SurprisingFindings

Nonprofit: Saint John's Foundation [Community Impact]

Milwaukee, Wisconsin

| 448 Sales |

SurprisingFindings is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

Average review rating is 4.8 or higher

SurprisingFindings

Contact

Following shop Follow shop

Announcement Saint John's On The Lake is a vibrant nonprofit retirement community in Milwaukee, WI. Many residents have downsized from a house to an apartment, and on that journey they've found vintage treasures in their closets, attics and basements. Many of these items came from their mother's and grandmother's treasure boxes. It is our mission to find new homes for these items while directing all proceeds into our Community Impact Fund.
Be sure to visit often as new items are added frequently. Happy hunting!

Announcement

Last updated on Jan 24, 2024

Saint John's On The Lake is a vibrant nonprofit retirement community in Milwaukee, WI. Many residents have downsized from a house to an apartment, and on that journey they've found vintage treasures in their closets, attics and basements. Many of these items came from their mother's and grandmother's treasure boxes. It is our mission to find new homes for these items while directing all proceeds into our Community Impact Fund.
Be sure to visit often as new items are added frequently. Happy hunting!

Contact shop owner

448 Sales

175 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Reviews

Average item review

(165)

Scott on Apr 22, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Great from start to finish.

SurprisingFindings responded on Apr 23, 2024

Thank you very much, Scott!

Movado Ladies 14K Gold Watch w/ 10K Gold Filled Speidel Mesh Bracelet Band - 17 Jewel Bearing Watch - Needs New Battery

Movado Ladies 14K Gold Watch w/ 10K Gold Filled Speidel Mesh Bracelet Band - 17 Jewel Bearing Watch - Needs New Battery
Kathy on Apr 20, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Exactly what I was looking for. Thank you!!! Great quality, fast shipping and good customer service.

SurprisingFindings responded on Apr 23, 2024

Thank you Kathy, we're happy you found what you were looking for!

Lot of 65 Antique Wooden Thread Spools - Various Shapes & Sizes

Lot of 65 Antique Wooden Thread Spools - Various Shapes & Sizes
Rain on Apr 13, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Very cute! Hard to find anything with a coati.

SurprisingFindings responded on Apr 15, 2024

Agreed, this coati charm is adorable! We're glad you're happy with it, thank you for the review!

H. Stern South American Coati Pewter Charm Pendant w/ Original Paper & Envelope

H. Stern South American Coati Pewter Charm Pendant w/ Original Paper & Envelope
Angela on Apr 7, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

I really like this set. Thank you.

SurprisingFindings responded on Apr 9, 2024

Thank you for your reviews Angela, we're pleased that you're happy with your beautiful earrings and pin!

Special! FRESHWATER PEARLS cling to a feathery swirl gold overlay in this DISTINCTIVE pin and earring set!

Special! FRESHWATER PEARLS cling to a feathery swirl gold overlay in this DISTINCTIVE pin and earring set!
Angela on Apr 7, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

I am very happy with my purchase.

Magnificent Round Sterling Silver Clip Earrings! Onyx and Mother of Pearl teardrops separated by 8 Marcasites

Magnificent Round Sterling Silver Clip Earrings! Onyx and Mother of Pearl teardrops separated by 8 Marcasites
maureen on Apr 3, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

beautiful doll that my grand daughter will love

SurprisingFindings responded on Apr 3, 2024

It warms our hearts to hear that Sarah The Doll will have a new friend, thank you Maureen!

1990's Crolly 18" Sarah Red Hair Doll w/ Irish Claddagh Brooch & Wooden Stand

1990's Crolly 18" Sarah Red Hair Doll w/ Irish Claddagh Brooch & Wooden Stand
Julie on Apr 2, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

A+++++ Excellent service, Fast Delivery 🚚

SurprisingFindings responded on Apr 3, 2024

Thank you Julie, we strive for excellence! Happy to hear your treasure arrived safe and sound, your new sugar bowl is a beauty!

Bianca Lidded Sugar Bowl - Wedgwood Bone China Made in England (Williamsburg Mark)

Bianca Lidded Sugar Bowl - Wedgwood Bone China Made in England (Williamsburg Mark)
sterrlingsilverr on Mar 28, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

love the bracelet, classic and feminine

SurprisingFindings responded on Apr 3, 2024

We're delighted that you love your new gorgeous bracelet, thank you for your review!

Vintage 18k Gold Italian Heart Charm Bracelet - Made in Arezzo in the 1900's

Vintage 18k Gold Italian Heart Charm Bracelet - Made in Arezzo in the 1900's
Emily on Feb 11, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Such a beautiful item in wonderful condition for a great price. Thank you, I love it!

