MythJewelryNYC

Brooklyn, New York

363
 Sales

4.8 (128)

6 years
on Etsy

4.8 (128)

363
 sales

6 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

363
 Sales

4.8 (128)

6 years
on Etsy

4.8 (128)

363
 sales

6 years
on Etsy

MythJewelryNYC is taking a short break

Note from shop owner taking a break!
All recent orders have been shipped, I’ll still be here to answer any questions if needed.
thanks! :)💖

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Dec 16, 2025

taking a break!
All recent orders have been shipped, I’ll still be here to answer any questions if needed.
thanks! :)💖

Contact shop owner

Rachel Marquez

Reviews

4.8 (128)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Alaura on Dec 25, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

Great quality and great stocking stuffer

Neon Green Black Flame Earrings, Pink, Goth, Punk, Rock Alt Alternative Style Fire Heavy Metal Emo Witch skater Edgy Music Festival, jewelry

Neon Green Black Flame Earrings, Pink, Goth, Punk, Rock Alt Alternative Style Fire Heavy Metal Emo Witch skater Edgy Music Festival, jewelry
Alise on Dec 7, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

They look gorgeous and the seller is very friendly. Will buy from again.

Neon Green Black Flame Earrings, Pink, Goth, Punk, Rock Alt Alternative Style Fire Heavy Metal Emo Witch skater Edgy Music Festival, jewelry

Neon Green Black Flame Earrings, Pink, Goth, Punk, Rock Alt Alternative Style Fire Heavy Metal Emo Witch skater Edgy Music Festival, jewelry
Alise on Dec 7, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

Wonderful all around!

Snake Skeleton Earrings Tattoo Style Alt Grunge Punk Goth Gothic Emo Edgy Halloween Alternative Skull Y2K 90’s Streetwear creepy serpent

Snake Skeleton Earrings Tattoo Style Alt Grunge Punk Goth Gothic Emo Edgy Halloween Alternative Skull Y2K 90’s Streetwear creepy serpent
Cynthia on Oct 10, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

These are great earrings. I am a Dia de Los Muertos aficionado and I wanted something to wear to the celebrations. These are very lightweight for their size and the gold accents have a nice sheen and are not “bright” or garish and I love the transparent red heart. Winner!

Rioja, Sacred Heart translucent Red Gold Earrings Virgin Mary Lady Guadalupe, Mexican, Latina Jewelry, Flaming heart Jesus, Milagro, Ex Voto

Rioja, Sacred Heart translucent Red Gold Earrings Virgin Mary Lady Guadalupe, Mexican, Latina Jewelry, Flaming heart Jesus, Milagro, Ex Voto
Amanda on Sep 30, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

The girls love these!!!!!!! Love from ATX

Rioja, Sacred Heart translucent Red Gold Earrings Virgin Mary Lady Guadalupe, Mexican, Latina Jewelry, Flaming heart Jesus, Milagro, Ex Voto

Rioja, Sacred Heart translucent Red Gold Earrings Virgin Mary Lady Guadalupe, Mexican, Latina Jewelry, Flaming heart Jesus, Milagro, Ex Voto
Anna on Sep 2, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

These are so pretty in person! The shipping was fast too!

Cyber Butterfly Hoop Earrings Silver Chrome Y2K punk goth alt Emo edgy gothic cyberpunk retro music fest mariposa choker mirror

Cyber Butterfly Hoop Earrings Silver Chrome Y2K punk goth alt Emo edgy gothic cyberpunk retro music fest mariposa choker mirror
Rhiannon on Aug 27, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

I couldn’t love these more! The seller was very kind and threw in a little bonus. They’re one of my favorite pairs of earrings! 🥰

Sacred Heart Neon Flames, Statement earrings Virgin Mary Guadalupe Mexican Latina Jewelry Flaming heart of Jesus Milagro rave music festival

Sacred Heart Neon Flames, Statement earrings Virgin Mary Guadalupe Mexican Latina Jewelry Flaming heart of Jesus Milagro rave music festival
Shrii on Aug 24, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

So unique and cute, I love dragons especially ones in this style so it was perfect. Although I do wish they were a little heavier so they didn't hang at a weird angle. I've already gotten compliments on them for my first time wearing them!

The Moon, Crescent moon with Gold Dragon Earrings, Serpent, Astrology, Wiccan, Witch, Witchy, Horoscope, mystic, mythical, moon phases

The Moon, Crescent moon with Gold Dragon Earrings, Serpent, Astrology, Wiccan, Witch, Witchy, Horoscope, mystic, mythical, moon phases
Kaitlyn on Aug 14, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

They work really well! They’re easy to put in, and look great! The colors are very vibrant too!

Neon Green Black Flame Earrings, Pink, Goth, Punk, Rock Alt Alternative Style Fire Heavy Metal Emo Witch skater Edgy Music Festival, jewelry

Neon Green Black Flame Earrings, Pink, Goth, Punk, Rock Alt Alternative Style Fire Heavy Metal Emo Witch skater Edgy Music Festival, jewelry
Rachel on Aug 10, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

I love it!! The seller was flexible with my requests and it’s exactly what I wanted! I hope they bring back the listing eventually so I can order more in the future 🙏🏻

Custom Personalized Dog tags Cat tags Pet gifts Customizable laser printed Acrylic Unique Gift *** Please read description for details***

Custom Personalized Dog tags Cat tags Pet gifts Customizable laser printed Acrylic Unique Gift *** Please read description for details***

About MythJewelryNYC

Jewelry For Muses. Inspired by magic, folklore and myth

Sales 363

On Etsy since 2020

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Jewelry For Muses. Inspired by magic, folklore and myth

Unique Jewelry & Handmade Mexican Folk Art.

Shop members

Rachel Marquez

Owner, Designer

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.