SentimentalSeeker

Indianapolis, Indiana

843
 Sales

5.0 (220)

12 years
on Etsy

5.0 (220)

843
 sales

12 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

843
 Sales

5.0 (220)

12 years
on Etsy

5.0 (220)

843
 sales

12 years
on Etsy

All 44

Contact shop owner

843 Sales

248 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jul 7, 2026

I source often, so check back frequently for new items. My goal is to list something new everyday! Some items will have vintage wear and will do my best to mention that; but please feel free to ask me questions!

Follow me on Instagram @ sentimental_seeker

If you’re local and would like to pickup without paying shipping costs-use coupon code LOCALPICKUP during checkout.

Contact shop owner

Morgan

Reviews

5.0 (220)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Galina on Aug 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Excellent service, seller. Fast shipping. Thank you

Chunky Ironstone Butter Pat and Restaurant Creamer Set

Chunky Ironstone Butter Pat and Restaurant Creamer Set
Sherry on Aug 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

My aunt is going to love this cute tea cup and saucer. Arrived sooner than expected and packaged with such care! Will be shopping here again!

Antique Vintage Bluebird China Teacup Set-Homer Laughlin Style Blue Birds

Antique Vintage Bluebird China Teacup Set-Homer Laughlin Style Blue Birds
Anna on Aug 13, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Just as described. Seller must be magic because the package arrived so fast! I didn’t even know what would be in the box when I opened it because I was like no way my hooks already got here, but it was them!

Vintage Brass His and Hers Wall Hooks-Bridal Shower Gift-Wedding Gift

Vintage Brass His and Hers Wall Hooks-Bridal Shower Gift-Wedding Gift
Tim on Aug 13, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Item was photographed and exactly as described. It was also packed really well and had no issues or damage when it arrived

Vintage Brass Magnifying Glass on Stand

Vintage Brass Magnifying Glass on Stand
Julie on Aug 13, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is exactly what I was looking for. The seller was great to work with. Shipped quickly and carefully packaged everything so the picture and frame arrived intact. Hope to do business again - thank you!

Vintage Art Fruit on Board Oil Painting

Vintage Art Fruit on Board Oil Painting
mary on Aug 8, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Packed with care good quality

Vintage Frosted Floral Fairy Lamp Top

Vintage Frosted Floral Fairy Lamp Top
ALISSA on Aug 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful! Coffee mug I purchased as a gift was exactly as pictured, great customer service and communication from seller. Quick to ship and arrived safely!

Vintage Fire King Leo Zodiac Horoscope Coffee Mug

Vintage Fire King Leo Zodiac Horoscope Coffee Mug
Etsy buyer on Jul 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I love it. Thank you so much.

Morgan responded on Jul 22, 2026

Happy you love it! Thank you for the review 😊

Retro Groovy Vintage MCM Lucite Mushroom Napkin Holder-Mail Holder

Retro Groovy Vintage MCM Lucite Mushroom Napkin Holder-Mail Holder
Grace on Jul 20, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Item as described, packaged well, and arrived quickly. Prefect for my collection. Thank you!

Morgan responded on Jul 22, 2026

Glad it arrived safely! Thank you for the review 😊

Vintage Fenton Milk Glass Hobnob Fairy Lamp

Vintage Fenton Milk Glass Hobnob Fairy Lamp
Kristi on Jul 12, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Obsessed with this vase. Exactly what I was looking for. Exactly as described, shipped quickly and packed well. Highly recommend buyer!

Morgan responded on Jul 12, 2026

Thank you Kristi! glad you love it and that it arrived safely 😊

Antique Stained Ironstone Pitcher

Antique Stained Ironstone Pitcher

About SentimentalSeeker

Giving Second Chances to Vintage items

Sales 843

On Etsy since 2014

Giving Second Chances to Vintage items

Giving Second Chances to Thrifted Pieces!

My love of old things started when I was a child, my first piece of glass was a blue opalescent Fenton hobnail bowl that I bought when I was 12. I went to lots of auctions and garage sales with my dad and the next day, we would do pop up sales! I love the thrill of the thrift hunt and if you're looking for something special, please message me and I'll keep an eye out! Thank you for stopping by and Happy Shopping!

Instagram

Shop members

Morgan

Owner

Giving a second life to things that might have ended up in the landfill. My love of thrifting started when I was a child as my family use to go to auctions, garage sales, flea markets and antique stores. I love the history a piece has to tell!

Shop policies

Last updated on February 16, 2023

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 1 hour of purchase

SentimentalSeeker

Featured items

Antique Old Man Portrait Gold Gilded Oval Frame-Antique Wall Art

Vintage Brass Birdcage Decor Large

Antique Wooden Spice Wall Cabinet 8 Drawer- Apocethary Cabinet

Mini Butcher Block Cutting Board Mini Wood Cutting Board Vintage Cutting Board

All items

Vintage Brass Birdcage Decor

Vintage Uranium Yellow Glass Floral Fenton Candle Votive Holders

Homer Laughlin Bluebird Platter Plate-Blue Bird Platter

Handmade Glazed Pottery Bird Whistle Set of 3

Vintage Mikasa Provencal Greenville Floral Dinner Plates Set of 4

Vintage Brass Trophy Style Table Lamp

Jana Kozon Kausalik Art Pottery Vase With Magnolia Flower

Vintage Brass Hands-Business Card Holder-Brass Hand Trinket Dish

Vintage Brass Birdcage Decor Large

Antique Super Stained Ironstone Ceramic Rose Pattern by Dunn Bennett & Co. England

Japanese Satsuma Porcelain Geisha Plates set of 5

Fenton Aqua Opalescent Optic Swirl Fairy Lamp

1930s Aluminum Cake Carrier Green Uranium Knob

Antique USS New York Commemorative Plate-Ironstone Ship Plate

Vintage Rome Colosseum Tapestry-Wall Tapestry Hanging

Brutalist Candle Holder Van Keppel Green Wrought Iron Candle Holder Midcentury Style Decor-Castle Core Decor

Hand Carved Wooden Duck- Duck Decor

Vintage Handpainted Floral Bread Board and Knife-Folk Art

Vintage Italian Copper Brass Tankard with lion head

Johnson Brothers Rose Chintz Candle Holders-Gift for Her-Small Containers or Planters

Antique Flow Blue Bowl Super Stained Ironstone

Mini Butcher Block Cutting Board Mini Wood Cutting Board Vintage Cutting Board

Vintage Brass and Oak Wood "Do It Now" Office Desk Letter or Bill Organizer

Vintage Brass Mother of Pearl Mosaic Inlay MOP Candlestick Holders

Handmade Wood Inlay Pieced Wooden Candlestick Candleholders

Susana Espinosa Puerto Rico Pottery Owl

Vintage 1985 Delmatto Ohio Blown Art Glass Vase Opaline

Antique Ironstone Alfred Meakin Moss Rose Sugar Bowl with Lid

Antique Ironstone Alfred Meakin Moss Rose Teapot

Antique Hand Painted Floral Milk Glass Syrup Pitcher

Antique Wooden Spice Wall Cabinet 8 Drawer- Apocethary Cabinet

Antique Old Man Portrait Gold Gilded Oval Frame-Antique Wall Art

Vintage Russel Wright Iroquois Casual ceramic stacking salt and pepper shaker set

Vintage Capiz Shell Charger Plates Set of 8

Murano Antica Vetraria Glass Millefiori Dish Handmade in Italy

Vintage Wooden Musical Treasure Chest Jewelry Box Lion Head Brass Decorations

Announcement

Reviews

About SentimentalSeeker

Shop members

Morgan

Shop policies

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations