TheWaywardHunters

Rolesville, North Carolina

4.6k
 Sales

5.0 (1.6k)

9 years
on Etsy

5.0 (1.6k)

4.6k
 sales

9 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

4.6k
 Sales

5.0 (1.6k)

9 years
on Etsy

5.0 (1.6k)

4.6k
 sales

9 years
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

4622 Sales

1456 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jul 9, 2024

Contact shop owner

Ashley DeForge

Reviews

5.0 (1608)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Josey on Jul 30, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

looks just like baby

Supernatural Baby Car Pin

Supernatural Baby Car Pin
Pat on Jul 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Perfect condition, love it!! (ゝω・´★)

Supernatural Baby Car Pin

Supernatural Baby Car Pin
Teddy on Jul 17, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Love this! I was looking for a semi-subtle way to show off my avatar love, and this was perfect. it has a proud place on my work hat. It arrived a little earlier than expected, which was very nice. I look forward to ordering from this shop again!

The Blue Spirit Mask | ATLA Style Pin | ATLA Lapel Pin - NEW Hard Enamel

The Blue Spirit Mask | ATLA Style Pin | ATLA Lapel Pin - NEW Hard Enamel
Anthony on Jul 14, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Awesome pin, great quality. included a cool striker!

Supernatural Angel Blade

Supernatural Angel Blade
Etsy buyer on Jul 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This pin looks great and I love the crossover. The order arrived on time and was hassle-free. Thanks!

Jasmine Dragon Fine Teas | ATLA inspired pin

Jasmine Dragon Fine Teas | ATLA inspired pin
Etsy buyer on Jun 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I love it! The card it was attached to was really cool and high quality as well.

Supernatural Angel Blade

Supernatural Angel Blade
Ev on Apr 13, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Love the pin. Great quality and great colors!

The Blue Spirit Mask | ATLA Style Pin | ATLA Lapel Pin - NEW Hard Enamel

The Blue Spirit Mask | ATLA Style Pin | ATLA Lapel Pin - NEW Hard Enamel
Etsy buyer on Aug 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Seller was super communicative and helpful, and the pin is perfection! Thank you!

Supernatural Scooby Castiel Pin

Supernatural Scooby Castiel Pin
Daniel on Jul 28, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great quality pin, the owner was extremely polite and kept me informed about delays with the postal service.

Classic 1 High Chicago Red Sneaker - High-Top Sneaker Hard Enamel Pin Inspired by Classic Basketball Shoe!

Classic 1 High Chicago Red Sneaker - High-Top Sneaker Hard Enamel Pin Inspired by Classic Basketball Shoe!
Montana on Jul 18, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Absolutely STUNNING pin. It’s hard to find angel-anything that isn’t cherubs, but also, Castiel is my favorite so💗 all-in-all, it checks all the boxes.

Supernatural Castiel's Wings Pin

Supernatural Castiel's Wings Pin

About TheWaywardHunters

Fandom pins based on your favorite shows and games!

Sales 4,622

On Etsy since 2017

Fandom pins based on your favorite shows and games!

Looking for our One Piece Pins? They were removed and now are only available through www.thewaywardhunters.com

All of our pins are back! - Check out all of our new pins, patches, stickers, & MORE! We are now trying to update and add new pins weekly.

So we started this shop as a Supernatural themed shop, but! as our love for different shows grew and our shop grew so much we've been expanding as much as we can so here are all of our fanart pins along with some original drawings we also turned into pins!

Thank you to everyone who has liked, favorited, and shopped with us for allowing us to make so many pins! CHECK OUT OUR WEBSITE FOR OUR FULL SELECTION OF PINS www.thewaywardhunters.com

Instagram

shop-website

Shop policies

Last updated on Dec 31, 2021

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy

Costume Accessories

Buy Hereditary Crown Online

Raw Materials

Buy Gnarled Wood Online

Docking & Stands

Buy Echo Dot Stand Clock Online

Home Decor

Black Branches for Sale TheElvenCritter

Hair Accessories

Mushroom Hair Pin - US

Gender Neutral Adult Clothing

Shop Prince Long Sleeve Tees

Storage & Organization

Buy Small Foam Case Online

Video Games

Custom Case - Super Smash Bros Melee - No Disc - No Manual - GameCube

Beads Gems & Cabochons

Buy Fang Gems Online

Womens Clothing

Shop Bagatelle Vest Buy Professional Tutu Online Buy Sage Green Dress Long Sleeves Women Online

Kitchen & Dining

Buy Ice Cream Scoop Favors Online

Collectibles

Brevettato Cigarette - US

Food & Drink

Buy Jolly Rancher Candy Online

Necklaces

Acorn Capsule - US

Fabric & Notions

Buy Embroidery Floral Patches Online

TheWaywardHunters

Featured items

Coffee Addict Pin - Skeleton Coffee & Iced Coffee Enamel Pin

Psychic Boy Anime Inspired Hard Enamel Pin - Glitter Power Aura Hard Enamel Pin - Best Scene Mob

Spoiler Alert - Crystal Ball Spiritual Fortune Telling Pin - Witchy Enamel Pin

Lovecraftian Monster | HP Lovecraft Inspired Monster Pin

All items

Psychic Boy Anime Inspired Hard Enamel Pin - Glitter Power Aura Hard Enamel Pin - Best Scene Mob

Psychic Boy Anime Inspired Iron-on Patch - Psycho Helmet Leader - Psycho Powers Boy Iron On Patch

Anime Hunter Clown Eyes Iron On Patch - Anime Manga Enamel Pins - Anime Iron On Patch

Classic 1 High Chicago Red Sneaker - High-Top Sneaker Hard Enamel Pin Inspired by Classic Basketball Shoe!

Halloween Pumpkin Guts Hard Enamel Pin – Quirky Humor Lapel Pin

R.I.P. My Guts Pumpkin Enamel Pin – Halloween Humor Lapel Pin

Love's Elixir COMBO: Pink Heart-shaped Enamel Pin and Pa tchof Enchantment - Love Hard Enamel Pin - Magical Potion Pin & Patch Combo

Love's Elixir: Pink Heart-shaped Iron-on Patch of Enchantment - Love Patch - Magical Potion Patch

Love's Elixir: Pink Heart-shaped Enamel Pin of Enchantment - Love Hard Enamel Pin - Magical Potion Pin

Cute Blood Villain Anime Girl Stickers - Anime Waifu - Crazy anime girl - Anime Manga Stickers

Coffee Addict Sticker - Skeleton Coffee & Iced Coffee Stickers - Coffee Themed Sticker

Anime Hunter Clown Eyes Holographic Sticker - Anime Manga Stickers - Hunter Anime Holo Sticker - 2 Stickers

Blind Anime Sorcerer - Powerful White Haired Teacher - Anime Manga Cute Enamel Pins

Cute Blood Villain Anime Girl - Anime Waifu - Crazy anime girl - Anime Manga Cute Enamel Pins

Pirate Rubber Boy & Pirate Hunter COMBO SET - Anime Manga Cute Enamel Pins - Anime Pirates Pins

Anime Hunter Clown Eyes Pin - Anime Manga Enamel Pins - Anime Hard Enamel Pin

Pirate Hunter - Anime Manga Cute Enamel Pins - World's greatest swordsman - Anime Pirates - Moss head lapel pin

Pirate Rubber Boy - Anime Manga Cute Enamel Pins - Anime Pirates

2 Supernatural Castiel's Wings Stickers - Angel Wings Sticker

Lovecraftian Monster | HP Lovecraft Inspired Monster Sticker | Skull Octopus |

The Blue Spirit Mask | Avatar Inspired Sticker | ATLA Sticker

2 Psychic Boy Anime Inspired Holographic Stickers - Psycho Helmet Leader - Psycho Powers Boy Holo Sticker - 2 Stickers

Psychic Boy Anime Inspired Hard Enamel Pin - Psycho Helmet Leader - Psycho Powers Boy Glitter Enamel Pin

Morning Ritual - Coffee Skull Pin - Hard Enamel Lapel Pin - Coffee Pin

Jasmine Dragon Fine Teas | Atla style Enamel Pin & Keychain Combo!

Jasmine Dragon Fine Teas | ATLA Style Keychain

Coffee Addict Keychain - Skeleton Coffee & Iced Coffee Keychain

You're Too Close Pin: A Humorous Reminder of Personal Space - Funny Enamel Pin

The Blue Spirit Mask | ATLA Style Pin | ATLA Lapel Pin - NEW Hard Enamel

Spoiler Alert - Crystal Ball Spiritual Fortune Telling Pin - Witchy Enamel Pin

Steamboat Luffy Pin - One Piece X Steamboat Willie Inspired Anime Lapel Pin

Supernatural Castiel's Wings Pin and Patch Combo - Angel Wings Lapel Pin and Iron-on Patch

Supernatural Castiel's Wings Patch - Angel Wings Iron-on Patch

Skull Astronaut Pin and Patch Combo - Space Themed Pin and Iron-On Patch

Skull Astronaut Patch - Space Themed Iron-On Patch

Skull Astronaut Pin - Space Themed Enamel Pin

Announcement

Reviews

About TheWaywardHunters

Shop policies

Shipping

Customs and import taxes

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations