ex Libris

$24.35

Only 1 available and it's in 1 person's cart
Personalized Gothic Cathedral Book Stamp - Ex Libris

Personalized Gothic Cathedral Book Stamp - Ex Libris

$24.35

5 people have this in their cart
DIY Rubber Stamp Making Kit - Complete Linocut Starter Set - Craft Kit Gift

DIY Rubber Stamp Making Kit - Complete Linocut Starter Set - Craft Kit Gift

$44.28

Custom Teacher Stamp: Graded by name stamp

Custom Teacher Stamp: Graded by name stamp

$23.61

Custom Snail Mail Rubber Stamp | Stationery Lover Gift | Mail Decor

Custom Snail Mail Rubber Stamp | Stationery Lover Gift | Mail Decor

$18.45

Only 1 available and it's in 1 person's cart
DIY Christmas Tag Rubber Stamp Kit

DIY Christmas Tag Rubber Stamp Kit

$20.66

Custom Soap Stamp: Handmade Acrylic Stamp, 2.35" x 0.8" Imprint

Custom Soap Stamp: Handmade Acrylic Stamp, 2.35" x 0.8" Imprint

$24.35

Only 3 left
DIY Rubber Stamp for Custom Messages with Interchangeable Letters and Numbers

DIY Rubber Stamp for Custom Messages with Interchangeable Letters and Numbers

$29.52

18 people have this in their cart
Custom Pottery Stamp: Acrylic Clay Art Branding Logo Stamp

Custom Pottery Stamp: Acrylic Clay Art Branding Logo Stamp

$22.14

Wedding Invitation Stamp For DIY Wedding Invites

Wedding Invitation Stamp For DIY Wedding Invites

$66.42

4 people have this in their cart
Custom Pet Portrait Dog Stamp: Personalized Rubber Stamp

Custom Pet Portrait Dog Stamp: Personalized Rubber Stamp

$20.66

Custom Logo Embosser Stamp: Handheld or Desktop Paper Embosser

Custom Logo Embosser Stamp: Handheld or Desktop Paper Embosser

$33.21

4 people have this in their cart
Custom Logo Rubber Stamp: Wood Mounted Business Stamper

Custom Logo Rubber Stamp: Wood Mounted Business Stamper

$19.92

3 people have this in their cart
Teacher Stamp Custom Portrait Name Stamp With Your Face

Teacher Stamp Custom Portrait Name Stamp With Your Face

$19.92

Wedding Invitation Stamp For DIY Wedding Invites

Wedding Invitation Stamp For DIY Wedding Invites

$61.25

Custom Signature Stamp: Self Inking Business Stamp

Custom Signature Stamp: Self Inking Business Stamp

$23.61

StazOn Ink Pad Kit in Opaque Cotton White

StazOn Ink Pad Kit in Opaque Cotton White

$18.45

Only 1 left
Custom Calligraphy Made With Love Name Stamp: Personalized Wood Handle Stamp

Custom Calligraphy Made With Love Name Stamp: Personalized Wood Handle Stamp

$23.61

Custom Floral Library Stamp: Personalized Book Stamp, Gift for Readers

Custom Floral Library Stamp: Personalized Book Stamp, Gift for Readers

$22.14

Made in Canada Stamp with Maple Leaf Support Canadian Rubber Stamp

Made in Canada Stamp with Maple Leaf Support Canadian Rubber Stamp

$18.45

Delicata Celestial Copper Pigment Ink Pad

Delicata Celestial Copper Pigment Ink Pad

$11.07

Personalized Ex Libris Stamp: Custom Library Book Stamp

Personalized Ex Libris Stamp: Custom Library Book Stamp

$22.14

Tsukineko Brilliance Moonlight White Pigment Ink Pad

Tsukineko Brilliance Moonlight White Pigment Ink Pad

$14.76

Weekly Habit Tracker Stamp, Bullet Journal Rubber Stamp

Weekly Habit Tracker Stamp, Bullet Journal Rubber Stamp

$21.40

Wooden Rubber Stamp Alphabet Gift Set With Box

Wooden Rubber Stamp Alphabet Gift Set With Box

$22.14

5 people have this in their cart
Made In Canada Stamp Support Canadian Rubber Stamp

Made In Canada Stamp Support Canadian Rubber Stamp

$18.45

Made in Canada Stamp Support Canadian Rubber Stamp

Made in Canada Stamp Support Canadian Rubber Stamp

$18.45

Maple Leaf Made In Canada Support Local Canadian Rubber Stamp

Maple Leaf Made In Canada Support Local Canadian Rubber Stamp

$18.45

Made In Canada Support Local Canadian Rubber Stamp

Made In Canada Support Local Canadian Rubber Stamp

$18.45

Custom Cat Portrait Stamp: Personalized Pet Rubber Stamp

Custom Cat Portrait Stamp: Personalized Pet Rubber Stamp

$20.66

Entered Date Self Inking Stamp For Dating Entries

Entered Date Self Inking Stamp For Dating Entries

$25.83

Final Sale Self-Inking Stamp, Red Ink (1.5″ x 0.5″)

Final Sale Self-Inking Stamp, Red Ink (1.5″ x 0.5″)

$16.97

Received Dater Self Inking Stamp For Dating and Receiving Paper Work

Received Dater Self Inking Stamp For Dating and Receiving Paper Work

$34.68

Custom Teacher Stamp: Self Inking Date Stamp for Homework

Custom Teacher Stamp: Self Inking Date Stamp for Homework

$47.97

Custom Wedding Invitation Stamp for Jacque

Custom Wedding Invitation Stamp for Jacque

$81.17

Wedding Invitation Stamp For DIY Wedding Invites

Wedding Invitation Stamp For DIY Wedding Invites

$68.63

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Sep 5, 2025
Sarah

Contact shop owner

Sarah

Contact shop owner

Reviews

5.0 (949)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

About ReturnToSenderCo

Custom rubber stamps, embossers and branding.

Sales 3,639
On Etsy since 2018

Custom rubber stamps, embossers and branding.

Shop about video description

Contributing a small part to small business' across the globe!

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Sarah Trafford

    Owner

    I'm a letterer and designer and am admittedly a make-a-holic, I can't help but want to make everything with my own two hands.

Shop policies

Last updated on Sep 5, 2025

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options
Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 12 hours of purchase

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Where can I send my logo file?

sarahtrafford@me.com

What type of file do you need for logo stamps?

A high resolution file in black and white. File type can be pdf, ai, eps, jpg or png.

Can I see a proof before you make it?

Yes, If you have a custom order (something with a custom design or text) I will send you an image of what will be cut into the stamp before production. This allows you to approve the spelling. If it's a logo, there is no need for a proof.

Do you offer local pickup?

Yes, I am in downtown Toronto and can offer local pickup. Please message me for location and hours.

My soap stamp isn't imprinting well

Please check your technique, these stamps are the correct depth and have worked successfully when done correctly.

These links may help:

www.lovinsoap.com/2017/10/guest-post-using-stamps-to-embellish-soaps-by-...

www.youtube.com/watch?v=zdfdsBshm0Y

What size should I purchase?

This depends on the size of the surface you are stamping. If you are worried about legibility, try printing your image or logo at the size you wish, if it looks good it will also look good when stamped.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy