TheMagicKeyCompany

Sister Bay, Wisconsin

1.4k
 Sales

5.0 (577)

6 years
on Etsy

5.0 (577)

1.4k
 sales

6 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

1.4k
 Sales

5.0 (577)

6 years
on Etsy

5.0 (577)

1.4k
 sales

6 years
on Etsy

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Oct 17, 2024

Welcome to THE MAGIC KEY COMPANY!

Here you will find vintage and new skeleton key creations along with my magical, handmade Witch Bells to adorn your home in every season. The Tree of Life Witch Bells are my original design, used to clear energy and to bring protection and prosperity to a home. Each Tree of Life takes hours to create, patience in my creative process is greatly appreciated!💖

One of my favorite parts of this creative endeavor is searching for vintage keys at antique and resale shops. Finding these mysterious old keys makes the mind soar, imagining what they have opened, and possibly even hidden and kept safe, so many years ago.

I'm lucky to live in Door County, WI, very near to Lake Michigan, one of our Great Lakes, and find peace walking the shores searching for little treasures. The pieces of driftwood used in my Witch Bells have been weathered and smoothed from their time in the water. I love bringing natural elements into my Witch Bells, from pine and cedar cones, to Great Lakes driftwood, bringing some of the magic of Door County into your home.

Unlock the magic and your imagination with The Magic Key Company.

Please visit my other Etsy shops:
https://www.etsy.com/shop/soulharborjewelry
https://www.etsy.com/shop/DoorCountyForager

Contact shop owner

Joni

Reviews

5.0 (577)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Alexis on Apr 24, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Everything about this is perfect! I love it. It hangs beautifully by my door and is just the perfect thing to protect the house but being pretty at the same time.

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 9 inch, Moss Wreath, Rainbow Dreaming Tree, Pride Decor, Housewarming, Home & Door Protection, Made to Order

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 9 inch, Moss Wreath, Rainbow Dreaming Tree, Pride Decor, Housewarming, Home & Door Protection, Made to Order
Etsy buyer on Sep 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I just love this. Perfect for my front door. Very pleased with the transaction. 10/10!

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Decoration, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Plaid Ribbons

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Decoration, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Plaid Ribbons
Tim on Sep 14, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

N/A No thanks no need

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Church Key, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Ornaments for Men

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Church Key, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Ornaments for Men
George on Sep 10, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful Autumn Swag and Great Quality!!!

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Décor, Brass Sleigh Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Small Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic Witchy

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Décor, Brass Sleigh Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Small Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic Witchy
Emily on Aug 31, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

So pretty, the key matches the vibe of the raven coin- thank you for making this for me!

Joni responded on Sep 1, 2026

Emily, I'm so happy you love your necklace, it looks so beautiful on you! It was an honor creating this for you!

Custom Order for Emily, Skeleton Key Necklace, Antique Vintage Key, Key To My Heart, Copper Raven Charm, Witch Jewelry, Rosary Style

Custom Order for Emily, Skeleton Key Necklace, Antique Vintage Key, Key To My Heart, Copper Raven Charm, Witch Jewelry, Rosary Style
Jennifer on Aug 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Very nice. Small but lovely

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Decoration, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Made to Order

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Decoration, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Made to Order
Heather on Aug 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

The piece is absolutely beautiful.

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 9 Inch, Front Door Wreath, Purple & Black Cotton Ribbons, Pagan, Housewarming Gift, Mossy Wreath, Made to Order

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 9 Inch, Front Door Wreath, Purple & Black Cotton Ribbons, Pagan, Housewarming Gift, Mossy Wreath, Made to Order
Michelle on Jul 14, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

beautiful sound - perfect for our front door. this is my second order - I will be back again. highly recommend this seller & shop

Witch Bells, Threshold Doorway Protection, Tin Bells, Recycled Silk Ribbons, Altar Spirit Bells, Ward off Evil, Clear Energy, Simple Rustic

Witch Bells, Threshold Doorway Protection, Tin Bells, Recycled Silk Ribbons, Altar Spirit Bells, Ward off Evil, Clear Energy, Simple Rustic
Etsy buyer on Jun 20, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

If perfect were possible, this charming work would be in that class of its own. The tree of life, full of charm and good spirits, feels welcoming and real on my front door. The size is just right, too, and the natural materials bid warm wishes. I love it!

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 5 Inch Mossy Wreath, Recycled Green Ribbons, Home & Door Protection, Doorknob, Housewarming Gifts, Made to Order

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 5 Inch Mossy Wreath, Recycled Green Ribbons, Home & Door Protection, Doorknob, Housewarming Gifts, Made to Order
Etsy buyer on Jun 8, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Absolutely beautiful and well made. It was exactly as pictured, but better. Is now hanging on my front door. Thank you for all you do.

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 9 Inch, Front Door Wreath, Purple & Black Cotton Ribbons, Pagan, Housewarming Gift, Mossy Wreath, Made to Order

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 9 Inch, Front Door Wreath, Purple & Black Cotton Ribbons, Pagan, Housewarming Gift, Mossy Wreath, Made to Order

About TheMagicKeyCompany

The Key to Magical Creations

Sales 1,430

On Etsy since 2019

The Key to Magical Creations

Magical Witchy Creations

Hi!! I'm Joni Rae Doyle and created this little shop in 2019. The Magic Key Company unites vintage skeleton keys and other pieces, along with natural found and foraged organic matter into magical creations.

I am a resident of Door County, Wisconsin, all of these magical pieces are created in my home studio. I search antique shops for vintage skeleton keys and beads, and walk the woods and shoreline of Lake Michigan searching for natural treasures to use in my artwork.

Shop members

Joni

Owner, Designer

A resident of Door County, Wisconsin, all of these magical pieces are created in my home studio. I search antique shops for vintage beads & skeleton keys & walk the shores of Lake Michigan searching for natural treasures to use in my artwork.

Shop policies

Last updated on May 17, 2020

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Home Decor

Buy Outdoor Wood Decor Online Abdallah - US Shop Guitar Acrylic Painting Sound Horn Sign for Sale Shop Miniature Bee Hive Buy Rose Tarlow Furniture Online Buy Jockey Bookends Online Buy David Ackerman Online Buy Ornaments 2024 Online Buy Clay Angel Ornament Online

Kitchen & Dining

Buy Portmeirion Botanic Garden Mug Online Buy Seto Plate Online

Canvas & Surfaces

Silver Alphabet Bead Clipart Font for Friendship Bracelets - Canvas & Surfaces

Storage & Organization

Brushed Nickel Shelf Rail - US

Shopping

Buy Mvp Football Ornament Online Buy Gift Google Spreadsheet Online

Gender Neutral Adult Clothing

Buy Ethan Klein Online

Necklaces

Buy Jade Cube Necklace Online

TheMagicKeyCompany

Featured items

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Décor, Brass Sleigh Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Small Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic Witchy

Handmade Autumn Witch Bells, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Everlasting Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Plaid Ribbons

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Decoration, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Made to Order

Witch Bells, Threshold Doorway Protection, Tin Bells, Recycled Silk Ribbons, Altar Spirit Bells, Ward off Evil, Clear Energy, Simple Rustic

Autumnal Wreath, Colorful Leaves and Berries, Grapevine, Woodsy Earthy Rustic, Small Fall Door Hanger, Samhain Pagan, Harvest Witchy Decor

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Décor, Brass Sleigh Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Small Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic Witchy

Handmade Autumn Witch Bells, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Everlasting Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Plaid Ribbons

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Decoration, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Made to Order

Witch Bells, Threshold Doorway Protection, Tin Bells, Recycled Silk Ribbons, Altar Spirit Bells, Ward off Evil, Clear Energy, Simple Rustic

Autumnal Wreath, Colorful Leaves and Berries, Grapevine, Woodsy Earthy Rustic, Small Fall Door Hanger, Samhain Pagan, Harvest Witchy Decor

All items

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Décor, Brass Sleigh Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Small Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic Witchy

Handmade Witch Bells, Doorknob Hanger, Grapevine Wreath, Butterfly, Green Earth Witch, Renewal & Protection, Pagan Decor, Housewarming Gift

Nautical Witch Bells, Lake Michigan Driftwood, Door County WI Sailing, Beach House Decor, Bronze Medallion, Vintage Skeleton Key

Autumnal Wreath, Colorful Leaves and Berries, Grapevine, Woodsy Earthy Rustic, Small Fall Door Hanger, Samhain Pagan, Harvest Witchy Decor

Autumn Witch Bells, Fall Doorknob Decoration, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Made to Order

Handmade Autumn Witch Bells, Acorn Bells, Door County Pine Cones, Everlasting Fall Leaves, Door Hanger, Woodsy Rustic, Plaid Ribbons

