TheCustomReserve

Illinois, United States

19.9k
 Sales

4.9 (3.5k)

8 years
on Etsy

4.9 (3.5k)

19.9k
 sales

8 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

19.9k
 Sales

4.9 (3.5k)

8 years
on Etsy

4.9 (3.5k)

19.9k
 sales

8 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

19880 Sales

1013 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jul 15, 2026

Contact shop owner

TheCustomReserve

Reviews

4.9 (3527)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Tracey on Jul 28, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

The stone was perfect and it’s beautiful!

Personalized Memorial Garden Stone, Sympathy Gift, Loss of Loved One, Grave Site Decor, In Loving Memory Keepsake Present, Memorial Tree

Personalized Memorial Garden Stone, Sympathy Gift, Loss of Loved One, Grave Site Decor, In Loving Memory Keepsake Present, Memorial Tree
Jill on Jul 27, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

My dear friend tragically lost her father to suicide a few months ago. His birthday was a few days ago and I wanted to send her something to honor his life. She text me and said it was absolutely beautiful. She said she was sitting there crying because I had sent her such a beautiful gift. ❤️ I highly recommend this item and this seller! 🤗

Personalized Memorial Garden Stone, Sympathy Gift, Loss of Loved One, Grave Site Decor, In Loving Memory Keepsake Present, Memorial Tree

Personalized Memorial Garden Stone, Sympathy Gift, Loss of Loved One, Grave Site Decor, In Loving Memory Keepsake Present, Memorial Tree
Emalee on Jul 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great for gifts! High quality.

Rectangle Printed Bar Mat For Countertop, Non-Slip Bar Mat, Mixology Decor, Home Bar, Personalized Bar Mat, Cocktail Gift, Gifts For Him

Rectangle Printed Bar Mat For Countertop, Non-Slip Bar Mat, Mixology Decor, Home Bar, Personalized Bar Mat, Cocktail Gift, Gifts For Him
Dene on Jul 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful and exactly as I ordered it.

Personalized Wedding Champagne Flutes, Mr and Mrs Champagne Glasses, Custom Toasting Glasses, Engraved Bridal Gift, Wedding Gift for Couple

Personalized Wedding Champagne Flutes, Mr and Mrs Champagne Glasses, Custom Toasting Glasses, Engraved Bridal Gift, Wedding Gift for Couple
Randi on Jul 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These champagne flutes arrived perfectly as described. I can't wait to use them at my wedding

Personalized Wedding Champagne Glasses With Initials, Custom Engraved Toasting Flutes For Newlyweds, Anniversary Gift, Mr. and Mrs. Glasses

Personalized Wedding Champagne Glasses With Initials, Custom Engraved Toasting Flutes For Newlyweds, Anniversary Gift, Mr. and Mrs. Glasses
Marie on Jul 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great glasses wonderful look to them

Personalized Wedding Champagne Flutes, Mr and Mrs Champagne Glasses, Custom Toasting Glasses, Engraved Bridal Gift, Wedding Gift for Couple

Personalized Wedding Champagne Flutes, Mr and Mrs Champagne Glasses, Custom Toasting Glasses, Engraved Bridal Gift, Wedding Gift for Couple
Etsy buyer on Jul 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Exactly like I hoped it would turn out! I can’t wait to give this to my husband for his birthday!

Rectangle Printed Bar Mat For Countertop, Non-Slip Bar Mat, Mixology Decor, Home Bar, Personalized Bar Mat, Cocktail Gift, Gifts For Him

Rectangle Printed Bar Mat For Countertop, Non-Slip Bar Mat, Mixology Decor, Home Bar, Personalized Bar Mat, Cocktail Gift, Gifts For Him
Kelly on Jul 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Good product, as described and pictured

Personalized Wedding Champagne Glasses With Initials, Custom Engraved Toasting Flutes For Newlyweds, Anniversary Gift, Mr. and Mrs. Glasses

Personalized Wedding Champagne Glasses With Initials, Custom Engraved Toasting Flutes For Newlyweds, Anniversary Gift, Mr. and Mrs. Glasses
Stephanie on Jul 28, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Nice item. 2nd one ordered Thank you

Personalized Baby Photo Album With Sleeves, First Birthday Gift, New Baby Present, Picture Keepsake, Baptism Gift, Boy Girl, Welcome Baby

Personalized Baby Photo Album With Sleeves, First Birthday Gift, New Baby Present, Picture Keepsake, Baptism Gift, Boy Girl, Welcome Baby
Krista on Jul 27, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

It’s beautiful and she loved it

Personalized Baby Memorial Gift, Memorial Keepsake Box, Baby Loss Gift, Child Memorial, Photo Memory Box, Engraved Gift, Angel Wings

Personalized Baby Memorial Gift, Memorial Keepsake Box, Baby Loss Gift, Child Memorial, Photo Memory Box, Engraved Gift, Angel Wings

About TheCustomReserve

Personalized Gifts for Him

Sales 19,880

On Etsy since 2018

Personalized Gifts for Him

Invite your best guys to be your groomsmen with these great groomsmen gifts

Make it custom -- with The Custom Reserve

Shopping for a man can be hard, we know. You can spend forever trying to find the perfect thing for his birthday or your anniversary -- and then he ends up never using it! Well, that's where we are here to help. Let us help you find a gift for him that he is sure to appreciate. We strive to offer a selection of luxury goods that any man would appreciate receiving! And, as always, we will personalize the item with whatever you like! Make it custom -- with The Custom Reserve

We pledge to provide:

-Excellent Customer Service: Whatever questions you may have, we will answer them!

-Quick and Easy Personalization: We'll show you the product, you tell us what you want it to say, and we'll take care of the rest. It's that simple!

-A Great Selection of Products: We've got a wide selection of products, so you won't have a problem finding something for the man in your life! From unique glassware that shows your appreciation for the Groomsmen that will be standing by your side to personalized bar mats that are sure to add a nice touch to any man cave!

Shop members

Colin

Owner
Riley

Customer Service

Production partners

Fashion Craft

NY, United States

FashionCraft is a production partner who helps us to create and ship out higher unit count orders in time for your special day!
Kate Aspen, Inc.

Duluth, GA

Produce and Ship Glassware

Shop policies

Last updated on Jun 19, 2018

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Kitchen & Dining

Custom 20 oz Stainless Steel Cup with Straw by TheTumblerLabCo Staffordshire Chef for Sale Buy Kitchen Utensil Mug Online Buy Fitz Floyd Apple Online Japanese Vintage Bone China Cup and Saucer by ClockTowerAntiques 3 Handmade Loomed Cotton Potholders - Pastel Halloween by FoundFelicity Meredith Marks "Disengaging" Mug - Real Housewives of Salt Lake City by GlitzGeekGoods Mary Mug-Coworker Mug-Mary Definition Mug-Personalised Mary Mug-Custom Mary Mug-Funny Work Gift-Mug For Coworker - Kitchen & Dining Butterfly & Dandelion Towel by AniasCottage Wizard Of Oz Coffee for Sale

Shopping

Buy Gandalf Dwarves Online

Toys

Buy Collectible Burago Online Cossack Leader by CMCstudio3D

Patterns & How To

117 All Tied Up vest by FranCreations

Rings

Flat Wide Platinum Band by MSJewelers

Pet Toys

Buy Egg Cat Toy Online

Food & Drink

Persian Food Gift for Sale

Yarn & Fiber

Shades of beige (14 oz cone) - Yarn & Fiber

TheCustomReserve

Featured items

Dad Established Engraved Whiskey Glass, Custom Father's Day Glass, Gift For Dad, Grandpa, Gifts For Men, Whiskey Gift, Whiskey Glass For Dad

Custom Beer Glass For Coach, Engraved Sports Custom Message Glass, Baseball Gift, Dad Gifts, Football Cup, Golf Drinkware, Pickleball

Engraved Custom Message Whiskey Decanter and Rocks Glass Set, Handwritten Font, Personalized Decanter, Graduation, Christmas Gift For Him

Personalized Whiskey Glass, Custom Message Engraved On The Bottom, Gifts For Men, Bourbon Gifts, Graduation Gifts, Birthday Gift, Home Bar

Dad Established Engraved Whiskey Glass, Custom Father's Day Glass, Gift For Dad, Grandpa, Gifts For Men, Whiskey Gift, Whiskey Glass For Dad

Custom Beer Glass For Coach, Engraved Sports Custom Message Glass, Baseball Gift, Dad Gifts, Football Cup, Golf Drinkware, Pickleball

Engraved Custom Message Whiskey Decanter and Rocks Glass Set, Handwritten Font, Personalized Decanter, Graduation, Christmas Gift For Him

Personalized Whiskey Glass, Custom Message Engraved On The Bottom, Gifts For Men, Bourbon Gifts, Graduation Gifts, Birthday Gift, Home Bar

All items

Embroidered Light Up Christmas Personalized Christmas Stocking

Personalized Embroidered Green Plush Stocking

Personalized Gray Christmas Stocking, Grey Stocking, Plush Embroidered Stocking, Personalized Stocking, Holiday Decor, Family Stockings

Pet Paw Print Christmas Stocking, personalized dog christmas stocking personalized cat christmas stocking, custom stocking for pet

Embroidered Red Truck Personalized Christmas Stocking

Embroidered 3D Santa Personalized Christmas Stocking

Engraved Mr. and Mrs. Gold Rim Stemless Wine Glass, Personalized Stemless Wine Glass, Custom Wine Glass, Home Bar Gift, Wedding Gift

Personalized Dog Memorial Garden Stone, Best Friends Flat Stepping Stone, Loss Of Pet

Engraved In Loving Memory Personalized Pet Memorial Garden Stone, pet grave marker, loss of dog, dog memorial, dog tombstone, sympathy gift

Engraved Welcome Garden Stone, garden decor, personalized garden stone, outdoor decor, family name, yard decor, housewarming gift, wedding

Personalized Sunflowers Flat Garden Stone, Welcome Garden Stone, Floral Garden Stone, Housewarming Gift, Gift For Gardener, Gardens Decor

Farmer Memorial Magnetic Yard Sign, Cherished Farmer Tribute, Outdoor Magnetic Sign for Memorial Gardens, Durable Yard Decor

Personalized Memorial Garden Cross with Roses, Custom Outdoor Sympathy Cross, In Loving Memory Grave Marker, Bereavement Gift for Loss

Personalized Engraved Ranch Animal Memorial Garden Stone, Sympathy Gift, Remembrance, In Memory of, Horse Memorial, Donkey, Cow, Duck, Goose

Be Still and Know Blanket, Psalm 46:10 Sherpa Throw, Christian Bible Verse Gift, Faith-Based Home Decor, Inspirational Cozy Blanket

In Memory Garden Stone, Beautiful Life Memorial Plaque, Outdoor Remembrance Stone with Floral Design, Sympathy Gift for Loss

Personalized Dragonfly Memorial Garden Stone, Outdoor Bereavement, Loss of Loved One Sympathy Gift

Personalized Beach Memorial Garden Stake, Custom Beach Sympathy Yard Sign, In Loving Memory Grave Marker, Ocean Memorial Gift, Bereavement

Personalized Farmer Memorial Garden Stone, Outdoor Tractor Bereavement Plaque, Loss of Loved One Sympathy Gift

Personalized Cardinal Memorial Garden Stone, Outdoor Bereavement, Loss of Loved One Sympathy Gift

Personalized Memorial Garden Stone With Cross, Custom Religious Memorial Gift, Outdoor Bereavement, Loss of Loved One Sympathy Gift

Personalized Class of Confetti Pennant, Custom Graduation Gift, College Grad, High School, Wall Decor, Class of 2026

Any Message Drinkware with Bubbles Square Bar Mat, Customized Bar Mat, Home Bar Accessories, Fathers Day Present, Beer Coaster, Gift For Her

Plush Bear, Personalized Teddy Bear, Customizable Stuffed Bear, Gift for Kids, Cuddly Plush Toy, Unique Gift Idea

Personalized Brown Bear, Custom Message Stuffed Bear, Birthday Gift, Gift For Her, Anniversary Gift

Personalized Brown Bear, Custom Message Stuffed Bear, Birthday Gift

Plush Sherman Bear, Personalized Teddy Bear, Customizable Stuffed Animal, Gift for Kids, Cuddly Plush Toy, Unique Gift Idea

Personalized Frog Plush, Gift For Girlfriend, Soft Stuffed Green Frog For Her, Anniversary Gift, Gift For Him, Frog Lover

You're My Mane Squeeze Plush Lion, Cuddly Toy, Adorable Stuffed Animal, Snuggly Crafts Companion, Gift For Her, Anniversary Gift

Personalized Baby Keepsake Box, New Baby Memory Storage, First Birthday Gift, Picture Box, 1st Bday, Newborn Keepsake

Engraved In Memory Of With Border Garden Stone, Sympathy Gift, Loss Of Loved One

Engraved If Love Could Have Saved You Garden Stone, memorial stone for garden, sympathy gift, remembrance, bereavement gift, mourning gift

Personalized Watercolor In Memory Of Wind Chime

Personalized Dog Memorial Stone, Angel Wings Memorial, Heart Shaped Stone, Pet Grave Marker, In Memory Of Cat

Personalized Cross Memorial Stone, Angel Wings Memorial, Heart Shaped Stone, Grave Marker, In Memory Of, Sympathy Gift

Personalized Memorial Stone for Loved Ones, Angel Wings Memorial, Heart Shaped Stone, Grave Marker, In Memory Of

Announcement

Reviews

About TheCustomReserve

Shop members

Colin

Riley

Production partners

Shop policies

Shipping

Customs and import taxes

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations