Stuck in the Late 90's Since 2007

Chicago, Illinois | 2156 Sales


Stuck in the Late 90's Since 2007

Chicago, Illinois 2156 Sales On Etsy since 2007

5 out of 5 stars (857)

KittenSurprise is taking a short break


Note from shop owner On vacation! Be back July 23rd!

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Jul 15, 2019

On vacation! Be back July 23rd!

Marjorie W.

Contact shop owner

Marjorie W.


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
quality 65 shipping 159 customer service 105


It's a Vintage Valentine's Day Pop Up! Kitten Surprise will be showcasing our best fresh vintage, along with top picks from Quasinu & Luvsick Plus! Get ready for Spring, buy yourself something gorgeous for Galentine's, or just have fun and stop by!
New in stock- vintage grab bags! We've paired some classic flicks with some corresponding vintage for the ultimate gift! Perfect presents for your bff!
View all 6 updates


Stuck in the Late 90’s Since 2007

Kitten Surprise began in 2007, has taken over my life, and I wouldn't have it any other way!

Kitten Surprise is an advocate for the environment. The average human throws away over 80 pounds of textiles a year, and it's getting worse every year with the influx of Fast Fashion. By shopping vintage, you're doing a small part in keeping valuable items away from landfills while looking fresh & cool. It's the best of both worlds!

We use recycled packaging. You may receive your item in a reused Amazon mailer or box, or something similar. Our bubble wrap, tissue paper & other shipping materials are also second hand.

Shop members

  • Marjorie

    Owner, Designer, Curator

    Marjorie Woolard is the founder, designer and curator for Kitten Surprise. She is the idea girl behind everything, brought back to earth by Nick's logic.

Shop policies

Last updated on September 29, 2018
NOTICE: We are out of the country until October 10th. All orders will be shipped on October 11th. However, you can find most of our pieces at Beehive Chicago while we are away! 2501 W. Chicago Ave, Chicago, Il, 60647

We specialize in making vintage wearable and fun for all shapes & sizes.

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
  • Other Method
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept exchanges
Contact me within: 3 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 7 days of delivery
I don't accept returns or cancellations
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
The following items can't be returned or exchanged
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:
  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Perishable products (like food or flowers)
  • Digital downloads
  • Intimate items (for health/hygiene reasons)
  • Items on sale
Returns and exchange details
We understand that shopping online can be a risk - especially with vintage! That being said, we do our very best to provide accurate measurements and sizing information. We recommend using these measurements instead of a tag size (like large or size 8) because tag sizes are not universal whereas measurements are.

We do not accept returns but you may send your item back for store credit. Just contact us within 24 hours of receiving your order!
We accept Direct Checkout via Etsy.
We ship 24-48 hours after your order is placed, excluding Sundays and Holidays. Rush shipping is available at checkout.
Additional policies and FAQs

Size 0
waist: 23"-25", hips: 33"-35"
Size 2
waist: 26", hips: 36"
Size 4
waist: 27", hips: 37"
Size 6
waist: 28", hips: 38"
Size 8
waist: 29", hips: 39"
Size 10
waist: 30". hips: 40"
Size 12
waist: 31.5"-34.5", hips: 41.5"-44.5"

waist: 24-25", hips: 34 - 35"
waist: 26-27", hips: 36-37"
waist: 28-29", hips: 38-39"
waist: 31.5-33", hips: 41.5-43"
waist: 34", hips: 44"

More information

Last updated on Oct 2, 2017
Frequently asked questions
Gift wrapping and packaging

We do not offer gift wrapping, but we are more than happy to add in a note or a small card if the item is a gift. Just let us know upon checkout!

Care instructions

I hand wash and line/air dry all of my vintage items unless they require dry cleaning. I recommend doing the same or washing your items on a gentle cycle in cool water.

Do you combine shipping?

Yes! We will package your items together as effectively as possible and refund you any shipping overages. Feel free to contact us prior to buying your items for a shipping quote, too!

Can I pickup my item in Chicago?

Yes! We offer local pickup in two places in Chicago!

BEEHIVE CHICAGO: located at 2501 W Chicago Ave. Open Wednesday through Sunday, 12-7. Use the coupon code BEEHIVE and you will receive free shipping. and we will confirm with you when your order is ready to be picked up!

3415 Fullerton, open Wednesday through Sunday 12-8. Use coupon code FLAIR to receive free shipping, and we will confirm with you when your order is ready to be picked up!