Witch Bells, Threshold Doorway Protection, Tin Bells, Recycled Silk Ribbons, Altar Spirit Bells, Ward off Evil, Clear Energy, Simple Rustic

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 9 Inch Mossy Wreath, Purple Green Moss, Cotton Ribbons, Pagan Wiccan Decor, Housewarming Gift, Made to Order

Tree of Life Witch Bells, 5 inch Doorknob Mini Wreath, Rainbow Dreaming Tree, Housewarming Gift, Colorful Mossy Tree, Pride, Made to Order

Grapevine Wreath, Purple Hydrangea, One Sided, Asymmetrical Wreath, Everlasting Greenery, Front Door Decor, Housewarming Gifts, Green Witch

Yule Witch Bells, Doorknob Hanger, Solstice Pagan Décor, Wisconsin Pine Cones, Rustic Woodsy Christmas, Small Holiday Wreath, Burlap Ribbons

Yule Witch Bells, Solstice Pagan Décor, Small Holiday Winter Wreath, Rusty Sleigh Bell, Pine Cones, Christmas Doorknob Hanger, MADE TO ORDER

Yule Witch Bells, Solstice Pagan Décor, Small Holiday Winter Wreath, Bells and Star, Rustic Woodsy, Christmas Doorknob Hanger, MADE TO ORDER

Yule Witch Bells, Solstice Pagan Décor, Wisconsin Pine Cones, Jingle Sleigh Bells, Long Door Hanger, Rustic Woodsy Christmas, Winter Witch

Yule Witch Bells, Solstice Pagan Décor, Wisconsin Pine Cones, Jingle Sleigh Bells, Doorknob Hanger, Rustic Woodsy Christmas, MADE TO ORDER

Yule, Solstice Witch Bells, Doorknob Hanger, Small Door Swag, Wisconsin Pine Cones, Sleigh Bells, Rustic Woodsy Christmas, MADE TO ORDER

Yule Witch Bells, Solstice Pagan Décor, Wisconsin Pine Cones, Sleigh Bells, Doorknob Hanger, Rustic Woodsy Christmas, Holiday Jingle Bells

Vintage Skeleton Key with Blue Kyanite Blade – Opportunity & Protection Charm, in Black Velvet Pouch with Crescent Moon and Stars, Talisman

Vintage Skeleton Key with Mini Selenite Stick, Opportunity & Protection Charm, Black Velvet Pouch with Crescent Moon Stars, Talisman Amulet

Vintage Skeleton Key with Clear Quartz Crystal Point – Opportunity & Protection Charm, in Black Velvet Pouch with Crescent Moon and Stars

Vintage Skeleton Key with Amethyst Crystal Point, Opportunity & Protection Charm, in Black Velvet Pouch Crescent Moon Stars, Talisman Amulet

Vintage Skeleton Key with Smoky Quartz Crystal Point – Protection Talisman in Velvet Moon & Stars Pouch, Spellwork, Charms, Amulets

Santa’s Magic Key, Choose Your Own Skeleton Key & Ribbon Design, Silver Bronze Copper Gunmetal Finish, Festive Christmas Ribbons, Ornaments

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Gift Tag, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Ornaments for Men

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Church Key, Stocking Stuffer, Rustic Copper, Ornaments for Men

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Copper and Red, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Ornaments for Men

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Copper and Red, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Ornaments for Men

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Buffalo Plaid, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Ornaments for Men

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Copper and Red, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Ornaments for Men

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Copper Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Ornaments for Men, Ribbon

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Silver Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Church Key, Stocking Stuffer, Snowflake Ribbon, Men's Gifts

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Silver Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Church Key, Stocking Stuffer, Gifts Under 20, Men's Gifts

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Silver Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Silver & Red, Stocking Stuffer, Ornaments for Men, Ribbons

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Silver Reindeer Key, Bottle Opener, Buffalo Plaid Ribbon, Stocking Stuffer, Beer Lover Gifts

Santa’s Magic Key, Christmas Tree Ornament, Skeleton Key, Snowflake Charm, Gifts for Kids, Stocking Stuffer, Secret Santa, Believe in Magic

Key to My Heart, Valentine Ornament, Keyring, Love Heart Charm, Silver Skeleton Key, Love Keychain, Czech Glass, Swarovski Crystals

Announcement

Reviews

About TheMagicKeyCompany

Shop members

Joni

Shop policies

Shipping

Customs and import taxes

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations