ThatOldPinball

Wharton, New Jersey

28
 Sales

4.8 (9)

3 years
on Etsy

4.8 (9)

28
 sales

3 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

28
 Sales

4.8 (9)

3 years
on Etsy

4.8 (9)

28
 sales

3 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

28 Sales

5 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jun 17, 2026

Contact shop owner

Melanie

Reviews

4.8 (9)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

john on Apr 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Seller was great and helpful

Special listing for John- Williams Police Force Pinball - Trucker Hat - Reproduction

Special listing for John- Williams Police Force Pinball - Trucker Hat - Reproduction
Kim on Mar 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

exactly as was pictured, perfect

Make Pinball Great Again 4” Magnet - Gaming - Stocking Stuffer

Make Pinball Great Again 4” Magnet - Gaming - Stocking Stuffer
Corey on Jan 18, 2026

4 out of 5 stars

Good hat for the money, goes with my bomber jacket

Williams Police Force Pinball - Trucker Hat

Williams Police Force Pinball - Trucker Hat
Justin on Jan 16, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Very hard to find item, recreated to the smallest details. Exceeded my expectations for sure. Thank you so much!

Williams Police Force Pinball - Trucker Hat - Reproduction

Williams Police Force Pinball - Trucker Hat - Reproduction
Justin on Jan 16, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Perfect seller, would definitely buy from again.

Official Williams Police Force Pinball T-shirt

Official Williams Police Force Pinball T-shirt
Tom on Nov 15, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

It’s a nice tee, thanks.

Pinball Tech Unisex Softstyle T-Shirt, Vintage Gamer Tee, Casual Retro Shirt, Fun Arcade Apparel, Gift for Pinball Lovers

Pinball Tech Unisex Softstyle T-Shirt, Vintage Gamer Tee, Casual Retro Shirt, Fun Arcade Apparel, Gift for Pinball Lovers
BJ on Aug 6, 2025

4 out of 5 stars

Nice looking T shirt. Will make a nice gift. I mistakenly thought this was embroidered, which it’s not. Does look good, crisp graphics.

Pinball Wizard Unisex T-Shirt - Retro Arcade Tee for Gamers, Game Night, Birthday Gift, Music Lover's Apparel, Fun Vintage Style

Pinball Wizard Unisex T-Shirt - Retro Arcade Tee for Gamers, Game Night, Birthday Gift, Music Lover's Apparel, Fun Vintage Style
Martin on Apr 8, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

awesome magnet and great quality

Make Pinball Great Again 4” Magnet

Make Pinball Great Again 4” Magnet
Brian on Feb 13, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Love the wording in the hat.

Make Pinball Great Again red snapback baseball hat

Make Pinball Great Again red snapback baseball hat

About ThatOldPinball

Pinball & Arcade Merchandise & Retro Gaming Gifts

Sales 28

On Etsy since 2023

Pinball & Arcade Merchandise & Retro Gaming Gifts

Just a few of our games!
Replacing the connectors and putting in new pins
sometime you have to work on your birthday!

Hi, We are the creators behind That Old Pinball.

What started as a hobby has turned into a passion for restoring classic pinball machines and grew into a business dedicated to keeping arcade history alive.

As a pinball enthusiast, We've spent years collecting, repairing, reproducing hard-to-find parts, and creating unique merchandise inspired by the machines we love.

The designs in our shop are created with fellow pinball and arcade fans in mind. From gaming apparel and stickers to magnets, keychains, and collectibles, our goal is to celebrate the hobby and bring a little nostalgia to your game room, workshop, or everyday life.

Whether you're a collector, technician, arcade owner, or simply someone who loves classic gaming, thank you for supporting a small business dedicated to preserving pinball culture.

Keep flipping!

— That Old Pinbal

Facebook

shop-website

Instagram

Shop members

Melanie & David

Owner

Hi, We are the creators behind That Old Pinball.

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Bathroom

Home Decor Gifts by TurkishToweLove

Hair Accessories

African Print Bonnet Wrap - Hair Accessories

Gender Neutral Adult Clothing

Buy Hot Dog Pyjama Online Cute Easter Bunny Sweatshirt by SeraBoutiqueCo Summer Vibes Women's Tee: Distressed Beach Mom Shirt by EZOOUTFIT Kansas Crewneck for Sale Buy Shadow Trooper Online Buy Playera Para Mama Online Fall Nurse Raccoon T-Shirt: Autumn Nursing Gift

Womens Clothing

S M SIZE dirndl by VbyVintage

Telephones & Handsets

That Girl of Mine Will Dillon Harry Tobias Arthur Lange 1916 Sheet Music V15 by EverydayEphemera

Bracelets

8mm Evil Eye Bracelet Onyx and Red Eye Bracelet by TheMystikalDen Cross Gold Beaded Bracelet by TheNeonCactusStudio

Hats & Caps

Yellowstone Organic Cotton Dad Hat – Hiking & Camping Unstructured Cap by TriniSkiesApparel

Canvas & Surfaces

Three-Rex Cake Topper SVG - 3rd Birthday SVG - Cake Topper SVG Digital Download eps dxf png - Canvas & Surfaces

Shopping

Buy Butterfly On Black Fabric Online Caramel Spandex for Sale

Collectibles

Buy Magnetic Rolling Tray Lid Online

ThatOldPinball

Featured items

Cute Dino Girl Pinball Shirt, Comfort Colors C1717 Retro Arcade Tee, Pink Dinosaur Gamer T-Shirt, Pinball Gift for Women

Silverball Social Club Shirt, Pinball T-Shirt, Retro Arcade Tee, Pinball Player Gift, Unisex Gamer Tee, League Night Shirt

Dinosaur Pinball Social Club T-Shirt, Gildan Soft Style Tee, Retro Arcade Gamer Tee, Funny Dinosaur, Silverball Club

Pinball Tech College Style Shirt, Retro Arcade Enthusiast Apparel, Vintage Graphic Tee

All items

Obsolete Tech Institute College Style Shirt, Vintage Electronics Graphic Tee, 70s Nostalgia Apparel

Obsolete Tech T-Rex Soldering Circuit Board Shirt, Retro Computer Geek Tee, Gildan Soft Style Tee

Obsolete Tech Collage Shirt, Retro Computer Graphic Tee, 70s Nostalgia Electronics T-Shirt, Gildan Soft Style Tee

Obsolete Tech Collage Graphic Tee, Retro Computer, VCR, Floppy Disk Humor, Gildan Soft Style Tee

Pinball Tech College Style Shirt, Retro Arcade Enthusiast Apparel, Vintage Graphic Tee

Pinball Wizard Flag T-Shirt, Comfort Colors C1717, America 250th Birthday Tee, Patriotic Pinball Shirt, July 4th Arcade Gift

Dinosaur Pinball Social Club T-Shirt, Gildan Soft Style Tee, Retro Arcade Gamer Tee, Funny Dinosaur, Silverball Club

Silverball Social Club Shirt, Pinball T-Shirt, Retro Arcade Tee, Pinball Player Gift, Unisex Gamer Tee, League Night Shirt

Retro Pinball House Shirt, Comfort Colors 1717 T-Shirt, Vintage Arcade Graphic Tee, Gamer Gift, Pinball Lover Top, Unisex Heavyweight Tee

Pinball House Graphic T-Shirt, Retro Arcade Gaming Apparel, Birthday Gift, Game Room Tshirt, Tournament Gear

Retro Style Pinball Wizard T-Shirt, Vintage Arcade Gamer Apparel, Coin Op Shirt, Pinball Tournament Shirt

Retro Pinball T-Shirt, Vintage Arcade Game Tee, Classic 80s Graphic Shirt, Coin Op Shirt, Pinball Tournament Shirt

Retro Pinball Gamer Shirt, Vintage Arcade Lover Tee, Just a Girl, Pinball Lover, Fan Gift

In My Pinball Era Shirt, Gildan Soft Style Tee, Coin Op Shirt, Pinball Tournament Shirt,

Cute Dino Girl Pinball Shirt, Comfort Colors C1717 Retro Arcade Tee, Pink Dinosaur Gamer T-Shirt, Pinball Gift for Women

Artistic Pinball Graphic Tee, Gildan Soft Style Tee, Retro Arcade Gaming Shirt, Coin Op Apparel

Funny T-Rex Dinosaur Playing Pinball T-Shirt, Gildan Soft Style Tee, Retro Arcade Gamer Tee, Unique Dinosaur Pinball Lover

Dinosaur Playing Pinball Shirt, Funny Pinball T-Shirt, Retro Arcade Gamer Tee, T-Rex Gift for Pinball Lovers, Dinosaur Game Room Shirt

Pinball Plunger T-Shirt, Pinball Apparel, Retro Pinball Graphic, Vintage Gamer Gift, Arcade Lover Shirt, Pinball Player Tee

I Like Pinball T-Shirt, Gildan Soft Style Tee, Retro Arcade Gaming Apparel, Funny Introvert Tee

Funny Dog and Pinball Retro Gaming Shirt, Gildan Soft Style Tee, Animal Lover Gift, Dog Mom, Dog Dad, Dog Lover

Funny Pinball Cat Shirt, Gildan Soft Style Tee, Retro Arcade Gamer Tee, Animal Lover Gift, Cat Mom, Cat Lover, Pinball Fan

Obsolete Tech Sticker, CRT, VCR, Floppy Disks, Retro Humor, Old School Enthusiasts

Obsolete Tech Dinosaur Sticker, Retro Computer, Arcade Fan Vinyl Decal, Soldering Dinosaur, Funny Sticker

Dinosaur Playing Pinball Sticker, Retro Arcade T-Rex Decal, Obsolete Tech Art

Retro T-Rex Arcade Sticker, Dinosaur Playing Asteroids Decal, Gamer Gift, Pinball Enthusiast Gift

I Like Pinball My Dog and Maybe 3 People Holographic Sticker, Arcade Decal, Dog Lover, Dog Mom, Dog Dad

Baby Pac-Man Keychain, Retro Arcade Gamer Accessory, 80s Nostalgic Bag Charm

Baby Pac-Man Glitter Sticker, Retro Arcade Vinyl Decal, 80s Gamer Collectible, Classic Arcade Game Sticker, Retro 80's Baby Pac Man

Retro Pinball Vinyl Sticker, Tri-Color Arcade Decal, Laptop Water Bottle Art, Birthday Gift, Add Some Retro Arcade Flair to your Gear

Hot Girls Play Pinball Sticker, Retro Arcade Gamer Vinyl Decal, Girls Play Pinball

Pinball Retirement Plan Sticker, Retro Arcade Gamer Decal, Game Room Decor, Pinball Humor

Make Pinball Popular Again Sticker, Retro Pinball Graphic Sticker, Vintage Gamer Gift, Arcade Lover Sticker, Pinball Player Sticker

That Old Pinball Logo Sticker, Retro Arcade Gamer Decal, Birthday Gift, Collectable, Pinball Enthusiast Gift

Pink Holographic Pinball Sticker, Retro Arcade Gamer Decal, Laptop Vinyl, Pinball Lover Gift

Retro Pinball Sticker, Vintage Arcade Art, 70's Design, Birthday Gift, Add Some Retro Arcade Flair to your Gear

Announcement

Reviews

About ThatOldPinball

Shop members

Melanie & David

Shop policies

Returns & exchanges