SurprisingFindings responded on Feb 12, 2024

Thank you Emily, we're so happy that you love your new treasure!

Vintage Marshall Field's Sterling Silver Collectible Pie Server

Vintage Marshall Field's Sterling Silver Collectible Pie Server
nirelle on Jan 21, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Interesting light weight African clay beads. Reasonably priced. The earrings are too big for me so will be a nice gift. Necklace should look nice with simple hoop earrings. Vendor a pleasure to work with.

SurprisingFindings responded on Jan 23, 2024

Thank you, you were a pleasure to work with as well :)

KAZURI BEAD Necklace and Single Bead Drop Earrings, HANDMADE in Kenya!

KAZURI BEAD Necklace and Single Bead Drop Earrings, HANDMADE in Kenya!

About SurprisingFindings

Sales 448

On Etsy since 2015

Old Treasures Newly Found

shop-website

Shop members

Paulina

Manager

Production partners

Saint John's On The Lake

Milwaukee, WI

We are a vintage and antique online thrift shop. All our items are donated to us from residents that live at an upscale retirement community.

Shop policies

Last updated on Jun 7, 2022

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

Seller details

View seller details

Captcha failed to load. Try using a different browser or disabling ad blockers.

SurprisingFindings

Nonprofit: Saint John's Foundation [Community Impact]

Announcement

Featured items

Items

Bayanihan Sterling Silver Bracelet

Moorcroft Pottery Lidded Dresser Jar - Anemone Pattern On Blue

Lladro Shepherdess with Dove Porcelain Figurine #4460

All Items

White KPM Urbino Sauciere / Gravy Boat with Attached Underplate

White KPM Urbino White Divided Server 9 3/4"

White KPM Urbino Sugar & Cream Set

Vintage Small Steiff Cocker Spaniel Toy Dog with Tag and Collar

Vintage Steiff Small Tabby Cat with Original Bell, Collar, Tags, and Bow

Native American Small Rabbit Pin Sterling Silver Signed WIL

Rare Vermeil Filigree Link Sterling Bracelet with Cloisonné Flowers & Vines

Crown Devon Fieldings John Peel Fox Hunt Pitcher

Moorcroft Pottery Lidded Dresser Jar - Anemone Pattern On Blue

Lladro Shepherdess with Dove Porcelain Figurine #4460

Rare 1898 & 1899 Antique Children's Magazine - Our Little Folks' Magazine Chicago IL

Vintage Cherub Angel Empty Perfume Bottle with Stopper

Antique Jeweled Gilt Vanity Hand Mirror - Stamped "Apollo"

Children Hugging Dog - Royal Copenhagen Porcelain Figurine #707

My Love - Romantic English Bone China Figurine of Young Woman with Flower, Royal Doulton HN 2339

Bayanihan Sterling Silver Bracelet

Set of 7 Excellent Vintage Arabia Porcelain Cups & Saucers - Made In Finland 1949-1964

H. Stern Sugarloaf Mountain Pewter Charm Pendant w/ Original Paper & Envelope

H. Stern Pewter Pendant Frevo Umbrella 20" Necklace w/ Original Paper & Envelope

H. Stern Frevo Umbrella Pewter Charm Pendant w/ Original Paper & Envelope

H. Stern Berimbau Sekitulege Pewter Charm Pendant w/ Original Paper & Envelope

H. Stern Water Lily Star-Shaped Pewter Pendant w/ Original Paper & Envelope

Rare Moroccan Berber Pendant with 3 Antique Moroccan Silver Coin Dangles

Set of 4 Vintage 9" German Collectable Dolls

Antique Victorian Gold Filled Etched Pin Brooch

Sterling Silver Enamel Matador Pin Brooch

Vintage Gorham Cordial Mini Goblet Cups - 955 Sterling Silver in Original Case

Vintage Campbell Soup Kids Dolls (They Squeak!)

NAPIER screw back EARRINGS ~ Black oval dome stone surrounded by 22 rhinestones

Vintage Brass Scissor-shaped Candle Snuffer

Vintage Wallace Sterling Silver Sugar Spoon

Vintage Royal Dux Blanc De Chine Mother & Baby Child Figurine

Whiting Sterling Silver Serving Fork

LIMOGES COVERED Round Dish

Lot of 10: HOT WHEELS by MATTEL Inc. (one mystery redline)

Lot of 3 Cars: MATCHBOX to ROADCHAMPS to SS

Reviews

About SurprisingFindings

Shop members

Paulina

Production partners

Shop policies

Shipping

Customs and import taxes

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations

Seller details